• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparison of ‘My Last Duchess’ with ‘Porphyria’s Lover’, by Robert Browning.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Comparison of 'My Last Duchess' with 'Porphyria's Lover', by Robert Browning. Both these poems were written in the mid-1800s, by Robert Browning, and are examples of his earlier works. He was one of the pioneers of the dramatic monologue form, which is used in both the poems. Browning described the dramatic monologue form as "Action in character, rather than character in action." He means that the personality and thoughts of the character are revealed in the poem, and it is not centered on their actions. The form allows the poet to hide behind a fictitious first person speaker. In these poems, the persona reveals aspects of his life through suggested and hidden narrative, rather than directly spoken. 'Porphyria's lover' is the monologue of a man, in love with a woman named Porphyria. The man knows he cannot keep Porphyria for ever, and so takes drastic steps in order for Porphyria to always be his. 'My Last Duchess' is a monologue by a 16th century Italian Renaissance Duke, showing the emissary of a count around his court, and subtly conveying the emissary a warning about his previous duchess. The two speakers that Browning uses, the Duke, and Porphyria's lover, are distinctly different. ...read more.

Middle

Although Porphyria's lover does kill her, there is still a tenderness and emotion in his monologue that is not apparent in 'My Last Duchess'. The lover seems capable of more emotion than the duke. It was the lover who sat in the cold cottage in a storm, and 'listened with heart fit to break' for Porphyria's return. The Duke, however, only has the faded memory of his anger and jealousy towards the Duchess. The poem does not serve as a picture of the Dukes emotions, just to show us the warning to the emissary, the silent listener of the poem These differences of outlook also show themselves in the way that the Duke and the lover murder their respective women. The Duke kills his duchess out of hatred and jealousy. He tells the emissary: 'I gave commands And then all smiles stopped together.' This method of murder, simply giving commands to another man is extremely impersonal compared to that of Porphyria. Porphyria's lover killed her with emotion, and debatably, he killed her out of love. He simply 'found a thing to do': 'All her hair In one yellow string I wound Three times her little throat around And strangled her.' ...read more.

Conclusion

The Duchess especially seems innocent, as the Duke tells the emissary that 'The white mule/She rode with round the terrace.' A white mule is symbolic, as white represents purity, and a mule is sterile, and so represents chastity. This subtext reinforces the idea that the murder of the Duchess was not necessary. On a similar note, when Porphyria enters into the lover's cottage, she removes 'her soiled gloves'. This indicates that Porphyria, unlike the duchess, lacks purity. It also highlights the fact that this may be an illicit relationship. There is not much more revealed about the women in the poetry than what has already been mentioned. This is because the main focus of the poems is the actions and mentality of the men, and so it is easier for the women to be simple but charming creatures. Due to the form of these poems, we do not learn anything about the views and attitude of Robert Browning, the poet. He has, however, used literary devices such as pathetic fallacy to help convey the hidden subtexts of the poems to the readers. The differences of language are also used to highlight the differences in character of the two speakers. English Coursework Chloe Cangardel Page 1 of 3 5/2/2007 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Robert Browning section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Robert Browning essays

  1. Commentary on 'My Last Duchess' by Robert Browning

    The physical setting of this poem is revealed by phrases such as �g That�fs my Duchess painted on the wall�h and words like �gcurtains�h and �gDuke�h. �gDuke�h itself makes one think of a beautiful castle with priceless furniture and art work.

  2. Comparing and Contrasting My Last Duchess and Porphyrias Lover

    She is active, he is passive. While she is busying herself moving around the cottage, he sits still. She is talkative while he is silent; she came in after being with many other people, while he sits alone and isolated in his cottage.

  1. English Literature Coursework - My Last Duchess & Porphyria's Lover

    the lovers state of mind is that he manipulates her body now as he is in direct control as he moulds her body to his comfort which shows that the lover has madness and aggressive compulsion which could only be released through love which causes death to Porphyria but happiness to the lover.

  2. the madness and wickedness in each poem. This essay will include three of Robert ...

    She is small 'no minion like me'. She is nasty, bitter, jealous and calculated. She hates her lover and his mistress; she wants her to suffer with him watching so he remembers her like that. She is paranoid 'while they laugh, laugh at me'. She is insane; she thought she could kill her lover's mistress by just starring at her.

  1. A Comparison Between 'Porphyria's Lover' And 'The Laboratory'

    The use of personification is effective (in the first four lines), giving the weather human qualities demonstrates its persistence. E.g. 'The sullen wind was soon awake, It tore the elm tops down for spite And did it's best to vex the lake' Enjambement (in the sentences describing Porphyria's death)

  2. Analysis of My Last Duchess by Robert Browning.

    As mentioned, he is presenting his best side, but through his speech the reader sees how he is very jealous and controlling, which leads one to believe that he may have many dishonorable qualities. Another ambiguous quality about the Duke is his historical character.

  1. Compare and Contrast Poetry Education for Leisure by Carol Ann Duffy (written 1986) and ...

    She also uses metaphors later on in when the character squashes a fly against the window, and says "now the fly is in another language." And when he "breathes out talent," onto the window. In "Porphyria's Lover" Robert Browning also uses a lot of metaphors to illustrate his poem.

  2. Both My Last Duchess and Porphyria's Lover are dramatic monologues written by Robert Browning. ...

    There is no reference to s*x in "My Last Duchess" but the Duchess is basically murdered for her natural sexuality, despite the fact that this is mainly in the Duke's mind, and to the reader she appears innocent and girlish.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work