• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Critically discuss the Labour Governments record of crime control since coming to power in 1997

Extracts from this document...


Labour Government Crime Critically discuss the Labour Government?s record of crime control since coming to power in 1997 When Labour came to power in 1997, they used Tony Blair?s famous statement of four years earlier, ?tough on crime, tough on the causes of crime?, to demonstrate their tough policies on crime. This was in contrast to the more soft approach seen to be adopted by the Conservative party at that time. However, it also meant that Labour intended to act more vigorously on preventing the causes of crime, such as poor education, lack of role models, and the break down of the familial structure. Various policies came out of this attitude, such as the zero-tolerance campaign on drug related crimes and gun crime. The government also introduced the Crime and Disorder Act 1998 and dramatically increased CCTV footage across the country to help prevent crime and help solve crimes, thus addressing both crime itself and the causes of crime. Whether these initiatives made any difference to the amount of crime recorded is discussed below. Police Recorded Crime has increased steadily since the Labour Government came to power in 1997. There was one exception which was that the figures for 2004/2005 showed a 6% fall in crime compared to 2003/4. However, one should be aware that in 1998/1999 there was a change in the Home Office Counting Rules for crime. This coincides roughly with the Labour Government coming to power and should be one reason for it. ...read more.


Transient populations are also excluded; the BCS is not organised using the electoral register, but on a process called PAF based on postal addresses; therefore the homeless are completely excluded, whilst those people who move a lot and do not stay at one address for very long are unlikely to get cover. Although there is not a large number of homeless people, they nevertheless have a phenomenally high victimisation rate, and that is therefore omitted. In addition, the sampling strategy employed with the BCS uses a constrained version of the PAF; addresses referring to institutional establishments, such as old peoples? homes, are excluded, as their crime experience was felt to be substantially different from other addresses. Consequently then, even a population frame that purports to cover the population of England and Wales will by necessity miss some sections of that population. The most recent BCS response rate was 75%; this is extraordinarily good by survey standards, but nevertheless 25% of people that the BCS has tried to contact are excluded; this does not matter if the people missing have exactly the same characteristics as the 75% who have been contracted, but it is very unlikely that the non-respondents have the same characteristics as the respondents. Aye Maung, writing in 1995, showed that there are disproportionate numbers of non-respondents in inner-city areas, and in properties judged by interviewer to be in poor condition, which are areas with high crime rates, and thus the question of whether the sample is representative or not has to be questioned. ...read more.


However, the increase in less serious crime is probably artefactual because of the change in recording crimes that was introduced. The violence debate, as to whether violent crime has really been going up or whether it merely appears to be because of recording practices, is particularly important, given the level of excitement that the media undergo because of the apparent rise in violent crime. The BCS is not particularly reliable in relation to violence, because a lot of violent crimes are because of domestic violence, and interviewees for the BCS would be reluctant to talk about domestic violence in the context of a household interview, especially if the offender is in the next room of the house. It is also interesting to look at public perceptions of trends in crime, and as to whether it is going up or down. According to BCS figures, in 2004, 5.61% of respondents thought that crime had increased in the previous year under the Labour Government nationally, and 27% thought that it had increased ?a lot?. Also in 2004, 5.42% of respondents thought that crime had increased because of the Labour Government locally, and 16% thought that it had increased ?a lot?. In conclusion, it can be seen that under the Labour Government since 1997, crime seems to have decreased by using the more reliable BCS figures. However, the public perception is that crime has gone up a lot, and one must question why this is, and whether the Labour government are trying to create this impression in order to support their position of being ?tough on crime? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Criminal Law section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Criminal Law essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Is the current law on the non-fatal offences against the person satisfactory?

    4 star(s)

    cover minor cuts; this means that the harm caused is not necessarily equivalent to GBH. In Ireland; Burstow, the House of Lords confirmed that psychiatric harm could amount to ABH (as decided in Constanza), but added that it could also constitute GBH in extreme cases.

  2. Property Offences, Corporate Manslaughter and Police Powers of Search and Entry.

    Reckless manslaughter A person is guilty of reckless manslaughter if she/he recklessly causes the death of another person. R v Lidar (1999) The defendant drove off with the victim hanging out of the car window. The victim was killed after as he was fallen out of the window and being run over by the defendant.

  1. Law - Unit 3 - Mock Exam Question

    In R v Pagett (1983) the defendant was trying to escape capture by armed police, and used his girlfriend as a human shield. He shot at the police, and his girlfriend was killed by shots fired at him in self-defence by the policemen. The defendant was found liable for the girl's death because it was

  2. The justifiable use of force in self-defence depends entirely upon the circumstances in which ...

    This was also confirmed in Cousins (1982), where the defendant believed that a contract had been take out on his life. He armed himself with a shotgun and paid a visit to the person's father who he thought was behind the contract and told him "I'm going to kill him".

  1. Prison Inmate Rehabilitation Through Education

    first place since they have never been directed down a different path other than the path of crime. "If the trend continues, prisons are likely to become merely overcrowded holding cells which release inmates without alternatives and tools and skills to apply for jobs, and become legitimate members of the community.

  2. Recognition Of Necessity

    as duress of necessity but for obviousness this is not the case. One factor to this debate that must be pointed out is that of Woolf LJ in Conway (1998). Here Lord Woolf stated that "Whether duress of circumstance is called duress or necessity does not matter".

  1. Non-Fatal Offences - Notes and Evaluation.

    This means that the defendant must intend or be reckless as to whether the victim fears or is subjected to unlawful force. There is no need for the defendant to intend or be reckless as to whether actual bodily harm is caused.

  2. How Satisfactory Is The Current Law On The Deception Offences?

    The decision in this case is more justifiable than DPP vs. Ray. The deception must be the operative cause of the obtaining of property, and this is a question of fact for the jury to decide, requiring proof that the victim would not have acted in the same way had he or she known the truth.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work