10/3/07                                                                                                           

 Evaluate the impact of the state religion on government and law in any two countries

In this essay I will be evaluating the impact of the state religion on government and law in Israel and Iran. Israel provides an interesting study of the interplay of religion and politics because it is a state that was created as a homeland for a specific religious group, and, on the other hand, Iran has also been greatly affected by its state religion in the more political area. I shall evaluate first, the state religion’s impact on government and law in Israel, and then move onto the state religion’s impact on government and law in Iran, and then finally draw up a conclusion.

Israel’s government is obviously influenced by its religion because the state was created a group as a result of Zionism and its various movements. It has to a notable extent, affected the government. In 1948 the different Zionist groups reached a compromise as to the nature of the Israeli state. The existing political status quo would be maintained after Israeli independence through the implementation of a system of proportional representation in the Knesset (Israeli Parliament). This would assure the different Zionist factions that they would receive some degree of representation in the Knesset. Another compromise between the various religious Zionist groups was that the Israeli state would keep the Sabbath, ensure the observance of dietary laws in state institutions, maintain Orthodox control over laws concerning personal status(for example marriage and divorce) and allow different educational streams in school including Orthodox. There was also to be no definition of the nature of the state and no fixing of its boundaries. This aspect of the compromise infuriated those with the “Greater Israel ideology” which was an ideology that advocated that the Jews have right to the whole of biblical Israel and particularly the West Bank. It was only through these compromises that the various Zionist groups were able to reach agreement over the wording of the Declaration of Independence. This meant that Israel did not have any Constitution, Bill of rights or boundaries and this is the same case that continues today.

Join now!

In Israel, religion also has a large impact when it comes to law. Israel was founded to provide a national home, safe from persecution, to the Jewish people. Although Israeli law explicitly grants equal civil rights to all citizens regardless of religion, ethnicity, or other heritage, it gives preferential treatment in certain aspects to individuals who fall within the criteria mandated by the “Law of Return”. Preferential treatment is given to Jews who seek to immigrate to Israel as part of a governmental policy to increase the Jewish population. The criteria set forth by the “Law of Return” are controversial. ...

This is a preview of the whole essay