Discuss Eye witness testimony

Discuss Eye witness testimony Eye witness testimony is often held as accurate and is used as the basis for many criminal prosecutions and investigations and can often lead to the conviction and consequent imprisonment of a suspected criminal. In reality eyewitness testimony can be altered and therefore become inaccurate in varying degrees. The information of an event is subject to many influences both within and without the witness. Psychologists studying eyewitness testimony refer to two main models, the Associative network model and the Schema theory. The associative network model of memory states that we have nodes between which links called cognitive associations can travel. Cognitive associations are links between ideas, for instance "pen" and "writing" could be one association. The more frequently that the link is exercised the stronger it becomes and therefore the easier it will be to retrieve. The model suggests that memories are built up through the networking of links and associations between nodes. Inconsistent information results from wrongly linked nodes. This information will receive more attention therefore its linkages will be strengthened resulting in improved recall of the said information. The second model, the Schema theory, takes a different approach. It states that we use our past experiences to help with the comprehension of the world. Past

  • Word count: 749
  • Level: University Degree
  • Subject: Biological Sciences
Access this essay

Eye Witness Testimony

a. Explain what is meant by the term repression (3 marks) b. Explain what is meant by the term flash bulb memory (3 marks) 2a. Outline one explanation of forgetting in STM (3 marks) b. Outline one explanation of forgetting in LTM (3 marks) 3. Outline and evaluate research into eye witness testimony (18 marks) 1a. Repression is forgetting because the memory holds too much emotion to remain conscious. Freud (1901) believed that some forgetting is an unconscious, motivated process. We forget certain memories because they are too psychologically painful to remain conscious. Therefore we repress them (push out) the memory and they remain inaccessible in our unconscious. For example, abuse experienced as a child might be repressed in memory. b. Flashbulb memories are a special kind of episodic memory, which we can vividly recall in great detail (e.g. September the 11th) It is called a flashbulb memory as the memory is recalled in almost photographic detail. They can also be about personal events, such as the birth of a brother. For Flashbulb memories to occur the event must be emotionally significant and are often unexpected. People who have flashbulb memories ten to remember information surrounding the event such as; where they were, what they were doing, who told them the news, what they felt about it, how others felt about it and what happened immediately afterwards. 2a.

  • Word count: 1001
  • Level: AS and A Level
  • Subject: Psychology
Access this essay

Eye Witness Testimony

EYE WITNESS TESTIMONY The language used by the police when interviewing witnesses and barristers during a trial may influence answers given by witnesses, this language may affect initial perception and subsequent recall. Both of these effects are shown in the study by Loftus & Palmer {1974). My experiment into this field showed the leading question with the `verb` contained the information about what the answer should be, thus language can have a distorting effect on EWT, which can lead to inaccurate accounts of the witnessed account. This was most certainly true in the study carried out, most participants gave a higher estimation of speed when the word in the critical question was changed from bumped to crashed, although a small number of participants were unable to estimate any speed at all. However the experiments were carried out by untrained experimenters which could explain possible confounding variables in the way that the experimenters could have unknowingly in their over-zealousness to prove the experimental hypothesis may have led participants by using tone of voice, facial expressions ect to respond accordingly. Studies into ways of improving the reliability of EWT to help prevent convicting innocent people, it is essential that steps are taken to improve the reliability of eyewitness accounts. EWT has considered hypnosis in an attempt to access repressed

  • Word count: 750
  • Level: AS and A Level
  • Subject: Psychology
Access this essay

