Comparison between the poem Nothings Changed and the poem Two Scavengers in a Truck

Authors Avatar

Bradley Cox - 10H

Mr Reeve – English

                

Comparison between the poem ‘Nothing’s Changed and the poem ‘Two Scavengers in a Truck’

The poem ‘Nothing’s Changed’ depicts a society where rich and poor, black and white are divided. The poem ‘Two Scavengers in a Truck’ however, shows the contrast between two lifestyles, rich and poor and the continuing gap.

Both poems demonstrate ‘unfairness’ and ‘inequality’. In the poem ‘Nothing’s Changed’ this is a typical scenario that took place in the apartheid era of racial segregation in South Africa where laws were enforced by the police keeping apart black and white people. The poet looks at attempts to change the racism taking place in his community, and shows how they don’t make the slightest bit of difference. However, in the poem ‘Two Scavengers in a Truck’, the poet tries to show how the poor are being made out to be the ones who are the least important, and have the low class jobs. On the other hand, the rich being the ‘beautiful’ ones driving in a Mercedes have the upper class well paid jobs as architects.

  The writer of the poem ‘Nothing’s Changed’ comes back to the village years later to find that literally nothing has changed, there are still lots of wasteland and bulldozed areas which have occurred because of the forces of segregation. He states that even after the victory of democracy and the anti-apartheid government coming into action, nothing has changed and the fact that racism is still all around him and dissimilarity still exists.  Whilst I believe that the poem ‘Two Scavengers in a Truck’ is much simpler, for instance in places it is written as if in vivid key colours, so we automatically see the phrases “yellow garbage truck” and the “red plastic blazers”. We distinguish the specific arrangement of the group of diverse people, all waiting at a stoplight and the bin men are looking down into the “elegant open Mercedes”, and the rich elegant couple within.

Join now!


I feel that the poet’s background affects the views and opinions that they express in each of the poems, firstly looking at the poem ‘Nothing’s Changed’ which was written by Tatamkhula Afrika who was born and bred by a Turkish mother and an Arabian father in Egypt. At the age of two Tatamkhula was orphaned and later fostered by white South Africans. In South Africa at the time, black people were treated unfairly whereas white people had an advantage over black people, they were treated fairly. Tatamkhula was treated fairly because of his pale skin; he didn’t want to ...

This is a preview of the whole essay