comparing poetry

Authors Avatar

Nisha Taylor 10SH                                             Mr Phelan

Compare the way in which different poets present the theme of growing up.

 There is many poem written on the theme of growing up which show poets own experiences and there observations of others. Through study of  ‘Growing Pains’ by Vernon Scannell, ‘In Mrs Tilscher’s Class’ by Carol Ann Duffy, ‘The Early Purges’ and ‘Mid Term Break’ by Seamus Heaney it can be clearly seen how poets use many different poetic techniques to create a tone and atmosphere in the poem that causes a certain reaction in the reader, such as emotive language, sensory imagery and form and structure of the poem.  

‘Growing pains’ describes a five year old boy and his first experience of love and heartbreak for Jessica. The father does not know what to do about the situation because of this he follows his instincts. The boy does not understand what this new feeling is. The poem is written in the first person from the father’s point of perspective.

In contrast ‘In Mrs Tilscher’s class’ describes the girls own memories of the primary school and her teacher ‘Mrs Tilscher’. The poem is in first person from the girls perspective. As in ‘Growing Pains’ It shows how her feelings change as she experiences some thing new, she is told a thing from a rough boy ’how you were born,’ At the beginning of the she felt safe and at the end of the poem she feels insecure and worried like the little in ‘Growing pains’

Like ‘In Mrs Tilscher‘s Class‘ ‘The Early Purges’ describes a boys child hood memories. He is remembers animals being killed on a farm and he is upset and confused because of the kittens being killed he does not understand it is similar to the little boy in ‘Growing Pains’ As he gets older he is beginning to accept that killing animals is essential to “keep pests down” so that the farm can run efficiently. The poem is written in the first person from the boys point of view.

Join now!

‘Mid Term Break’ also describes a young boys reaction to death it describes and young boys memories after his four year old brother has died being Knocked over by a car.  The poet describes that he sees when he comes home and how he feels. He to does full understand what is happening. The poem is written in the first person from the boy’s perspective.

In ‘Growing Pains’ The theme of love runs through the poem. The father’s love for his son is shown by ‘I covered him up and stroked his head.’  this shows  protecting and ...

This is a preview of the whole essay