• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

contract law case

Extracts from this document...


X owns a holiday cottage in a remote mountain area. In May he agreed to let it to Y from 1-15 August. Y paid a deposit of � 200. On the afternoon of 31 July, after Y and his family had set off from their home near London, a landslide rendered the cottage uninhabitable. X, who had recently spent � 500 on redecoration in preparation for Y's visit, was unable to contact Y, and Y only found out what had happened when he arrived at the cottage. Y spent � 200 on hotel accommodation for the night before returning home next day. Y and his family were very disappointed at not having the holiday they had planned. Y is now demanding that X should return his deposit and pay him compensation. Advise X. What difference, if any, would it make if the damage to the cottage had been caused by a fire carelessly started by X? ...read more.


Upon discovery of the frustration event one need to examine, whether the effect of the doctrine can be limited as Viscount Simmonds in Taskiroglou stated that this doctrine must be applied within a very narrow limits. As it is not to be invoked lightly to relieve contracting parties of the imprudent commercial bargain (bad bargain) Lord Roskill in Pioneer Shipping. Here Y may argue that the frustration event may be reasonably foreseeable. If the event is foreseeable there is no frustration, Walton & Harvey v Walker & Homfrays. However a person of reasonable intelligence would not have regarded these (landslide) likely to occurs (Treitel) Upon establishing the existence of the frustrating event next one need to examine the extent of remedies. Prior to 1943 the law was as in the case of Fibrosa, which says the loss lies where it falls. This means right and liabilities already acquired up to the time of termination remain intact but subsequent obligations are discharged. ...read more.


But applying the principle in Jackson v Horizon Holiday, Y may able to claim compensation for his family. However the avenue is rejected in Woodar Development v Wimpey Construction, but in Linden Gardens Trust it was stated that if the purpose of the contract that enter on behalf of the 3rd parties is for their enjoyment this is enforceable. With regard to the second part of the question if the damage to the cottage had been caused by a fire carelessly started by X. Then X may not be able to establish frustration. Because frustration must not be self - induced, Maritime National Fish v Ocean Trawler. The burden of proving the events that frustrated the contract is on the party alleging frustration. If there is an allegation of self - induced frustration, the burden lies on the person alleging self - inducement. As from the facts it is clear that the frustrating events is of self - induced frustration and Y bears the burden of proving so. And if Y succeed, the remedy would lie under breach of contract as discussed above. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Law of Contract section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Law of Contract essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Contract Law - Offer And Acceptance

    3 star(s)

    an offer made to living person who ceases to be a living person before the offer is accepted ... is no longer an offer at all' B. Lapse Of Time * Where an offer is stated to be open for a specific length of time, then the offer automatically terminates when the time limit expires.

  2. Four ways in which a contract may be discharged.

    War broke out between Germany and Britain on 3rd September 1939 and Gdansk was occupied by the Germans on 23rd September. (g) A contract will not be frustrated simply because it has become more onerous or expensive to perform than originally envisaged.

  1. What is the importance of implied terms to the contract of employment

    the contract of employment impose higher standards and obligations in the employment relationship such as the duty of mutual trust and confidence49, than would be found in contracts for services. Certain legally implied terms50 are only available under the contract of employment.

  2. I have been asked to advise a client on considering contracting with a building ...

    Both of these cases are shown below. Les Affreteurs V Walford 1919 "A charter of a ship provided expressly for 3% commission payment to be made on signing the charter. There was a trade custom that it should only be paid at a later stage.

  1. "There are occasions where terms are implied into contracts which have never been discussed ...

    In the case the claimant contracted a painful skin disease from chemicals in his underwear. It was held that the buyer would have impliedly made known the purpose for which the underpants would be used even if he had not expressly stated it.

  2. Contract Law

    The auctioneer may withdraw items from the auction or cancel the auction all together without incurring any liability from potential bidders. b) Auctions with Reserve Each bid represents an offer which the auctioneer may reject or accept. Acceptance of the offers occurs and an agreement is formed when the auctioneer knocks down the property to the successful bidder.

  1. Aspects of the law affecting construction projects.

    1. Common Law within the construction industry. Common law forms the basis of all law that is applied in England; it is also known as ?evolved? law as it has developed as a result of custom and judicial decisions as distinct from the law that is made by governments.

  2. Aspects of Contract and Business Law Case Studies

    In the contract and scenario above, if Temuulen industrial did not pay the outstanding £5,000 then this shows lack of capacity within the contract. Amersham & Wycombe limited who would be looking to enforce the contract would have to plead (Present and argue their position).

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work