• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Curleys Wife: Miss Dynamite or lonely victim?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Curley's Wife: Miss Dynamite or lonely victim? Throughout the book Steinbeck changes Curley's wife in different ways. He makes the reader feel hatred, sympathy, annoyance and love for Curley's wife. These different interpretations create an unusual feel for this character. It is difficult to pinpoint one particular character that she is, as our opinions change regularly in the book. Since the beginning of the book Curley's wife has come across very confident, lustful and bold. She puts on a confident, troubling image to start but as the book progresses she slowly reveals the lonely, apprehensive woman she really is. This image gets her in to a lot of trouble and makes her come across bad. She isn't liked by the farm-workers, and they treat her very badly. ...read more.

Middle

This shows Curley's wife trying to grasp some sort of confidence by humiliating the other characters. By calling them names she feels almost superior and special, which is what she always wants. Women are treated with very little respect and were never equal to men in this time. She belongs to Curley like an object or a possession. This is when her lonely victim side of her shines through because she is treated so badly we feel sympathy and sadness for her. A good example to show how women are treated in this day is by her name. In the book we always refer to her as Curley's wife and never know her actual name that shows how controlling and male-dominated the farm is towards women. ...read more.

Conclusion

It quotes all the reasons we used to hate Curley's wife in the past and compare it with her now, laying peacefully on the hay. Steinbeck changes Curley's wife character a lot, which makes it hard to answer whether she is Miss Dynamite or a lonely victim. I think that Steinbeck's intentions were to make us feel sympathetic towards her but also to have a hidden hatred for her previous attention-seeking character. In conclusion, I think that this question of whether Curley's wife is Miss Dynamite or a lonely victim cannot be answered. Steinbeck changes the character too much throughout the book so that you can never pinpoint a true opinion. Only till the end do you realise a true sense of loneliness and sympathy, but while she was alive she was an annoying/ troubling character, which will always linger in our minds when we try to understand her image. Jemma Davis ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE John Steinbeck section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a star student thought of this essay

3 star(s)

Response to the question

The question here asks the candidate to analyse the character of Curly's wife in Steinbeck's 'Of Mice And Men', with particular emphasis on whether we should feel contempt or sympathy for her. The candidate's Response to the Question is very ...

Read full review

Response to the question

The question here asks the candidate to analyse the character of Curly's wife in Steinbeck's 'Of Mice And Men', with particular emphasis on whether we should feel contempt or sympathy for her. The candidate's Response to the Question is very well-attuned to the question, with a good viewpoint that doesn't simply answer the question. The assumptions aren't made in the opening paragraph and the candidate uses the essay to discover for themselves and for the examiner what they believe. Though they do not ever appear to come to a conclusion, alluding to the fact that the question is unanswerable because Steinbeck "changes [Curly's wife] regularly in the book". This is somewhat counter-productive because to not clearly answer the question compromises the strength of the overall answer. It would seem though, that the candidates answer is sufficiently-supported in order to achieve at least a C grade.

Level of analysis

The Level of Analysis here is sound. All the expected aspects of a GCSE candidate response are evident - an appreciation of the base text, understanding of the question, and accurate identification of moments that aid in answering the question (interactions with Curly's wife and other characters, Steinbeck's own descriptions of the Curly's wife), as well a an astute recognition of how she as a character herself must feel, being "right at the bottom" of the hierarchy. I would argue that she is not at the bottom though - Crooks is evidently at the bottom. The use of the word hierarchy is complex because each character has their own 'hierarchy'. Curly, for example, will put his wife near the top but, as stated by the candidate in their response, the ranch-hands might disagree and put her lower down, and maybe even place Slim at the top. So candidates as a whole should avoid making such sweeping generalisations as very few things - particularly the characters, which are symbols of human traits and emotions - in any novel are so straightforward. Humans are complex, and so are fictional characters.
Where this candidate really wins marks is in their understanding of the contextual factors that influence the other character's opinions of Curly's wife. She has no name, and is isolated on a ranch in the middle of nowhere with a group of men, and so is very bored, but as the candidate noted, women were "never equal to men in this time". This understanding shows the candidates ability to appreciate the social standards of the time and how these affect the novel's happenings and the interactions between the men and Curly's wife.
Perhaps though, greater analysis should be focused on Curly's wife's dreams, and what these say about her. Being a major theme in the novel, it is foolish for any candidate to miss it when analysing characters. Her dream of moving away and being a rich and famous movie star show us further that she is superficial and idealistic, but also that she is disparagingly bored with her existence as someone else's property - she wants to break away from the constriction of being nothing more than the nameless wife of the son of a ranch-owner during the Great Depression. This is fairly straightforward as the theme of dreams is reverberated through the entire novel and is frequently used as an exam question, so this candidate missed easy marks in not recognising this.

