• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Assess the Usefulness of Different Sociological Approaches to Suicide.

Extracts from this document...


´╗┐Liam Curran There are two main approaches to the issue of suicide; positivism and interpretivism and their views differ dramatically in method and theory. I will be assessing the strengths and weaknesses of each approach, in the way they both study suicide. Early positivists such as Durkheim (1895) see suicide as social facts, which means it can be studied scientifically.His fundamental argument was that suicide was not an individual act but that suicide had a social cause that is found in every society. He found four types of suicide: Egoistic - inadequate integration, Altruistic - excessive integration, Anomic - inadequate regulation and Fatalistic - excessive regulation. Strengths of his argument support his egoistic suicide, as Marshall and Hodge (1981) say that there is a connection between the suicide rate, and economic crisis. A problem with this argument is how positivists see it as ?scientifically? studying because he doesn?t question the validity or reliability of the data he looks at, and he takes them as factual when interpretivists look at ...read more.


For example, Marilyn Monroe who overdosed, but nobody knows for definite whether or not it was a suicide, and interpretivists ignore the fact, that coroners are trained to look for signs and don?t just rely on the use of their common sense. Another criticism of Douglas? is that he never done any of his own research, which is a weakness because this shows the only evidence he has is that of other sociologists, which itself is based on other works. Atkinson et al (1978), performed some primary research using four English coroners and five Danish coroners and were told to decide of 40 cases and found that the Danish coroners were much more likely to give the verdict of suicide than the English coroners because in Denmark the verdict is given if there is no other evidence, and on the balance of probabilities, a suicide is more likely, and this shows how weak the positivist method is because it disproves the claim that suicide can be studied scientifically as social facts when really, each country has different interpretations to suicide. ...read more.


His own study of 12 months found 32 cases of people throwing themselves under a train and found that 32 were suicide, 5 were accidental and 10 were open verdicts. A strength of Taylor?s theory is that he combines both approaches to suicide and uses a mix of different methods, involving scientific and interpretive methods, which improved the validity of the results. However, reliability is an issue because there are very little realist approaches to suicide and interpretation is still different, even if combined with scientific methods. Also Taylor uses cases from people under trains which doesn?t show a broad scale of the way people were feeling which can often determine how they commit suicide, which then gives the meaning of the suicide. Overall, interpretivist approaches are more useful in studying suicide because today there are many different societies and can adapt to the meaning of suicide as opposed to positivist approaches to suicide that struggles to adapt to the world we live in today, through the use of scientific methods to discover social facts that, over time can change. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Crime & Deviance section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Crime & Deviance essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Assess the Usefulness of Official Crime Statistics to a Sociological Understanding of Crime

    4 star(s)

    criminal and then this label becomes the person's primary identity and can lead to a continuation of deviant or criminal behaviour. This is known as the labelling theory. Page 210 A Giddens [2001] Marxist perspective believes that the law and it's agents, being the police, courts and the judicial system

  2. Durkheims study of suicide has been criticised on theoretical and methodological grounds. Outline Durkheims ...

    The indicators that Durkheim uses are the official suicide rates. Durkheim used the official suicide statistics of Europe and a method called Multivariate analysis. This consisted of comparing the incidence of various social factors with the known incident of a particular event, in this case suicide.

  1. Assess the usefulness of official statistics to a sociological understanding of crime.

    However the gap between BCS and police figures is reducing due to a new police recoding criteria. Disadvantages of victim surveys are that it's not reliable even though it is the largest victim survey it only interviews a small population.

  2. Assess the usefulness of interpretive approaches to the study of suicide.

    Instead, Durkheim relied on coroners' statistics which are essentially just socially constructed in various ways depending on what the coroner classed as suicide. Interpretive approaches to suicide therefore have the obvious advantage that they do not rely on statistics as a source of evidence which are subject to bias and inaccuracies.

  1. Positive Approach To Suicide

    A search for help suicide- This a cry for help when everything else has failed. Escape suicide- This is when the victim has no other way out as life has become unbearable. Repentance suicide- This is seen as repentance for the wrong doings they have causes in the past and an attempt to set the score straight.

  2. Outline and Assess Sociological Approaches to Social Control Within Crime and Deviance

    He called these three changes: Penetration, Size and Density, Identitiy and Visibility. He argued that in the past societies had simple forms of control; any law passed by the state would be randomly enforced by whoever and whomever. However, Cohen argues that increasingly the law is expected to penetrate right

  1. Outline and evaluate Durkheims theory of suicide.

    For example leaving a note accusing others of failing the person in a particular way. This means that there is no single act which can be determined as suicide as the meaning are different to people, deeming Durkheim's theory as untrustworthy.

  2. Using Item A and elsewhere, assess different sociological explanations of suicide

    Later positivist approaches from Gibbs and Martin, have criticised Durkheim?s typology, because integration is hard to define and therefore hard to conceptualise and measure, and therefore sought to define it as a situation where there are stable and long lasting relationships, which happens when there is status integration, for example

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work