Do you have any sympathy at all for Hibbert? Give evidence for your opinion
Journey's End igcse English Do you have any sympathy at all for Hibbert? Give evidence for your opinion It could be argued that the realistic way the horrors of life in a First World War trench are depicted in "Journey's End" leads us to feel sympathy for all the soldiers, including Hibbert, an officer in the company led by Stanhope. We see how soldiers had to deal with physical hardships like rationed food, rats, extreme discomfort and the emotional traumas of terror and almost inevitable death. The conditions they come to accept as ‘normal’ would strike anyone not accustomed to them as intolerable and Hibbert’s response, based on his instinct for self-preservation, may be seen as rational and in many ways understandable. However, his stance goes against the crucial military requirements of camaraderie and unity against the enemy and thus he loses the sympathy of the audience, even though he has, in all probability, been forced to go to war through conscription. I shall examine in this essay why it is possible to feel sympathy for Hibbert at the beginning of the play, but how this diminishes as more of his character is revealed. We first meet Hibbert towards the end of Act One. The stage directions describe him as ‘small, slightly built, in his early twenties’, reinforcing his youth and far from heroic stature. He refuses supper, complaining of ‘beastly
I will be analysing the characteristics of Captain Dennis Stanhope from the play Journeys End, by R.C. Sherriff.
The Character of Stanhope In this essay, I will be analysing the characteristics of Captain Dennis Stanhope from the play "Journey's End", by R.C. Sherriff. Captain Dennis Stanhope was the commanding officer of Company 'C' in the army. From an English public school, where he played Cricket and "Rugger" (Rugby), Stanhope had become an inspiration to his men at the front. His drinking obsession was a direct consequence of the stress involved from the pressure of being a commanding officer on the front line. Described as a tall, thin, broad shouldered, 21-year-old commander, his appearances are affected by a three year service under the French; his previously tanned face becomes pale and appears tired and drawn. The first scene of Journey's End deliberately excludes the direct introduction of Stanhope, himself, so as to allow the other characters to build up his status as the leader of his the men in his platoon. The characters Hardy and Osborne are seen having a conversation in which they describe his guilty pleasure as "Drinking like a fish" (page 4). However, out of loyalty and respect for Stanhope, Osborne responds to Hardy's comment by staying that "he's a long way the best commander we've got."(Page 4) We swiftly gain the impression that Stanhope, despite his tender age, is equally devoted as he is a strong character in this play, who is dedicated to his duty, as is
Journeys End. Act 2 begins with a feeling of hope. Trotter has comical conversation with Mason about how he likes his breakfast. Trotter continues by having an optimistic conversation with Osborne about England and the attack.
Journey's End Before Act 2, Scene 1 Osborne was putting a drunken Stanhope to sleep. Osborne gets ready for bed as he hears the rumble of the distant guns. The act ends with a feeling of tension and suspense. Act 2 begins with a feeling of hope. Trotter has comical conversation with Mason about how he likes his breakfast. Trotter continues by having an optimistic conversation with Osborne about England and the attack. Raleigh shows admiration of Osborne and has a discussion about the Germans. At the end of the scene Stanhope has an argument with Raleigh about the letter he wanted to send to his sister. Sheriff uses these situations to depict the futility and hardships of war. Sheriff shows a cheerful atmosphere at the beginning of the scene, 'What a lovely smell of bacon!' This shows the humanity that exists within the dugout. It contrasts with Act 1 in which there seems to be no hope and the atmosphere is dire. This comparison emphasizes the futility of war and tragedy of the life of the soldiers. In addition to this, Sheriff displays a comical conversation between Trotter and Mason, 'well I like a bit o' lean too.' This further emphasizes the humanity of the soldiers by illustrating to the audience how they are like ordinary people, which causes the audience feel to sorry for the characters in the play. Furthermore, an ironic atmosphere is put forward when Trotter asks
Journey's End: R.C Sherriff uses the characters in his play Journey's End to create tension and drama.
