Compare and contrast some of the short stories by Thomas Hardy paying particular attention to his depiction of & the role of women in the stories.

Authors Avatar
Compare and contrast some of the short stories by Thomas Hardy paying particular attention to his depiction of & the role of women in the stories.

The roles of Women in Hardy's short stories are contrasting and interesting at the same time.

In Hardy's lifetime many strong women surrounded him. His mother came from a poverty stricken background and was a servant until she married Hardy's father. She influenced his life heavily, as a mother figure and also she guided him into literature and arts. To his mother education was very important, therefore she proceeded to push him in that direction and make sure he got the schooling she didn't.

Some may see the women in Hardy's short stories to be dependent and they may seem to rely on men, but times were hard for women and they may have had to rely on men to survive.

In the stories we looked at as a class ("The Withered Arm", "Old Mrs Chundle", "Tony Kites") we can see a developing life unfold...

Teens=Tony Kites

20's=the withered arm (Gertude)

30's-40's=The Withered arm (Rhoda)

60's-Death=Old Mrs Chundle

In Tony Kites we see that the women all want this young "Handsome" man and he wants them all. However Tony is not that attractive. The text itself states "'Twas a little, round, firm, tight face, with a seam here and there left by the smallpox, but not enough to hurt his looks in a woman's eye, though he had it badish when he was a boy.". This suggests that Tony had some scars on his face and therefore he would not be extremely beautiful, or dashing, so then you have to look at why the women fancied him. Tony was very wealthy, he was a farmer's son and when we meet him he is on his way home from the market with an empty wagon, suggesting that he sold his entire product. The women are smart, they do like him but they need to be set up, so to speak, so they may do anything he asks to be with him, for example, hide in the back of his wagon while he gives a lift to another woman. They are portrayed as being dependent on the male species and at this time many women used tactics such as pregnancy...e.g. "I ask ye to have spirit to refuse him, if ye virtue is left to 'ee and you run no risk?"
Join now!


Mr Jolliver has asked his daughter if she is pregnant.

One woman who may have tried this tactic is one Rhoda Brook, she fell pregnant to Farmer Lodge and then it seems he didn't want her. Rhoda is a much stronger character than any of the women in Tony Kites. She has tried to get a steady life set up for her, she wanted a steady income a house and family, via a man but it didn't work out and now she is worse off, she has to work hard labour for a living and support her ...

This is a preview of the whole essay