To what extent was the impact of WW1 a key factor in the US decision to restrict immigration 1917-29?
To what extent was the impact of WW1 a key factor in the US decision to restrict immigration 1917-29?
Before WW1, the USA was famous for its open door approach to immigration. The country was a melting pot of nationalities where immigrants and citizens alike shared a common goal: the attainment of the American Dream, which argued any person, from any background, could succeed in achieving their goals if they worked hard enough. The majority of immigrants – poor, uneducated and unskilled – jumped at the opportunity to make the crossing to Ellis Island. However, after America’s entry into the war in 1917, federal government decided to impose restrictions on immigration in the form of the 1917 Immigration Act. This was followed by further laws in 1921, 1924 and 1929 which made it increasingly hard for immigrants, in particular those without desired skills, to enter the US. There is debate as to the true intention behind this move: some argue it was reactionary, in response to the Red Scare of 1919-1920. Perhaps it was just a form of passive racism that reflected the mood of the country at the time. Others plead more patriotic reasons; the idea that foreigners were distrusted in times of crisis and weakened the US war efforts.
As patriotism grows to strengthen morale during war time, so too does resentment of foreigners who begin to be seen increasingly as ‘outsiders’. This feeling was particularly strong in the US as it was primarily Italian-Americans protesting against the fighting which was viewed as disloyal. Citizens felt immigrants were corroding the unity of the country: they also feared ‘aliens’ could easily betray America by being loyal to their home countries. The USA distrusted immigrants already living in America; the idea of allowing more in was considered outrageous. This argument is slightly flawed in that an immigrant’s loyalty was likely to be, in fact, with America - the country that had provided refuge and opportunity to them – as opposed to their country of origin which they had deliberately left in search of a better life.