• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month
Page
  1. 1
    1
  2. 2
    2
  3. 3
    3
  4. 4
    4
  5. 5
    5

Compare and contrast the treatment of the play Hamlet by the directors Franco Zeffirelli and Kenneth Branagh, concentrating on the last scene from the words "The readiness is all" to "The rest is silence."

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Compare and contrast the treatment of the play Hamlet by the directors Franco Zeffirelli and Kenneth Branagh, concentrating on the last scene from the words "The readiness is all" to "The rest is silence." Focus on the stagecraft and importantly the presentation of character and the language spoken. Many events have occurred in this complex play to put the main character, young Hamlet, in the position and frame of mind in which he finds himself at the beginning of the last scene of the play. Only months ago, his father died, seemingly from natural causes leaving everyone grief stricken. Yet within two months, Hamlet's mother Gertrude had re-married - to Hamlets uncle Claudius! Then the ghost of Hamlets father appears to him and tells him that Claudius murdered him and that he wants Hamlet to avenge his death. Hamlet also has a place in his heart for the beautiful Ophelia in whom he cannot trust. Hamlet cleverly proves Claudius' guilt but manages to stab Ophelia's father Polonius instead who is hiding behind a tapestry in Gertrude's room. Hamlet is then banished by Claudius to England where he is supposed to be beheaded. Meanwhile Ophelia goes mad with grief and drowns just after her brother Laertes comes home. Claudius receives word that Hamlet is on his way home so he and Laertes (who seeks to avenge the deaths of his father and his sister) plot to kill him upon his return. Hamlet gets back to find it is Ophelia's funeral and he grieves for her. ...read more.

Middle

Branagh's 18th-19th century setting however called for the foils and they were much more suitable. But the heavy clashing together of the swords in Zeffirelli's adaptation, was much more dramatic and some how more fitting to the events enfolding in the scene. The pearl and the goblet are also props in the scene but are not really seen. The goblets suited their setting and a pearl is after all a pearl. Acting: The acting styles of the two actors playing the part of Hamlet (Mel Gibson and Kenneth Branagh) are very different. Gibson does much better at getting the moody, contemplative and quintessentially mad sides of Hamlet's character across and I feel is more like the Hamlet you read on the page. Branagh's Hamlet is very 'stiff upper lip' and military. He also over accentuates the role. He is not the Hamlet written in Shakespeare's script but he does convey the side of Hamlet we forget - the fact that he is the son of a king brought up to face war. Branagh heavily portrays this side of him. Claudius (played by Alan Bates in the Zeffirelli movie and by Derek Jacobi in the Branagh movie), is much the same as Hamlet's character in the Branagh, very 'stiff upper lip'. Zeffirelli's Claudius is much more frivolous and a bit of a wastrel - less like a king and more like a stupid young man with too much power. Gertrude (played by Glen Close in the Zeffirelli movie and by Julie Christie in the Branagh movie), is at two ends of a long scale in the different movies. ...read more.

Conclusion

Imagine someone who is not very into Shakespeare - they would think this was the funniest thing they'd ever seen - but then they probably wouldn't sit through 3 and a half hours worth of film in a language they barely understand. To get anything from this movie you have to be very committed to Shakespeare indeed. This film may have been accurate to a fault when it came to using Shakespeare's language, but when it came to doing things the way Shakespeare intended - they're way off the mark. Any of Shakespeare's plays that are made into films should still hold the key essence of a play at their very heart. Zeffirelli does this very well. In the Zeffirelli movie you can really get the essence of what Shakespeare is about. Even though a lot of Shakespeare's original words were cut out, the film still carried the story beautifully. The film is much shorter and easier to watch. For someone not used to Shakespeare this is a good film to watch and that is essentially what makes a film successful - its audience appeal. Overall the two movies are very different and no two people would draw the same conclusions as I. They show superbly how differently the same tale can be interpreted. It gives you a better chance to look at the play through someone else's eyes and not just how you see it and interpret it. For me however I preferred the Zeffirelli movie because it kept that play like feel to it and is more true to the way Shakespeare told this story of revenge and tragedy. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Hamlet section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Hamlet essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Hamlet Film and Play Comparison. Zeffirelli made some changes in Hamlet that do ...

    3 star(s)

    Because of this, Hamlet emerges as a more aggressive and active character in the movie. While the movie plot line stays the same, by eliminating Hamlet's Hecuba soliloquy from the movie, the audience is oblivious to Hamlet's uncertainty and unconfidence and instead getting the impression that Hamlet is a bold and frisky character.

  2. Peer reviewed

    Shakespeare's presentation of Hamlet

    3 star(s)

    The Ghost significantly tells him at the end, "Remember me" which burdens Hamlet with the responsibility of duty and honour. Hamlet's knows of the corruption, describing that there is "something rotten in the state of Denmark" and even uses the metaphor, "Denmark's a prison".

  1. Analyse the ways in which Shakespeare uses the dramatic monologue to trace the development ...

    The comparison to the battle also means that Hamlet can either be passive or active, which is a choice he has been struggling with throughout the play. The opening line of the soliloquy, 'To be or not to be' shows that Hamlet is despairing in life and is willing for it all to end.

  2. How does Shakespeare portray changes in Hamlets character in soliloquy one and four

    and most importantly a role model in his life and therefore has no one to look up to and to guide him. Shakespeare uses many techniques throughout the beginning of the play to form Hamlets character and to effect his emotions.

  1. With reference to key lines and speeches in the play, discuss interpretations of the ...

    Not much is seen of her in daily activity, but we can imagine her as a woman fascinated by trinkets and gifts, and enjoying the material pleasures of life. This however does not make her a bad person. She reserves her deepest love for her son, and despite her shallow

  2. Direct Actor Playing Macbeth

    he should say in a sort of trance, or rave. I think this because he would be so shocked about what he has just done, so the murder would not have sunk in yet.

  1. How Does Shakespeare Convey a Sense of Anomie in Hamlet Act 1, and to ...

    Or if thou hast up hoarded in thy life extorted treasure in the womb of earth, for which, they say, you spirits oft walk in death, Speak of it: stay, and speak!" What Horatio is asking the ghost, is whether he has indeed come to warn of a terrible event,

  2. Shakespeare has written Ophelia as the prominent female in the play. Is this because ...

    He speaks in a cold way to Ophelia about this. Laertes obviously cares a lot for his sister and wants to protect her. He shows this in this scene. This scene is just one of many in Hamlet where men have more authority and knowledge than women.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work