Compare and Contrast ways in which the supernatural is conveyed and used to maintain the reader's interest in 'The Signal Man' and 'The Red Room' - Refer to any other nineteenth century stories you have read.

Authors Avatar

Compare and Contrast ways in which the supernatural is conveyed and used to maintain the reader's interest in 'The Signal Man' and 'The Red Room'. Refer to any other nineteenth century stories you have read.

Both of the stories are very gripping and keep you in apprehension throughout When it comes to ghost stories, both hold the general key to a first-class mystery. They both take a slow approach to getting to the main climax, which encourages you to keep reading. Both the stories are traditional horror stories.

In a traditional horror story, horror is usually presented through gothicism or a psychological aspect of horror. Both of these techniques are used in 'The Red Room' and 'The Signalman' and is also popular with such writers as Poe in the story 'The Tell-Tale Heart' and in the story 'The Monkey's Paw' by W.W. Jacobs.

Both of the stories have a twist at the end, which gives each a sense of individuality. In 'The Signalman', by Charles Dickens, the twist is all that there seems to be a mysterious connection between the spectre and all the other characters which I found to be quite disturbing. However the most significant connection appears to be between the narrator and the spectre in that the narrator repeats the words that the signalman hears from the spectre. The clue that there is a connection is given at the beginning of the story when the narrator and signalman first meet. The narrator, when he first saw the signalman shouted down to him the words, 'Halloa below there', and in departing the signalman asked him what made him say those exact words.

'You had no feeling that they were conveyed to you in any supernatural way?'

This shows that there must have been some connection between the spectre and the narrator as on their first meeting the signalman senses something strange or even ghostly about the narrator's manner and words, and clearly feels a connection or else he would not have asked. The signalman also says at one point that he mistook the narrator for someone else, the spectre. Also when the signalman tells the narrator of his troubles with the spectre, he shows him the action that he makes every time he appears, In the narrator's mind he thought of the action as saying 'for God's sake, clear the way'. Now what may seem as a coincidence, but is really the connection between the characters is the fact that the warnings of the driver to the signalman before he was cut down were the exact words which had haunted the signalman and the narrator's thoughts of what the actions of the spectre meant.

Join now!

The signalman's appearance is quite peculiar as is his behavier. He looks at the bell when I does not ring and talks of a ghost. His eyebrows are thick and his skin tone is odd. Painting a picture of a mysterious looking man who is a little melodramatic, this technique is also used in 'The Red Room'. We too feel, the desperation and distraction of his ordeal. He 'wiped the drops from his forehead' showing his nerves, and so making us feel nervous.

Dickens' portrayal of the tunnel and the cutting is very detailed. The words 'dark' and 'gloomy' get an ...

This is a preview of the whole essay