• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast Plato's concept of the Body and Soul with Aristotle's.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Compare and contrast Plato's concept of the Body and Soul with Aristotle's. In this essay I will be comparing what Plato and Aristotle thought about the relationship of the body and Soul. The main fundamental difference between what Plato and Aristotle thought about the relationship between the Body and Soul is that Plato thought that the Soul was immortal; it was existed before the Body and its here when the Body dies. Plato thought this to be true because of his theory of forms. Plato thought we had such ideas as a 'perfect circle,' or a 'perfect chair,' not because we have seen them before or they had been described to us, but the image was already known to us through the world of forms. Plato adopted a theory that our Soul had already lived a life in the world of Forms and as the Body experienced things this unlocked memory from that world of Forms so the Body/Mind recognises objects as a 'circle,' or 'chair' but not a perfect a 'circle,' or 'chair,' because only the Forms we remember are perfect because in the material world things change making them imperfect. ...read more.

Middle

Here Aristotle is saying that the Soul of the eye is dead, the body of the eye is dead, but it's the qualities of an eye that make it an eye that never die, they might not work properly or at all but it's the qualities that make it an eye. Plato did mention the concept of form in his writings, but in the past life of the Soul, Aristotle uses form to describe part of the Soul. Plato also mentioned form as part of the Soul too, "The Soul is divided into three different parts, roughly translated as reason, emotion and desire." But Plato became less sure about which parts of the Soul are immortal. Considering Plato taught Aristotle this indecision might have influenced Aristotle as a philosopher, there is certainly logic and similarity between this uncertain thought of a separate immortal Soul, and Aristotle's thought of form being immortal and the Soul not. Plato tells us that the human person has different elements: the physical body; the mind; and the immortal Soul. Aristotle totally disagrees with this, he wrote: "We can totally dismiss as wholly unnecessary the question whether the Body and Soul are one: it is meaningless as to ask whether the wax and the shape given to it are one." ...read more.

Conclusion

There are points of Aristotle's philosophy on the Body and Soul that seem true to me. "The particular nature of any Soul will depend on the living thing that it is." This line basically says that the living object has an effect on the Soul. For example if a human is unhappy, he/she will have an unhappy Soul. To me this seems a logical philosophy of the Soul, and how it can be affected by the living thing that it was part of. According with Plato's philosophy I believe that after the Body is dead and the soul is released, but I believe the Soul keeps the characteristics of the Body it belonged to and doesn't die with the Body. But I disagree with Plato and I don't think that the spirit goes to the realm of forms. Even though there two philosophers have many different ideas on the Soul's relationship with the Body, they do have many points of agreement. Plato taught Aristotle, and in many points it is clear to see how Plato influenced him in many ways, even in his indecision in the purpose of the soul. Aristotle gets himself confused when it comes down to the minor points of his Philosophy, but both philosophers had their downfalls and their triumphs. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Philosophy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Philosophy essays

  1. Explain Plato's and Aristotle's ideas of form, body, knowledge and soul.

    Sensation is the passive capacity for the soul to be changed through the contact of the associated body with external objects. In each variety of sensation, the normal operations of the appropriate organ of sense result in the soul's becoming potentially what the object is in actuality.

  2. Explain Platos concept of the soul and Its relationship to the body.

    Our body is our senses that rare to touch, taste, hear, see and smell and presents our appearances of everything. Through our bodies we are able to sense these experiences in order to gain knowledge and make our opinions. Plato related body and soul to the cave in the way the cave traps the prisoners, the body traps the soul.

  1. Evaluate plato and aristotle on well being

    Plato argues that each of the three parts of the soul corresponds to a different type of pleasure Rational- Gains pleasure in seeking the truth. Spirited- Gains pleasure out of achievement and honour. Appetitive- Gains pleasure through the empirical senses, e.g.

  2. Plato & The Soul

    To further emphasise the point, Plato writes "...when the soul investigates by itself it passes into the realm of what is pure, ever existing, immortal and unchanging". He argues that just as the body's prime function is to understand the material and transient world, the functioning of the soul as

  1. Compare, contrast and evaluate Plato and Mill on the relationship between individual and society

    it will only benefit society, as the individuals will be able to contribute more if they reach their full potential and are allowed to develop their own ideals and opinions. Mill has concerns over the limits of which power can be legitimately exercised by society over the individual.

  2. Plato Questions - Concept of the Soul

    Given this view, Plato viewed teachers such as Socrates to be not instructors who instill knowledge but rather as "midwives" whose job is simply to help give birth to those ideas that are already within us. Plato believed that the human person also has different elements: the physical body, the mind, and the immortal soul.

  1. Explain the fundamental ideas of resurrection and immortality of the soul. (18)

    This example also implies that the resurrected body is physical as Thomas could touch him.

  2. The Concept of Life After Death is Incoherent - Discuss.

    The question of what life after death was attempted to be answered by H.H. Price. Price argued that it was possible that our mind could survive the death of our body and exist in a mental world.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work