• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Tiger mums and gifted children. Analysis of the ideas of Amy Chua

Extracts from this document...


´╗┐Patricia Mellany Jensen 3.B.Engelsk stil nr. 1D. 2/9-2012 Tiger-mums and gifted children Methods of upbringing differ depending on the parents, whose methods depend on their values, which again depend on their cultural background. It makes sense that two different continents like the Western and Asian continents have completely different cultures. The Asian children are said to be overperforming themselves in terms of knowledge and education, since they achieve extremely high grades in Western schools. This is the cause for great debates in the Western continent concerning the Asian children and their parent?s methods. Amy Chua provides her opinion as to ?Why Chinese mothers are superior?, how a misunderstanding between the two continents exists and how Western parents are on the wrong path. But who is really superior? And can we all have gifted children? Amy Chua is a person with a great amount of ethos; she is a professor at Yale Law School in USA, which is of course marked in her article. ...read more.


The purpose of this is for the Western mother to feel more connected (and not dissociate herself) from the tiger-mums she will meet herself. The tiger-mum also narrows down boring logos information in form of numbers, so that she can involve more interesting personal stories (pathos) from her everyday life. Tiger-mum?s methods surely seem tempting and promising, but the future is hard to foresee if we were all to become tiger-mums. The increase in the number of intelligent and cultured children would mean more competition, since the intelligence and working standard would rise and therefore more would be demanded, so only few can achieve excellence. This would increase the pressure upon the children, who in theory continuously would be paced forward. This would obviously demand more of the children?s time and probably result in an unhealthy physical and emotional circle. If everyone wants to excel, even though everyone cannot excel, because then the point of excellence would just be average, children would really feel low self-esteem. ...read more.


If the child wants to give up, the parent should express disappointment because one should never give up on a personal goal. A personal goal would also make the child more interested in reaching it. It is not someone else?s goal, so we should be able to find the strongest character here. We can all become tiger-mums like Amy Chua, but we cannot all become the best, since it would just increase the average level and result in low self-esteem, since everyone now wants to be the best. So even though tiger-mum?s methods work for her, it would not work for all of us. But tiger-mum fulfils her intention, which is to remove all misunderstandings and prejudice concerning tiger-mums and Western parenting methods (despite continental differences). She does this with a twist of logos and pathos, in which the latter mentioned, is the key to her success, since it makes people interested enough to care. But the superior raising method is not to be found in one of the continents, but by combining the two methods, like in every other case where you combine the merits. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Composition section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Composition essays

  1. The Form and function of child directed speech

    The utterances used by the caregiver are shorter than in adult conversation and often consist of no more than four words. However, these utterances are well-constructed and are likely to include the emission of fillers, overlapping and false starts that are all found in everyday adult speech.

  2. The Scarlet Letter Passage Analysis

    New England as set "in a hard soil and amid the close struggle for subsistence", making Puritan life seem like an impossible task (107). He also implies that growth within the Puritan society is unattainable through the language he utilizes such as the "hard soil" and the unending "struggle" for survival.

  1. The Story of Amy Tan

    Everyone would sound the same and would have the same ideology. The diversity in English is in fact a good thing it shows one's cultural background and adds uniqueness to every country. So it's fine to have tint of background in your English.

  2. The difference between a tabloid and broadsheet article

    article rather than a broadsheet one, because broadsheet newspapers are usually more formal and far more factual. A lexical field of abusive language is present within the article. Words such as '"black s***"', '"f****** black"', 'twisted', 'taunted' and 'vile' are all examples of this.

  1. How effective are the strategies employed by Save the Children to make this brochure ...

    It feels like it is an urgent situation. The title has a huge impact on the reader because the reader is captivated and starts to understand that it is an important situation. On the first page, there is the sentence: "Our work in China".

  2. Voluntary Euthanasia, A Personal Report

    take my own life. That's not illegal. died an undignified and . But because of the terrible nature of painful death. Do you . my illness I cannot-to carry out my want to see this happen . wish I need assistance. Should a to someone you care . doctor give me the assistance I need, about. .

  1. Do smartphones increase or decrease social interaction?

    their smartphone to do something else instead of interact with someone that is right by their side. Based in observation, as I don?t have a smartphone I frequently see someone completely focused in their smartphone that they ignore everyone else that is around them.

  2. Lives Changed. Will my mum go to prison?

    I had not felt the desire to disclose any details with the adults in my life. Like many teenagers I felt that adults were an alien species almost talking a different dialect; I wanted to help the quiet ones too timid to speak up - like lost souls not exactly sure enough of themselves to say anything.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work