Section B Essay: Eye Witness Testimony

Section B Essay: Psychology of Testimony Describe what psychologists have found out about the processes and factors affecting witness testimony One thing psychologists have found out about the processes and factors affecting witness testimony is that leading questions can have large effect on ones recall of an event. In the study by Loftus and Palmer (1974) the participants (university students) were shown a video clip of a traffic accident and then given a questionnaire. The 17th question on the questionnaire was, "How fast were the cars going when they smashed/ collided/ bumped/ hit/ contacted?" Each of the five conditions was characterised by a different verb. The results showed that those in the "smashed" condition had the highest estimates of speed (40mph) and those in the "contacted" condition had the lowest estimates (31.8mph). This shows that questions asked after an event has occurred can alter ones recall of the event. Psychologist have found that ones attitudes can have on ones perception of an event. The effect of ethnicity on perception was investigated by Duncan in 1976. The participants (white American college students) watched two versions of a video where two men had an argument that became angrier until one pushed the other. In one version of the video, the person who pusher the other was black and in the other, he was white. Upon watching on of the

  • Word count: 1405
  • Level: AS and A Level
  • Subject: Psychology
Access this essay

Outline and evaluate factors influencing eye witness testimony

Francesca Briggs Outline and Evaluate Factors Influencing Eye Witness Testimony The term ‘eye witness testimony’ refers to an area of research into the accuracy of memory concerning significant events, it is legally considered to be a reliable account of events. However, research into eye witness testimony has found that it can be affected by many psychological factors such as, anxiety and stress, reconstructive memory, selective attention and leading questions. Anxiety and stress can be associated with many factors such as, violence and crime. Clifford and Scott (1978) found that participants who saw a film of a violent event remembered less of the information than a control group who saw a less stressful version. However, Yuile and Cutshall (1986) found that witnesses of a real event had accurate memories of what happened. The police interviewed witnesses and thirteen of them were interviewed five months later. Recall was found to be accurate, even after a long period of time. One weakness of this study was that the witnesses who experienced the highest levels of stress where actually present at the event, instead of watching second hand from a film, and this may have helped with the accuracy of their memory recall. Selective attention is when the witness is able to describe one detail, giving them less time to pay attention to other details. It can also be because

  • Word count: 795
  • Level: AS and A Level
  • Subject: Psychology
Access this essay

To what extent does psychological research support the accuracy of eye witness testimony?

To what extent does psychological research support the accuracy of eye witness testimony? (18 marks) Eye Witness Testimony is an area of research into a witness' recollection of an event, (crime, act of violence, car crash), and the accuracy of their memory. It can prove accurate and invaluable to police investigations but it is also fallible. This research studies what about the testimony is reliable, why errors are made and how to make them more reliable. * Rattner reviewed 205 cases of "wrongful arrest" and found that in 52 % of cases, incorrect EWT had been to blame. * This could be due to Bartlett's theory of Reconstructive Memory. This is the idea that witnesses take original information (e.g. a folk story, as Bartlett studied in 1932), and use "effort after meaning" with their existing ideas, experience and cultural teachings (schemas). * Loftus said that certain situations improve the validity of EWT, which include proximity to the incident, racial similarities and the sobriety and emotional state of the witness. There are a lot of studies finding errors in EWT - Elizabeth Loftus, in 1979, found that Weapon Focus in a hostile situation detracts the witness from the description of the accused. Participants were exposed to two different situations, one being a minor argument in the adjacent room, a person then left that room covered in grease holding a pen.

  • Word count: 1286
  • Level: AS and A Level
  • Subject: Psychology
Access this essay

To a criminal psychologist, however, it is not just the external factors surrounding an eye witness' testimony that they would be interested in. the whole point of a witness testimony is to ask a witness

Behavioural Issues Coursework Student number-04003154 Kenneth Scott 25/11/05 Scottish criminal justice is a very complicated are of study. There are many different topics of thought that surround the Scottish criminal justice system, in terms of both physical and mental areas. The criminal justice system stems out into a number of different other subject areas mainly because criminal justice affects so many different fields in society. It's not just simply about police arresting criminals, the accused going to court and ending up the criminal goes to prison. There are many other extending factors connected with the process. There are many different officials involved each putting input into different areas of the process. As mentioned it is not just the police courts involved in the process but other types of people are influential in making the system work. Psychologists are an integral part on many different levels throughout the criminal process. They help people understand why a crime was committed and help other authorities with the convictions of accused people. There are number of things that psychologist can do to help in the conviction for example criminal profiling can be very useful when trying to catch a person. Also psychologists are used for research methods, trying to establish how important different aspects are. Eye witness testimony is

  • Word count: 2360
  • Level: GCSE
  • Subject: Psychology
Access this essay

Do leading questions have an effect on eye witness testimony?

