• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparative Essay Heaney-Clarke

Extracts from this document...


English Coursework Comparative Essay In 'Mid-Term Break' Seamus Heaney writes about a painful memory. Compare this poem with two others from this collection in which poets write about memories. Include one poem by Gillian Clarke and one poem from the Pre-1914 Bank. The painful memory that Seamus Heaney writes about is his brother's death and funeral and how it affects his family and social life. Gillian Clarke's poem is not about a painful memory but is more about the wonder of "inherited" memory (a memory which is passed down through the generations like a story) her poem though like Seamus Heaney's is about near death and its effects, even though Gillian Clarke is of no relation to the girl who nearly drowned, she is only included once her mother interferes. Ben Johnson is another painful memory and like the other two poems is about death, the death of his first born son. 'Cold Knap Lake', Gillian Clarke's poem and 'Mid-Term Break' by Seamus Heaney are both structured loosely and irregularly, they both use the technique of "stream of consciousness" this creates an effect that the poets are writing down what they feel at that precise time, the same effect is created by 'On My First Sonne' by Ben Johnson his structure is strict because it is in the form of a sonnet but it is not a traditional sonnet because it does not have 14 lines. ...read more.


All three poems 'Cold Knap Lake', 'Mid-Term Break' which are modern poems and 'On My First Sonne' which is a classical form of a sonnet, all these poems use literary techniques such as alliteration in 'Cold Knap Lake' some examples of this and the meanings behind them are "we once watched a crowd." The repeated sound of "w" and "ow" create a feel of water which is one of the main themes of 'Cold Knap Lake', there is also "drawn by the dread of it" creates a feeling of horror and fear, also the fact that people are curious about death. 'Mid- Term Break' also uses alliteration such as "counting bells knelling classes to a close" which is like the sound of bells, knelling is the sound of funeral bells so the poet being able to hear the sound of funeral bells all ready and it being near the beginning of the poem means that there is a strong atmosphere of tension and sorrow already. Also "four foot box a foot for every year" is a repeating of the "f" sound which is soft and sorrowful. There was also many uses of sibilance which is a form of alliteration but is the repetition of the "s" sound and is used to give a sense of evil or as in 'Cold Knap Lake' it is used to give ...read more.


'On My First Sonne' is mainly about losing something that is deeply loved, and the fear of loving something that much again only to be hurt. All three poems are about grief, death or near death. 'Mid-Term Break' is the death of his 4 year old brother and the personal close family. 'Cold Knap Lake' is about the near drowning of a young girl; it is impersonal, because the girl is a stranger and is distant. 'On My First Sonne' is of the death of his firstborn son. 'Mid-Term Break' and 'Cold Knap Lake' is about memory , it is a theme of 'Mid-Term Break' and is a central theme of 'Cold Knap Lake' the memory is sometimes elusive and full of "cloudiness" as portrayed in 'Cold Knap Lake' or is forever stuck in the mind as shown in 'Mid-Term Break', 'On My First Sonne' is about his son's death and he is never likely to forget it as he has promised to love nothing as dearly as he loved his son. In 'Mid-Term Break' another theme is death which is seen as cold and harsh by the words he uses such as "corpse" and "hard blow". Death in 'Cold Knap Lake' is described as beautiful and life as beautiful by words such as "rosy" or "dressed in waters green silk" All three poems are about loss and the effect it has on people and their memories. ?? ?? ?? ?? Hannah McVeigh 5W Miss Orrett ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Seamus Heaney section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Seamus Heaney essays

  1. Peer reviewed

    Compare the poems 'Mid-Term Break' by Seamus Heaney and ' 'Out Out- ' ' ...

    4 star(s)

    This cumulative effect of the language helps to create mood and atmosphere but also makes sure that the theme of the poem is clearly communicated and remembered throughout. The reader cannot escape from the theme of death as it is constantly mentioned.

  2. Compare the way the poets present the ideas of DEATH or LOSS in 'Mid-Term ...

    ironic, as the people that, like 'wolves' 'howl into silent telephones' get no reply other than a 'the Vodaphone you are calling is switched off' - and due to this 'their phones ring in the rubble'. This shows how the dead passengers of the train mobile phones are ringing 'in

  1. C/W Comparing The Poems; On My First Sonne, ...

    He seems to be a shell-shocked child in the first half of he poem, during the wake. It is the passage of time that enables him to find some new meaning for what has happened. It is only the 'next morning' when he realises what has happened: ''the copse' becomes 'him'.

  2. Compare how attitudes towards other people are shown in: Follower (Seamus Heaney), Catrin (Gillian ...

    'I was a nuisance'... 'But today it was my father who keeps stumbling.' These two lines, in the same stanza, cleverly show the injustice of the son's attitude and the use of enjambment-'All I ever did was follow In his broad shoulders...'

  1. Has its own individual outlook towards death. The three poems that I am studying ...

    coffin corresponds to his age - "a four foot box, a foot for every year." The line "a four foot box, a foot for every year" is important as the alliteration makes it sand out as a stanza on its own, telling the reader in a very indirect and pathetic way that the child was only 4.

  2. Using the four poems; 'Song of the old mother' by William Butler Yeats, 'On ...

    The labour experienced by both of them was probably a painful affair. The poet remembers the tight red rope of love we both fought over, which means they both want to cut the umbilical cord. The poet explains that even when the child is grown up she feels the tension between them still.

  1. Choose any two poems you feel have common theme (or themes). Write about them ...

    this, along with many other things: she may be angry with herself due to the fact that she wasn't there to protect her son, or she may be angry with God for taking her son away from her at such a young age.

  2. In 'Mid-Term Break, Heaney writes about death and loss. Compare the way Clarke and ...

    This sounds very innocent and is ignoring the fact that these harmful weapons are hurting people. So it emphasises the poem because at first everything is looking bad, and now at the end of the stanza, it's all been ignored.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work