Quality of writing

The Quality of Written Communication is acceptable. There are moments when a misuse of language makes the answer clunky and hard to understand. A better knowledge of how to accurately use commas would prevent this. Whilst basic, some student struggle with punctuation, but sentences like "This is when her lonely victim side of her shines through because she is treated so badly we feel sympathy and sadness for her" are often hard to understand and their intention ambiguous because of the repetition of "her". For example, the correct expression would be: "The is when THE lonely, VICTIMISED side of her shine through...". As well as this, there are moments when the candidate's grammar slip up: "makes her come across bad" should be "makes her comes across AS bad". These minor errors can be corrected by a simple spell-check and proof-reading before submission.


Did you find this review helpful? Join our team of reviewers and help other students learn

Reviewed by sydneyhopcroft 16/02/2012

Read less
Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE John Steinbeck essays

  1. charcter study of curleys wife

    They make judgments without getting to know her first. They judge a book by its cover. Curley, her husband doesn't trust her with the other ranch hands. She was just out of place on the ranch, and because of that, must have been a really lonely person with lonely feelings.

  2. What is the reader supposed to think about Curley's wife?

    This explains his views on Curley's wife. And when she dies he calls her a "tramp" and Candy blames her for ruining his dream of living with George and Lennie. There are no other females on the Ranch that we know about.

  1. Curley's wife is a tart. Discuss.

    He does not want any trouble. Crooks also feels the same way about her. As they are both outcasts and lonely she believes, they are an easy target to pick on. She says to them, "They left all the weak ones here."

  2. "A piece of jailbait"- is this a fair description of Curley's wife?

    through comments of the men on the ranch, "well she got the eye" I think that this a very clever technique that Steinbeck uses as it carefully builds up the suspense of the three peoples first meeting and also gives a foreboding sense that things aren't going to go well

  1. An inspector calls

    He is a stupid man and says things in his speech which turned out to be untrue. "The Unsinkable Titanic" and that there would "never be a war with Germany". He sacked Eva Smith because of his greed and the lack of understanding, he only want cheap labour (so more money for himself).

  2. Explore Some Of The Ways That Steinbeck Presents Good And Bad In His Characterisation ...

    A girl was standing there looking in?. Steinbeck portrays her in a horrible manner. He shows her as unintelligent and as an unimportant figure. The word sunshine refers to hope, freedom, happiness and dreams. This foreshadow that she may cause trouble or come in the way and could ruin it all for Lennie and George.

  1. Explore the ways Steinbeck creates sympathy for and dislike of Curleys wife.

    Steinbeck describes her ?throwing her body forward? as it highlights to the reader her need for physical attention. ?Thrown? is a powerful verb that depicts her intent to show off her body and attract men. The adverb ?heavily? describing her make-up indicates that she has spent a lot of time

  2. The Presentation of Curley's wife

    Finally, Curley?s wife, like Lennie, has no ability to self-evaluate. Unlike Lennie, she doesn?t have the excuse of being mentally slow. She?s just self-obsessed, and unable to judge herself and her position honestly. It seems at every chance she gets, Curley?s wife likes to talk about her lost opportunities.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work