• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparison of Cynddylan on a Tractor by R.S Thomas and Docker by Seamus Heaney.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Poetry Coursework There are many similarities between the poems "Cynddylan on a Tractor" by R.S Thomas and "Docker" by Seamus Heaney. Seamus Heaney is an Irish Catholic who lived in Northern Ireland for most of his life. He was a lecturer in Belfast during the 1970s at the peak of the Northern Irish Troubles. He was witness to the sectarianism and institutionalised discrimination that was part and parcel of Northern Irish life during this period; the poem "Docker" reflects this. The docker works in the shipyards of Belfast, whose employees were 95% Protestant and where sectarianism was rife. In "Docker", the subject is shown to be someone who cannot separate himself from his work and religion. The two completely control everything he does. However, his god is not the loving God of the Gospels. The docker's god is more like the wrathful pedantic god of the Old Testament. "God is a foreman with certain definite views Who orders life in shifts of work and leisure." But for him God and work are one and the same; the dockyard is his life. "Mosaic imperatives bang home like rivets,... A factory horn will blare the resurrection." These lines also demonstrate Heaney's sympathy for his subject. His commandments or prejudices have been hammered into him "like rivets", his only understanding of religion is through the medium of his work, "a factory horn will blare the resurrection". The docker is no specific person, he could be anyone. ...read more.

Middle

Heaney uses informal language such as "Oh yes..." and "the wife" to convey this. R.S Thomas was a Church of England minister and from 1942-54 he was Rector of Manaton, a hilly isolated area of south Wales, much of it uninhabited. As an adult, he learned the Welsh language in order to understand the farmers in his parish. Much of his poetry is about the people of Manaton, reflecting their lives and their culture. R.S Thomas writes the poem "Cynddylan on a Tractor" as a warning to mankind about the destruction of nature caused by mankind's insensitivity to nature. He portrays Cynddylan, sitting proud on his tractor as being insensitive and destructive. He does not see the beauty of the countryside that is around him, yet he believes that he is innovative, he is modernising his agricultural technique. Yet R.S Thomas is not a Luddite, he is not against progress or invention, but in this poem he is warning about the folly of pride. It is Cynddylan's pride which causes him to be oblivious to the damage he is causing to nature. However this is not a poem about a specific person; it is an everyman story - "Cynddylan" is the Welsh for "man". Thomas uses many different techniques effectively to portray Cynddylan. The connotations of the language describing Cynddylan and his actions are all pejorative, "breaking", "emptying", "scattering". ...read more.

Conclusion

To an extent he empathises with him, he doesn't condemn the man, but he condemns what he is doing. Both men, the docker and Cynddylan, are totally unaware of the harm they are doing to the people and the environment around them. Furthermore, the issues raised in the poems are enduring. Prejudice persists in every corner of the world and issues surrounding the environment are more relevant now than they have ever been with the advent of global warming and climate change. Anyone can learn from the poems - they are universal. Similarly, both poems are sixteen lines long. "Docker" however is split into four quatrains whereas "Cynddylan on a Tractor" is written continuously. Each of the four quatrains in "Docker" present a section of the subject's life; sitting in the pub, his sectarianism, his uncompromising religion and his domestic life. The imagery, however, in each poem is contrasting; in "Docker" it is harsh and industrial; in "Cynddylan on a Tractor" it is pleasant and natural. Personally, I prefer the poem "Docker" because, as I live in Northern Ireland, it has more resonance with my life. Although it is set before I was born, the prejudices and the destructive religious fervour Heaney describes are still commonplace if less obvious and socially acceptable. To an extent, I can empathise with the "docker" and his rigid religiosity. However, I also like "Cynddylan on a Tractor". I can understand Thomas' exasperation with people's undeserved pride in their possessions and dominion over nature. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Comparisons section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Comparisons essays

  1. The two poems I have chosen to study are The Evacuee by RS Thomas ...

    care for her as she starts her new life in the country. Another way that RS Thomas shows that the girl is safe now is through his careful use of language to describe how the family invite the girl into the kitchen and as the make a place for her

  2. Compare and contrast the similarities and Differences between the poems of Seamus Heaney and ...

    Heaney's other poem 'The Early Purges' focuses on Heaney growing up through his childhood, and his journey to becoming an adult, and obtaining a different perspective on certain things. 'The Early Purges', is very significant. 'Early' implies something that happened to Heaney when he was young - early on in

  1. How does H.G. Wells create fear and tension for the reader in the Victorian ...

    Wells shows that the Narrator is self-conscious and terrified by making the reader imagine darkness everywhere which he cannot escape. The word 'stifling' make me think of stiff and tight, this might be that the author wants us to think of this, to make us feel as if we were there with the Narrator.

  2. Compare how "Strange fruit" and "Not my business" portray violent acts

    form of juxtaposition as we believe fruit is a sign off goodness and suddenly the "Strange Fruit" is recreated as a sign of suffering. Another frequent technique used in "Strange fruit" is harsh consonants. The use of the words like "sudden smell" in stanza eight creates a sound of evil in the reader's mind.

  1. Poems can capture important moments in our lives. Discuss how Seamus Heaney and Carol ...

    Brady and Hindley were child kidnappers in the time of Duffy's childhood, and this suggests that in the classroom the power of learning and the positive, comfortable environment with a steady routine helped children to be innocent instead of having to worry about the 'real world', and that horrors like

  2. By close reference to the poems Mid-Term Break,(TM) by Seamus Heaney, and Out, Out,(TM) ...

    The first speech is by Macbeth, after the death of his wife. He describes life as a 'walking shadow, a poor player, that struts and frets his hour upon the stage, and then is heard no more.' He also compares life to a candle when he says, 'out, out brief candle.'

  1. A Comparison of Four Poems that show violence

    Will't please you rise?' and 'I dropped it into third' for Hitcher. Both of these quotes are after an important event in the poem; suddenly changing subjects. This contrasts however with the Laboratory's speaker who seems very in tune with what she is doing every step of the way.

  2. Seamus Heaney : Comparisons

    Scientists can tell from these bodies there social status by clothing, jewellery and they can also tell this sometimes by taking into account the bodies last meal. The peatlands manage to preserve the body so well that scientists can take a look into the body's stomach in order to see this.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work