Comparing Shakespeare and his sonnet, 'Shall I compare thee to a summer's day', The well known poet and songwriter of the Jacobean age John Donne and his poem 'The Flea', and the well known American poet Walt Whitman and his poem 'To a Stranger'.

Authors Avatar

Love is a theme which seems to be unescapable. It is in everyday life and it affects everyone. Love has been a topic of much of the great literature which we keep in high esteem. Thus it is an ideal theme to do as the three poems being analysed are pieces of great literature, mainly from the cannon of literature. In this lecture the poets being analysed are the immoral poet and play writer of the Elizabethan age, Shakespeare and his sonnet, ‘Shall I compare thee to a summer’s day’, The well known poet and songwriter of the Jacobean age John Donne and his poem ‘The Flea’, and the well known American poet Walt Whitman and his poem ‘To a Stranger’.

‘Shall I compare thee to a summer’s day’ was one of William Shakespeare’s most famous sonnets. It was written in the Elizabethan Age which was from 1588 – 1603.

In the Elizabethan age it was customary for gentleman to write love sonnets about their lover and give it to them. As William Shakespeare was a brilliant poet and play writer of that age he was thought of to be the ideal English Renaissance man and was thought of very highly by nobles of the land.  

Shakespeare’s upbringing was irregular to that of someone else in his position. His father John Shakespeare was a Glover and leather merchant which was not a highly paid position. His mother Mary Arden was a landed heiress which allowed for some benefits to come to Shakespeare including free schooling at the Grammar school in Stratford. This gave Shakespeare a high reputation. Also as his father John was a Stratford official which allowed for high tuition for his son. This high education was an influential factor of Shakespeare’s life as it gave a good education so the standard of poetry was at a much higher level, also it gave him the feeling of superiority and capability among people so that he felt free to create his own sonnet structure. As his early life was care free his poetry was mainly on love.

The sonnet “Shall I compare thee to a summer’s day” was written about a woman Shakespeare loved. In the sonnet he describes the beauty of the woman and he debates whether or not to compare her to a summer’s day. The sonnet shows how strong Shakespeare’s feelings were for his lover. His emotions come over through his disguised and obvious compliments and contrasts. He thinks she is beautiful and, unlike a summer’s day, her perfection will not fade, as this sonnet is written to illustrate and capture the woman’s beauty and the love he has for her. The sonnet is typical for the era as it was common for gentleman to write love sonnets about their lover and give it to them.

Join now!

Shakespeare wrote one hundred and fifty four sonnets and due to their consistent quality. His sonnets were in the style known as ‘the Shakespearean sonnet form’.  A Shakespearean sonnet has fourteen lines, broken down into three quatrains and ending with a rhyming couplet.

In each quatrain a different subject is discussed and described, the subject is then changed at the start of each new quatrain.

A Shakespearean sonnet has the rhyming pattern ABABCDCDEFEFGG.

For example in ‘Shall compare thee to a summer’s day’, the first quatrain shows this rhyming pattern, it is at the beginning so is the ABAB ...

This is a preview of the whole essay