• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and Contrast the Ways in Which the Two Poets Present Their Memories

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Compare and Contrast the Ways in Which the Two Poets Present Their Memories "Parliament Hill Fields" and "I Remember, I Remember" are poems involving memories of the poets. They approach nostalgia in different ways, however, therefore producing contrasting results within the poems. In "I Remember, I Remember" the situation he is in forces the poet into his memories, whereas, in "Parliament Hill Fields", the poet is looking back of his own accord. This results in a difference between the moods of the poems, giving "I Remember, I Remember" a more resentful tone that comes from being forced into his memories by visiting his birthplace. This is ironic, as, the title suggests "I Remember"-a voluntary act, but the feeling given is that the poet does not want to remember these things. Also, the repetition in the title suggests a certain level of wistfulness that demonstrates yet more irony, as these are definitely not fond memories for the poet. The tones of the two poems contrast one another for the duration of the poems. "I Remember, I Remember" is a bitter poem, depicting the poet's unhappy memories of childhood or even his sour feelings towards his memories. These feelings were apparent at the start of the poem as Larkin travels "by a different line for once". ...read more.

Middle

Another way in which Betjeman tries to make the images seem grander is in his poetic diction. He alters the syntax on numerous occasions like "in Virginia creeper drown" and "train and tram alternate go". This gives an archaic sound to the poem, which leads to grandness as it seems rich and has a more poetic feel than if the proper word order was used. The issue of pity appears in both poems. With Betjeman, he pities the lives of others, but Larkin demonstrates self-pity in his poem. The pity in "Parliament Hill Fields" is shown in the lines "And my childish wave of pity, seeing children carrying down Sheaves of drooping dandelions to the courts of Kentish Town". There is ambiguity in the real meaning of these lines. It is possible that he pities himself here, although, by following the statement about pity with references to the children, it isn't that likely. It could be that it is a simple case of him pitying the children for how hard their lives are, or for how meagre their existence in comparison to his life "up the hill" and away from poverty. He might pity the children for being so na�ve as to take "drooping dandelions" (worthless weeds) to their mothers, thinking they will be pleased at this. ...read more.

Conclusion

This leaves the reader feeling contented. "I Remember, I Remember" seems to end quite flippantly with "Oh well, I suppose it's not the place's fault". By saying "Oh well", Larkin seems to be dismissive. It seems odd to me that, after writing of how he resents his past, he can just forget it so quickly. It could be that he is being philosophical and does not want to dwell on the things that are in the past. The poet could also feel that as it is in the past, there is nothing that can be done about it now. This is contradictory to the meaning of the rest of the poem as it makes you wonder why he was thinking so much about his life if he can just dismiss it all in a single comment at the end. By also saying that "it's not the place's fault", Larkin lays the blame on himself for his childhood and fate. This also contradicts the rest of the poem, as he was previously blaming anyone but himself. In conclusion, I can say that Larkin presents his memories in a very bitter way, thus creating the feeling that he was unhappy as a child. Betjeman, however, presents his memories in a more nostalgic way and the way in which he wrote the poem makes every aspect of the memories seem grand. This indicates that he is happy with the memories he has. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE John Betjeman section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE John Betjeman essays

  1. "Childhood in all aspects is extremely important to Betjeman." Choose Three Poems That Show ...

    He is scared of the house and has to run as quickly as he can to avoid it and get past it so he can reach the party. "Made a rush for the next kind lamp-post out of the dark."

  2. Could The Suicide be The Executive after a life of failure?

    He's trying to say he is so successful and rich he can afford all these expensive, modern items like by saying 'I've got a scarlet Aston Martin-and does she go? She flies!', he chose the colour scarlet so his car stands out and everyone takes notice of him.

  1. Poems by John Betjeman

    contrasts greatly to 'Devonshire Street' which has solid and hard words like 'mahogany, wrought-iron, brick, Edwardian.' Betjeman portrays his ideas of love as 'love so pure it had to end', which makes me feel sad, as he has obviously been given the wrong impression about love.

  2. We have been giving to 20th century poems to examine. They are "Evans" by ...

    The nurse says to the woman that tea is ready, and tells her to wake up. The writer says, "Oh chintzy, chintzy cheeriness, half dead and half alive." She said those things in a halfhearted manner, not really meaning them at all, just doing her job like she usually does.

  1. With close reference to two poems you've studied, show how specific places provide Betjeman ...

    The town is eating its way into nearby villages but Betjeman asks 'it' to spare rural Middlesex, as it is paradise compared with London as he portrays in the first verse: 'Out into the outskirts edges Where a few surviving hedges Keep alive our lost Elysium-rural Middlesex again.'

  2. Compare and contrast 'Slough' and 'Belfast Confetti' - Comment on the poetic devices used ...

    A meaning that could be taken from this is that sentences are one of a few things that differ us from animals. The fact that he was "trying to complete a sentence in his head" speaks volumes about his state of mind at the time.

  1. How does Betjeman convey his attitude towards Slough?

    The rhythm of the poem is also Iambic Pentameter which means that Betjeman has used this to make the stresses of each line land on important words such as 'bombs', 'blow' and 'mess' so these words are emphasised when reading the poem, and stand out so they are noticed more.

  2. Compare and Contrast the Poetry of James Berry and John Betjeman, with particular reference ...

    Lucy feels she can relate to her because she feels alienated too. Lucy ends the poem with the Jamaican proverb, "Bird sing sweet for its nest," meaning you should stick to what you're suited to. When Lucy travels back to Jamaica, she realises it has changed and nothing is as she remembered it.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work