Contents Page: * Abstract page 3 * Introduction page 3 * Method page 4 * Results page 6 * Discussion page 6 * Conclusion page 9 * References page 10 * Appendix page 11 Abstract The aim of this study was to research the effect of leading questions on eyewitness testimony. The hypothesis was that leading questions would have a significant effect on memory recall. This draws on results of a study by Loftus & Zanni whose research indicated that leading questions increase the number of incorrectly recalled details. Participants were selected by opportunity sampling. The chosen study group were given a briefing and told that they could leave at anytime if they wished to. The group watched a clip from Crimewatch UK, and completed a questionnaire based on their viewing. There were two forms of questionnaire. The first was a control questionnaire that did not include leading questions. It used the critical word 'a'. The second was an experimental questionnaire which used the critical word 'the', and which included five leading questions. The statistical

  • Word count: 3069
  • Level: University Degree
  • Subject: Biological Sciences
Access this essay

Eye witness testimony is so unreliable that it should never be used in convicting criminals. Discuss.

Psychology Assignment 1 "Eye witness testimony is so unreliable that it should never be used in convicting criminals" Eye witness testimony is a legal term. It refers to an account given by people of an event they have witnessed. Memory is very important for eye witness testimony. An accurate memory for an event can help lead to the conviction of a guilty person or the release of an innocent person wrongly convicted. Inaccurate memory can lead to the conviction of an innocent person or a failure to convict a guilty person, as the jury almost always believe the accounts of eye witness testimony; this was shown in the Devlin report where it is stated that eye witness testimony should never result in a conviction in an English court in the absence of other corroborating evidence. Research points show that eye witness testimony is highly inaccurate. Loftus and Palmer conducted extensive research over 30 years and found that eye witness testimony is vulnerable to many different types of influence. Research into eye witness testimony demonstrates that memories are quite fragile and subject to distortion by post-event information. Studies also indicate that misinformation can introduce serious errors into eyewitnesses' recall of the event. Bartlett challenged the idea of memory as a passive process, and suggested that memory is an active process rather than a "tape-recording"

  • Word count: 2041
  • Level: AS and A Level
  • Subject: Psychology
Access this essay

To what extent had psychological research shown Eye Witness Testimony to be reliable and accurate?

To what extent had psychological research shown Eye Witness Testimony to be reliable and accurate? There are many cases that both help and hinder the reliability and accuracy of EWT (Eye Witness Testimony). One experiment conducted by Loftus and Palmer showed strong results of unreliability and inaccuracy. They gathered a group of American students and showed them a video of a car accident. They then asked them several questions including "At what speed do you think the cars were going when they (hit/smashed/collided/bumped/contacted) each other?" Only one verb was used per participant. Loftus found that the estimated speed changed depending on the verb they used. The verb affected part of the participants' memory of the incident. This is strong evidence to show that EWT is highly unreliable as it can be affected by leading questions such as that of Loftus and Palmer's. But this theory can be criticised by the idea of demand characteristics. There is no way of knowing that the participants weren't subconsciously trying to please the experimenters by giving them the answer they think they wanted to hear. This would greatly affect the internal validity of the results. However, to combat this criticism, Loftus offered money for accuracy in the questions, therefore cancelling out the chance of demand characteristics having an effect. She found that the results were no different

  • Word count: 865
  • Level: AS and A Level
  • Subject: Psychology
Access this essay