Comparative Commentary - Comparing text 1(a) and 1(b).

Authors Avatar

Comparative Commentary

Comparing text 1(a) and 1(b)

Text 1(a) is titled ‘LIDO’, a holiday resorts brandname. The text is an advertisement, from ‘Travel and Leisure magazine’. Text 1(b) is titled ‘Where’. It is a poem, written by A.S.J. Tessimond.

The themes of text 1(a) and 1(b) seem to be similar to a certain extent. Both texts are about a place. A loved place, where happiness can be found. A place like paradise. Unlike text 1(b), text 1(a) is an advertisement. It recommends a stay at a ‘LIDO’resort. It claims that the ‘LIDO’resorts are just like paradise (‘Float on the crystal calm waters of a protected Caribbean cove.’or; ‘... Which means that it’s not just comfortable, it’s tropical elegance blended with every modern luxury.’) Text 1(b) is a poem. This text is not meant for commerce. It is about the place people love most. According to the author of the poem, this place is different for each person. It could be an imaginative place, but also a real one.

 Text 1(a) concentrates on the material side of a place. It lays the accent on the luxury, elegance, comfort and adventure that can be found at a ‘LIDO’resort (line 2; ‘Dress for an elegant gourmet dinner or eat when you feel like it courtesy of 24-hour room service.’) Text 1(b) does not concentrate on these material issues. It emphasizes the happiness that can be found in little things like people smiling, music or beautiful weather (line 2; ‘Where people laugh in the sun. And the people are warm as the sunshine and live and move easily’, or line 8 for instance; ‘And palms weave sinlight into sheaves of gold’)

It is not hard to see that text 1(a) is an advertisement. The author only uses positive words to make clear how great the ‘LIDO’resorts are. The adjectives are even exaggerated; ‘crystal calm water’, ‘elegant gourmet dinner’, ‘great massage’, ‘unlimited golf’, ‘Super-inclusive’. The author makes clear that the ‘LIDO’resorts are perfect holiday destinations. (line 10; ‘It’s not just all-inclusive, it’s Super-Inclusive. And most of all, it’s not just a resort, it’s a Lido resort by SuperClubs.’)

Join now!

The text type of text 1(b) is more difficult to see. It is not directly clear that this is a poem. Although you do not see the rhyme immediately, there is a certain rhyme in the sentences; line 14; ‘Perhaps it is east of the sun and west of the moon, Perhaps it is a county called the Hesperides.’  The text is, just like poetry, aligned to the left. But more important is the subject of the text. It is very personal, it is a written fantasy (line 12; ‘Perhaps your country is where you think you will find ...

This is a preview of the whole essay