• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

What is liberal about John Rawls Theory of Justice? How may it be criticised?

Extracts from this document...


What is liberal about John Rawl's Theory of Justice? How may it be criticised? John Rawl's Theory of Justice (published in 1970) argues for principled reconciliation of liberty and equality. The theory is neither altruistic (focused on helping others), nor is it egoistic (self-concerned), Rawls offers a model of a fair choice situation within which parties would hypothetically choose mutually acceptable parties of justice. But to what extent is this theory liberal? Firstly Rawls believes in the theory of a "social contract", similarly to Hobbes and Locke, which is a liberal idea. As Locke maintains, "where there is no law there is no freedom". Our individual liberty requires that others are restrained from encroaching upon our freedom and this protection can arguably only provided by a sovereign state. Liberals recognise that it would be in their interests to sacrifice a portion of their liberty in order to protect their liberties, as well as avoid the "state of nature", within which life would be "nasty, brutish and short". ...read more.


It is also liberal in its "reasoned" approach, for example where it may be necessary to trade freedoms off each other for the sake of obtaining the largest possible system of rights. The second principle of justice involves social and economic inequalities are to be arranged so that they are of the greatest benefit to the least advantaged members of society (as mentioned previously, liberal to the same extent of welfare liberalism) and that offices and positions must be open to everyone under conditions of fair equality of opportunity. This again seems to be more egalitarian and socialist rather than liberal. Liberals are committed to equality - but on the grounds that all individuals are of equal moral worth and are therefore entitled to equal rights and responsibilities, yet are born with very different talents and entitled to rewards accordingly. Rawls theory seems in some ways to be more similar to social equality or achieving equality of outcome. Rawls theory of justice demonstrates that he holds a social liberal position, which is that he values equality but also emphasises common freedoms. ...read more.


Therefore they should be more community based and a universal system of justice would simply not be compatible with this. Michael Sandel wrote "Liberalism and Limits of Justice" and within it criticises how Rawls asks us to think about justice whilst divorcing us from the very values and aspirations that define u as well as that the original position is abstract and implausible. He primarily seeks to use liberal moral ideals to build a new "public philosophy" in America. Walzer believes that Rawls's Theory of Justice fails to incorporate any morals or values, and instead focuses too much of the bargaining of goods. From the left wing, Robert Paul Wolff argues that Rawls theory constructs justice from existing practice and does not take into account that there may already be existing problems of injustice embedded into the ideas of capitalism, private property and the market economy. A final criticism is put forward by Susna Moller Okinb who maintained that Rawls theory could justify injustices and hierarchies embedded within the family network. She also criticises Rawls for not taking patriarchal social relations and gendered division of labour into account. ?? ?? ?? ?? Lucy Goodwin 13.3 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Political Philosophy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Political Philosophy essays

  1. Power and Politics in Organizations: Public and Private Sector Comparisons

    This would include, say, the size of their population or territory; their racial or linguistic make-up; and a wide range of social, economic, and even political conditions. Federal systems represent ways of organizing and managing diversity.

  2. Explain why the Liberals were electorally so successful so often, 1868-85?

    The defeat of 1874 prompted the creation of numerous 'popular' Liberal fronts in the urban areas styled on the original Liberal Association based in Birmingham. However by 1877 these were all centralised into a structured formation of the National Liberal Front, which initially remained in Birmingham.

  1. A Study of Carl Rogers' Theory of Personality

    However, some studies have found that openness to experience and organismic trusting did not intercorrelate, contrary to expectations (Pearson, 1969, 1974; cited in Maddi, 1996).

  2. Notes on John Stuart Mill's On Liberty

    to those who practice it. So the majority has in many cases made h********l s*x illegal, which the majority may claim to be better for the homosexuals as well. This is called being paternalistic. Another example of paternalism would be if a town banned bungee jumping from a local bridge because it was concerned that those jumping would be hurt.

  1. How and why does Locke explain the creation, value and protection of property?

    When people work on the land, they cause everyone to gain since they can give people product from the land by trading it for other things. In conclusion, the government has to protect people's property since people have a natural right to own it and that is the reason why they joined the society.

  2. Karl Marx's (1818 - 1883) theory of capitalism.

    At the heart of capitalism was the contradiction between the demands of the capitalist to earn a profit and the demands of the worker, who wants to retain some profit to subsist. Over time, the workings of the capitalist system would exacerbate this contradiction, and its resolution can be had only through social change.

  1. The study of international or rather global politics, seeks to provide an account of ...

    Contributions and insights As Burd (in Sabine 1973:329) explains, "Living at a time when the old political order in Europe was collapsing and new problems both in state and society were arising with dazzling rapidity, he endeavoured to interpret the logical meaning of events, to forecast the inevitable issues,

  2. Democracy and Capitalism in the Developing World: Compatible or Conflictive.

    These will invariably generate the type of security necessary to encourage citizens to work, save and invest (Claude 1976). This also acts to release and foster the energies necessary to initiate change, entrepreneurial ventures and economic development. However, one will also see that while liberal democracy may be compatible with

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work