• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Referring to the John Duffy "Railway r****t" case to illustrate, discuss the strengths and limitations of offender profiling.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Cassi Axon Referring to the John Duffy "Railway r****t" case to illustrate, discuss the strengths and limitations of offender profiling. 'Offender profiling' is a general term that has no accepted definition and varies in its use between the USA and the UK. It is based on three strands of expertise: statistical analysis of crime data, behavioural science, and detective expertise. Psychological profiling was in fact used in the Second World War to profile enemy leaders to see if they had weaknesses that could be exploited - for example, William Langer's profile of Hitler and his accurate prediction of suicide after defeat (Langer, 1972). Traditionally police collected hard evidence from the scene of a crime, such as blood, saliva and s***n. Other less concrete indicators might be ignored, such as the choice of victim, what was said or not said, the location and the nature of the assault. Psychologists help police to interpret these clues. The basic assumption of offender profiling is that the offender's behaviour at the crime scene reflects something about them as a person. It leaves a 'psychological fingerprint,' particularly where there is a pattern over a number of crimes. For example, tying up a victim suggests a need for control. The aim is to go beyond the facts and develop hypotheses about the offender. The information used includes the analysis of the crime scene, details of the victim and current knowledge about offenders from research. Holmes (1989) suggests that profiling is most useful when the crime reflects psychopathology, such as s******c assaults. ...read more.

Middle

This type of offender believes he is developing some type of relationship with the victim, and mistakenly believes, the s****l assault produces intimacy. 2. Victim as object - blindfolding and/or gagging the victim, while the offender tends to be disguised. The offender is concerned most with control in the interaction of the r**e. The woman is seen as a dangerous object that must be 'trussed and coerced' (Canter, 1994). 3. Victim as vehicle - violence (both physical and verbal), which demeans the victim. The actions here are a reflection of the offenders anger. This emphasis on statistical patterns has led to the creation of a database called CATCH'EM (Central Analytical Team Collating Homicide Expertise and Management). The database contains details of over 4,000 child murders, which allows police officers to make statistical predictions about the killer. For example, 62% of killers of females under seventeen are single, but 83% if the victim is male and under sixteen. If the child's body is found without s****l interference, there is around a 70% likelihood that the killer is the guardian or parent, but when there is s****l interference, this figure drops to 1% -2 % (Murder in Mind, 1993). In the UK there seems to have been some resistance to profiling by the police because psychologists have been viewed as 'outsiders' and not being able to offer anything more than what a could practitioner (eg, detective) could. Geberth (1983) feels that 'experts' have very little to say compared with what experienced police officers are likely to work out for themselves. ...read more.

Conclusion

We should also be aware of the danger of the self-fulfilling prophecy with respect to profiling. Detectives should bear in mind that a profile may well fit a number of people and may not be totally accurate. The fact that a suspect happens to fit the profile does not 'prove' that they committed the offence. There may be several people who share the suspect's make-up and so the police should be cautious before making a presumption of guilt. This issue is most likely to be created because psychologists will tend to work on probabilities whereas police may be more likely to operate in absolute terms of guilt and innocence. The danger is that once a person has been labelled as a suspect and brought in for questioning, the police will make a presumption of guilt and see their role as merely to elicit a confession. There is little good scientific research to which one can turn in trying to answer the question of how useful profiling is. Success or failure are not so easily measured when one is dealing with the sort of material used in profiling. If a profiler's information proves to be 50% accurate and 50% inaccurate should this be counted as a success or a failure? In addition if any information provided by a profiler is used that helps in catching a criminal is this success, even if the rest of the information provided was useless? A related issue to this is that profile details may only be considered as useful if it provides a type of detail, which the police could not have reasonably deduced, for themselves. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Crime & Deviance section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Crime & Deviance essays

  1. The Strengths and Limitations of Left Realism and Right Realism Theories in Explaining Crime ...

    A lack of discipline and teachings of what is right and wrong as a child could mean that those who are already prone to crime become much more likely commit to criminal acts later on in life. In a traditional nuclear family with strong family bonds children can be condition

  2. Critically compare the three main theories of deviance and assess their strengths & weaknesses

    * Chambliss (1976) suggests that much of what takes place I the creation of rules is 'non decision making'. Many issues - such as the way wealth is distributed - never reach the point of decision. Marxists argue that crime is widespread in all parts of society.

  1. The Birth (and Creation) of Demons and Despots

    In addition, there are many who are considered to be simply insane or extremely morally deviant. Such are Charles Manson, Jim Jones and Jeffrey Dahmer, and oddly enough, we are actually more shocked at the actions of these individuals, than those of true genocidal murderers.

  2. anti-social behaviour

    The next research question addressed whether or not the respondents were aware of ASBO's. The study clearly shows that the respondents are aware of ASBO's. This may suggest that there is a percentage of the younger generation who are aware of the existence of ASBO's.

  1. Crime Data

    For example; people who visit pubs and bars regularly are at more risk of violence. The risk of single people becoming victims of violent crime was also higher than most average. Sources: Crime in England and Wales 2006/2007, Home Office Statistical Bulletin, www.homeoffice.gov.uk 8.

  2. Criminal Investigation Procedures

    Thus being able to question the suspect about past crimes which the police suspect they were involved in. The National Crime Intelligence Service (NCIS) can also be used to collect potential evidence although the NCIS is mainly used to gather intelligence information on the more in depth cases such as terrorist attacks much like the Echelon system.

  1. Forensic investigation

    Hair palled out at the root will provide DNA, but shed hair will only contain mitochondrial DNA, and one of the other forms of DNA is v*****l fluid which contains cells from the lining of the v****a. Any DNA collected will go on to the National DNA database, were it

  2. Describe law and order in London in the late 19th century

    Nevertheless, the nature of the murders captured the attention of Samuel Montagu, a local MP, who on the 10th September 1888 offered a �100 reward as he feared the murders would damage their reputation to be seen doing not enough to help catch the murderer.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work