• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare how Willy Russell portrays the two mothers in Blood Brothers. Account for the different reactions the audience will have toward the two women throughout the play.

Extracts from this document...


Compare how Willy Russell portrays the two mothers in Blood Brothers. Account for the different reactions the audience will have toward the two women throughout the play. Blood Brothers, a play set in the Liverpool of the 1960's and 70's. It portrays the lives of two boys, who are "of one womb born, on the self same day" but also of "how one was kept and one given away". It all ends in tragedy, that much is said but a much bigger issue hides in the lines. What does, exactly make a good person? And it also raises the ever present problem of class. Not a single society has ever conquered class there will always be division between those stronger or cleverer or those born into the right circumstances, with the right opportunities and the right money. Even communist Russia which aimed to bridge the social gap and make all things equal only succeeded in creating even greater extremes of poverty and wealth. Each end of the scale is represented throughout the play in the form of the two mothers, Mrs. Johnstone being lower class and Mrs. Lyons being higher. They both have things going for them but it's almost a race to see who can bring up the better son, but how can you measure success. What is success? Is it love or money or happiness perhaps? All of these things were getting pretty hard to come by in 1970's Liverpool its docks and traditional manufacturing industries were in sharp decline. ...read more.


you may not have thought possible from a woman who seems to think of her baby as a possesion "Edward is my son, mine!". But did Mrs Lyons bring about her own selfproclaimed ruin? Her love of her son or maybe just fear of losing him made her paranoid and her paranoia about her sons discovery of the truth made her a bad mother perhaps. We also see her becoming perhaps becoming less rational believing in the superstition she once scorned Mrs. Johnstone for which suggests her lacking the common sense she used to have, putting Mrs Johnstone's little superstitions down to a lack of education or a sign of the society in which she was brought up. But a chracter has to be presented a certain way for it to change. We are introduced to the two mothers very early in the play, Mrs Johnstone first. Instantly the audience like Mrs Johnstone and dislike Mrs Lyons. We see Mrs Johnstone falling from glory. This fall is illustrated by the use of Marilyn Monroe as a kind of benchmark, one minute she is "sexier than Marilyn Monroe" next she's "twice the size of Marilyn Monroe". The audience see she has her heart in the right place and has been ditched by her good for nothing husband, They sympathize with her struggling to pay the milkman with many hungry mouthes to feed. However on the other end of the scale Mrs Lyons can't have any children, it's all she lacks in her apparently perfect world and perhaps that's why she gains ...read more.


Where as Mrs Lyons seems to be fairly well educated, we see her argue her way out of tight spots like when her husband gets suspicious when she snaps a Mrs Johnstone for wanting to hold the baby, he says "don't be hard on the woman" but Mrs Lyons comes back saying that she dosen't want the baby to catch anything as if to imply that her husband cares for their child less than her and then guilt trips him further by looking as if "she is about to cry" in the stage directions. This is meditated, she knows what she is doing and it shows clear inteligence. Mrs Johnstone could probably make more use out of Mrs Lyons education in the work place than she ever would being a house wife and this clear advantage and the way it is put across to look so unfair allow Mrs Johnstone to be viewed as the clear underdog and everyone loves an underdog. I think that Mrs Lyons is made out to be the villain of this tale but really its just the writer manipulating the audiences emotions. It could probably easily be turned around and Mrs Lyons be made the hero. Willy Russell presents the two mothers as total opposties in class but they do share one thing their mutual love of Eddie. He portrays Mrs Johnstone in a very favourable light and Mrs Lyons in a negative one. This has a huge effect on the way the audience relate to and feel about the two different charaters. Positive or negative it is all engineered by the writer. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Blood Brothers section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Blood Brothers essays

  1. Peer reviewed

    Compare how Willy Russell portrays the two families in 'Blood Brothers' and account for ...

    3 star(s)

    I've got to go to work for an hour'. Mrs Lyons doesn't like Edward to go off for too long as she is scared about what might happen to her precious child, 'I've told you never to go where that boy- where boys like that live.' The houses that both families live in are very different as Mrs Johnstone lives in a small council house, 'We're moving away.'

  2. How does Willy Russell explore the themes of class and society in Blood Brothers?

    This sent Mickey into a rage and he eventually shot Edward. "The gun explodes and blows Edward apart." The police then shot Mickey "They open fire and four guns explode, blowing Mickey away". The narrator utters a few words and this would cause a great amount of tension as he

  1. How has Willy Russell portrayed Mrs. Johnstone and Mrs. Lyons in Blood Brothers? How ...

    'Then, I'm afraid,' this shows she is dreading the idea of what is going to happen. She should have a dreading, saddening face on and look as though she is about to burst into tears. I think the lighting should position a spot light on the babies and Mrs.

  2. Compare how Willy Russell portrays the two mothers in Blood Brothers. Account for the ...

    At the beginning of the play, the Narrator describes Mrs. Johnstone as, "the mother, so cruel" but perhaps this is not what we are led to think of Mrs. Johnstone. This is because further on the play we get to learn about Mrs.

  1. How are the mothers presented in the play Blood Brothers and how does the ...

    "You won't tell anyone, Mrs Johnstone, because if you do you shall kill them!", this shows the audience how Mrs Lyons manages to prevent the mother from doing anything reckless and she also gives the mother a guilty conscience about how if anything happened to the twins then it would all be Mrs Johnstone's fault.

  2. Examine how Willy Russell presents the nature/nurture debate in Blood Brothers.

    'I know what you are. You're a fuckoff! MRS LYONS: You learn filth from them and behave like a horrible little boy, like them.' Mickey's bad behaviour and foul mouth began to rub off on Eddie. Mrs.Lyons, being the over protective mother she was, was also worried of losing her precious son.

  1. Blood Brothers interview with Willy Russell

    Though, really, it is the decisions made by individuals, which determine if you have a good life or not. Mrs. Lyons eventually collapses psychologically; she has lived with a life full of paranoia because of her decision to force Mrs.

  2. How does Russell present superstition as a driving force in Blood Brothers?

    This stage direction shows that Mrs Johnstone's belief is so strong that even a superstition she's never heard of can control her life. However, superstiton is not the only driving force in Mrs Johnstone's life. Her decision to give Edward to Mrs Lyons is also motivated by social class.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work