And do we blame Superstition for what we come to pass? Or could it be what we, the English, have come to know as class?

Authors Avatar

And do we blame Superstition for what we come to pass? Or could it be what we, the English, have come to know as class?

The death of Edward and Mickey was very sudden and unpredictable but was it to do with superstition or class division?

Mrs Lyons convinced Mrs Johnstone that if the twins were to ever find out they were twins, they would immediately die. The strange thing is, when they did find out they were brothers, they were both dead in 90 seconds. Although Mrs Lyons only said that tall story to Mrs. Johnstone as threat and a precaution, it did actually happen. So, was their gruesome deaths due to superstition or class?

When Mickey shot Edward, was it on purpose or did it actually go off on it’s own accord? Did Mickey know the gun was loaded from the previous robbery for which he got sent to prison? Maybe Mickey purposefully shot Edward because he knows that if Mrs. Lyons chose him instead of Edward, he would have the easy life and Edward would be at the bottom of the barrel like Mickey. But on the other hand, would Mickey shoot his brother and long-time friend? Maybe Mickey was under the influence of the pills when he ran to nis mother’s home and took the gun from under the floorboards and blew Edward to pieces. All this we have to take into consideration.

Mrs Johnstone said to Mrs Lyons that she only had to shake hands with a man and she was pregnant whereas Mrs Lyons couldn’t have a baby no matter how hard she tried. I think the moment that decided both of their futures was when Mrs Lyons put new shoes on the coffee table and Mrs Johnstone said:

“We are just able to get along now.”

That one sentence together with the new shoes on the table was certainly going to bring some trouble to the suburbs of Liverpool. After Mrs Lyons put the new shoes on the table, Mrs Johnstone says:

“Oh God, Mrs Lyons, never put new shoes on a table....

You never know what’ll happen.”

And at that moment, the twins were born.

After that, the Narrator talks about salt being spilled, mirrors getting cracked and single magpies. Next, Mrs. Johnstone says twice that she is not superstitious but it is obvious that she is.

Poor people tend to be more superstitious because they have more things go wrong for them so they have to blame it on something. If Mrs Johnstone accidentally walked under a ladder and then came home to a house full of children with the flu, she would blame it on the ladder. These kind of people also believe in fate. Fate is when something is destined to happen and you can’t do anything about it. Mrs Johnstone probably believes it is fate that she has eight children. Mrs Lyons probably does not believe in fate because nothing has really gone wrong for her. She doesn’t believe in superstition because nothing has gone wrong for her to blame superstition on. She thinks Mrs Johnstone is silly for believing in superstition and Mrs Johnstone thinks Mrs Lyons is silly for not believing in it.

Join now!

The time Mrs Johnstone is due is the time when Mr Lyons comes back from his business trip. This places Mrs Lyons in a prime position and Mrs Johnstone into a “catch 22” situation.  Mrs Lyons convinces Mrs. Johnstone that she can’t afford two new children so she offers to buy one and tell Mr Lyons it was hers all along. If Mrs Johnstone says no, she would get fired, but if she says yes, she will regret it and although Mrs Lyons says she’ll see the baby all the time, she knows she won’t.

Mrs Johnstone decided ...

This is a preview of the whole essay