• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and Contrast The Charge Of The Light Brigade with The Charge Of The Heavy Brigade Paying Particular Attention to the following

Extracts from this document...


Adam Fisch 4C Compare and Contrast The Charge Of The Light Brigade with The Charge Of The Heavy Brigade Paying Particular Attention to the following: The similarities and differences in poetic structure and language, The way in which Tennyson has used historical sources And Tennyson's portrayal of soldiers and generals at the time The two poems that I am looking at are 'the Charge of the Heavy the Brigade' and 'the Charge of the Light Brigade'. These two poems have been written by the same poet, Tennyson. Both of them were written shortly after battles fought consecutively in 1854 against the Russians. The poems are very specific, so much so that the 'Charge of the Heavy Brigade' has the date the battle took place as part of the title. The poem 'Charge of the Heavy Brigade' also mentions the name of specific leaders such as Scarlett. Both poems refer to the number of men in each brigade, the figures 600 and 300 are exact estimates of the men that fought in each battle. However Tennyson has rounded the figures to the closest hundred, so that they are easier for the reader to remember. The poems are similar in a few ways. When reading the poems the rhythm and the pace add to the sense of movement of horses, men throughout. For instance in both poems when the English are charging the pace accelerates and in ' the Charge of the Heavy Brigade', when the English move up a hill to reach the Russian position, the length of the lines increase and so it takes longer to finish the stanza, thus giving the illusion that there is an actual hill. ...read more.


We notice that in the 'Charge of the Light Brigade' Tennyson does not specifically name the enemy as Russian. Instead it seems that Tennyson is suggesting the enemy is more the 'someone' who 'blunder'd'. Throughout the 'Charge of the heavy Brigade' there is much emphasis on the individual Scarlett and Tennyson stresses that the 300 men in the 'Charge of the Heavy Brigade' are his men not any one else's. It is specifically Scarlett who inspires 'the gallant three hundred' onward into battle and the fray. This is the opposite of the 'Charge of the Light Brigade' as in the second stanza it implies that the soldiers went into battle against their own 'reason' as it is not 'theirs' to 'make reply'. Instead the soldiers follow the orders and we are told that 'boldly they rode and well'. In the sixth stanza when Tennyson asks the reader to 'Honour the Light brigade', it is to honour the ordinary men not the officer who made the order. The 'Charge of the Light Brigade' has no hero as such but creates all the soldiers who died as equals, elevating them to the position of heroes by the end of the poem. Despite mentioning the Russians in the fourth stanza of 'Charge of the Light Brigade' we are left with the impression that the 'Noble 600' are in fact fighting against fate, and fighting against 'Death'. In this poem, the tragic loss of lives are made more important and it would seem that Tennyson does this by showing that even though they might fight bravely they do not have a chance in the 'valley of Death'. ...read more.


The enemy are driven into 'wild disarray' and leave 'over the brow and away'. Unlike the 'Charge of the Light Brigade' the 'Charge of the Heavy Brigade' also uses longer lines to build tension towards the climax of the battle however we are never in doubt of the Heavy brigade's success as by repeating the words 'up the hill' Tennyson implies that the English are winning ground. In the 'Charge of the Light Brigade' by repeating the words 'valley of Death' we are presented with a lasting image as Tennyson implies that there is no hope for the light brigade. Despite their bravery as the light brigade rides on 'into the jaws of Death' we feel as if they are trapped in a situation they cannot escape from. The 'Charge of the Light Brigade' relies on repetition and the equal lengths of lines which make the poem shorter and more to the point. In the 'Charge of the Heavy Brigade' Tennyson is able to create atmosphere by manipulating pace and sound. Whilst both poems deal with the subject of war they do so in very different ways and although the 'Charge of the Heavy Brigade' is a poem of celebration the 'Charge of the Light Brigade' is contained, precise and arguably more realistic as Tennyson reveals to us that they did not die by the hand of the enemy but that lives were lost through the mistake made by one person. The 'Charge of the Light Brigade' leaves a greater impression on the reader and we are more likely to remember the 600 who died as they are immortalised by Tennyson's words. 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE War Poetry section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE War Poetry essays

  1. Compare and contrast The Man He Killed by Thomas Hardy and the The Charge ...

    'The Charge Of The Light Brigade' has an uneven rhyme scheme. Only a few lines rhyme with each other and it is not constant throughout the poem. A good example of this is 'Half a league, half a league.' The first word has more stress and emphasis on it and you put less on the next two words.

  2. Explore the similarities and differences between "The charge of the light brigade" and "The ...

    It updates the poem "The charge of the light brigade" to explain how the conditions they have to live in are appalling as they are now starving and forgotten as no one will spare change to the men behind this country.

  1. Analyse the techniques and literary devices used by the author in "Charge of the ...

    There is a rhyme scheme with three lines in each stanza rhyming together. There is another rhythm, continuing throughout the story; hoof beats of the horses in battle are heard with a series of words as the poem is read.

  2. Compare and contrast how the poets convey their attitudes to war

    of stanza; "The wise hyenas come out at eve, to take account of our dead". This gives the poem another edge to it. Also the poet says "our dead". This means he is related to the dead in some shape or form, whether it be country or son.

  1. charge of the light brigade essay

    The brief victory that was gained in the fourth stanza has made no difference in the overall scope of the battle. The first time these words were used though, they ended with a claim of the soldiers' boldness and skill: this time, they end with the soldiers being shot down.

  2. 'The Charge Of The Light Brigade' - analysis

    'Sabering the gunners there', it sounds as if the British were winning the battle but they were not. The word 'plunged' sounds like the charge is force full and almost reckless 'plunged in the battery-smoke' meaning going in boldly. They broke the Russian line of defence.

  1. Comparing and contrasting "The charge of the Light Brigade" and "The Defence of Lucknow" ...

    "Forward, the Light Brigade! Was there a man dismayed?" (The Charge of The Light brigade, S: 2) This verse also includes a rhetorical question which notifies us that the soldiers were fully prepared to seek orders and act upon them without any hesitation. This shows how obedient and loyal they were.

  2. How is the theme conflict presented by Alfred Tennyson in The Charge Of The ...

    Even with the disbelief by the stupidity of the order, Tennyson?s respect for the soldiers and their duty does not diminish. The unjustified violence of the Crimean war and the horror of ?The Charge of the Light Brigade? is definitely shown in many stanza?s in the poem.? Into the jaws of Death, Into the mouth of h**l?.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work