Women and the Second World War Sources Questions

Authors Avatar

  1. Study Source A. According to Source A, why were women needed to help with the war effort?

Before World War II, not many women worked, and there were certain jobs that people believed women couldn't or shouldn't do. Women didn't have any kind of military role before the war. Most women were used to getting married, having children and bringing them up, and having a husband around the place who would usually be the sole wage earner - in other words, only the man would go out to work. Of course, once the war broke out, the majority of men were away fighting in some way. So this had a big effect on family lives, and the lives of women. The jobs still had to be done after all. So the purpose of this source is to persuade women to do their vital bit for the war. To get involved in the armed forces, and to work in fields in which men had previously worked.

Source A is a broadcast on the BBC Home Service by a member of the women’s Institute in May 1941. It is aimed at women to persuade them to do their crucial bit for the war. It is an appeal aimed at women, and has a few elements of propaganda. The authors tone and attitude to the situation Britain faced was very positive, as she knows it’s a great opportunity for women to work together and show that they are able to do any job that a man is capable of doing. The broadcasters main aim is to make sure she brings an emotional approach to her audience, so that women can reflect on the dreadful situation that Britain faced. She seems to be very compulsive towards the entire war effort; she makes it sound exciting, and thrilling. Her speech makes you want to volunteer to join the war effort. She portrays the war effort in an upbeat positive manner.

“We are fighting for our lives”.

 The Broadcaster seems very patriotic and is determined to win the war. Seeing as Britain was on the brink of defeat in 1941, she could probably see her whole life flash before her eyes if Britain were to give in to Hitler. Not only would her future be ill fated, but she would also lose her little freedom which she took advantage of. This is why she is hoping to get a constructive response from the women of Britain.

2. Study Sources A and B. Does the writer of source B have a different attitude to the importance of women in the war effort from the author of source A. Explain your answer using both sources.

Source B is an article in the West Ham Gazette. A female member of the Local Council in West Ham wrote this editorial in 1941. Source A is a broadcast on the BBC Home Service by a member of the women’s Institute in May 1941. Both sources are from 1941 just when Britain were on the brink of defeat. They are both aimed at women, are about women, and are from a woman’s point of view. Both sources agree that women should do their vital fraction for the war, to fight. Women, of course, didn’t physically fight, however they did do some very important and skilled jobs. They became involved in the war effort, which helped Britain win the Second World War.

However, both sources not only have things in common, but they also differ too.

“Women should get on with the job”.

The author of source B is more demanding. It is almost like she can give orders, and has more authority over what women should and shouldn’t do. Whereas in source A, the author doesn’t put as much power into her speech, although her dialogues seem to have more enthusiasm. “Isn’t it worth it? Together yes it is”. She gives her listeners more of a choice as to whether they want to help in the war effort she makes the war effort sound amusing and entertaining; source B has a more commanding and intimidating role.

The author of source B has a rather cynical and cheeky behaviour, not only does she want women to work in the war effort, but also she wants the “good conditions” that they are permitted to. As a result she wants to get more out of the war. She wants lasting changes for women. She wants to be treated with more respect.

She also seems to be a bit of a sarcastic feminist. Her opening paragraph suggests that women are only regarded as important when the country is in desperate need of them. Its almost as if the author doesn’t like being used. Her article gets more to the point. Whereas source A is full of passion and interest. It’s more appealing. “We are fighting for our lives”. Source A is more like an unconditional obsessive duty that any woman would be proud to perform.

Both authors have totally different attitudes. The author from source A is much more patriotic and eager, but the author from source B portrays the war effort in a depressing manner.

3. Study source C. In what ways does source C help you to understand the difficulties faced by women during the Second World War?

Source C is a woman speaking in 1941, describing her evening routine at home after working in a factory all day. She is being interviewed, and she seems relatively tense. Her typical daily schedule seems to be very hectic and busy. She doesn’t go into detail about her day because she knows her interviewer knows what’s entailed when she mentions queuing for food, cooking food, washing and mending. Working wives were faced with the constant difficulty of having two jobs, one in the home and the other at work. It was very difficult to fit in cooking, shopping, housework and childcare with exceedingly long working hours required in a full-time job, predominantly at a time when domestic tasks were considered entirely a woman’s liability. Women’s wage rates were usually half of those of men.

Join now!

Factory hours made standard shopping unattainable. A family’s ration book could only be registered with one grocery shop, and by the time a woman got there after work, it would be likely that she would find the usual queues, and also that many of the goods had already been sold out. Before the war, shops usually opened until fairly late in the evening, but now had been well ordered to close early on to save energy. Working women found they had no time to queue for unrationed goods, and might have to shop in their lunch hour, missing their ...

This is a preview of the whole essay