Journey's End R.C Sherriff uses the characters in his play Journey's End to create tension and drama. In the opening scene Sherriff uses Osborne, an elderly man who is second in command of the company that's coming on duty, and Hardy, the captain of the company that is coming off duty, to set the scene. Hardy starts to do this when pointing out features on a map of the front line, "Here we are, we hold two hundred yards of front line. We have a lewis gun here and one in this little sap here and sentry posts where the crosses are". Sherriff also uses Hardy and Osborne to give an insight into the character, Stanhope's, personality and to describe the living conditions in the front line. He first does this by using the stage directions at the beginning of the play ' CAPTAIN HARDY, a red-faced, cheerful looking man is sitting on a box by the table, instantly drying a sock over a candle-flame, this gives a first impression of the trenches and dugouts being cold and wet. Sherriff then takes this description further when Hardy says "Excuse my sock, won't you... Guaranteed to keep the feet dry, trouble is it keeps getting wet doing it." The living conditions are then further described as poor. When Hardy offer Osborne a drink of whisky but warns him " Don't have too much water it's rather strong today", this gives the indication that the water is unsafe and has to be disinfected.
Compare and contrast the different writers' presentations in at least two of the extracts.
Compare and contrast the different writers' presentations in at least two of the extracts Comment on: Differences in writers' views on their characters Language, form and structure Use of genre conventions The poem, "Base Details" by Siegfried Sassoon and the play "Journey's End" by R.C Sheriff are both pieces of WW1 literature written by men with experience fighting in the army. However their presentations of characters and methods they use to convey their thoughts in the chosen extracts are quite different and not only because they are written in different forms. Sassoon presents the Majors to be heartless as they "speed glum heroes up to the line of death". They fail to consider the soldiers who they command and know nothing about them. Their attitudes are similar to that of the Colonel in "Journey's End" as he seems to bear no conscience upon sending young Raleigh to perform a raid. In fact he recommends him for the job and seems to think he is "just the type". Although his attitude is particularly different to that of Stanhope who stutters and carries the opinion that it is "rotten to send a fellow who's only just arrived". However, his reasons for not wanting Raleigh to be sent happen to be because of their childhood friendship. Because of the different forms of writing, Sheriff has been able to create backgrounds for the characters and gives reasons for
Grapes of Wrath Analysis.
Eric Aronsohn Period 3 3/23/03 Grapes of Wrath Analysis Steinbeck's The Grapes of Wrath offers many windows on real life in Midwest America in the 1930s. But it also offers a powerful social commentary, both directly in structure and indirectly in characters. Typical of very many, the Joads are driven off the land by far away banks and set out on a journey to California to find a better life. However the journey tears the family apart. Their dreams of fortune and prosperity are reduced to the simple desire to stay a family. California promised to be the land of milk and honey but unfortunately turns to sour grapes. In the same way, the hopes and dreams of a generation turned to wrath and resentment. Steinbeck affords an open ground of this catastrophe for public examination by use of language and structure. The novel is harshly realistic. With the Joads as they travel, we meet the dark underside of capitalism with its forsaken poverty, its inhuman greed and the dehumanization of the individual, and sense a compromised trust between government and people. The truth of the journey contains wounded characters: the despairing Muley Graves, the strange Noah and the obsessed Uncle John, a one-eyed man filled with self-pity, the typical Mae serving in a Highway 66 cafe and the hell-bent vigilantes and deputies. This realism reaches a strange, even melodramatic nadir in the final
Zucko and Hansel were making their way to the Deep Ravine.The journey was very long and very tiring.They had been travelling for four hours and Zucko was getting grumpy and hungry.Luckily Hansel had thought about this and had had loads of food
CHAPTER 3 YE DEEP RAVINE Zucko and Hansel were making their way to the Deep Ravine.The journey was very long and very tiring.They had been travelling for four hours and Zucko was getting grumpy and hungry.Luckily Hansel had thought about this and had had loads of food before he left so he was happy with himself and admiring the amazingly beautiful jewelled hills and bronzed mountains.He was also singing along with the flowers.Zucko told hansel they were stopping for a break so he could magic himself some food,when all of a sudden,out of nowhere a strange looking woman with pink hair and purple clothes and boots on stopped and talked to them.In a very angry voice he said,"Don't go any further.This journey is dangerous and should not be finished.With this Hansel laughed and told the man that they had been told by their master that they were the only ones who could complete it and that they were both very prepared to go on the dangerous journey in order to get the Girdon back to where it belongs.At this the man the man walked away,so Zucko and Hansel continued to make their way to the Deep Ravine.More disaster struck as they started to make there way a terrible storm brewed up.The rain was torrential and all of the flowers closed up in order not to stop themselves from drowning.Zucko and Hansel ran under some trees to stop themselves from getting wet.The trees were very
Journal Entry
Journal Entry Thursday 28 October 1918 As I write this, I cannot help but feel dreadfully alone. I no longer have an officer to rely on and I feel as though I have lost my best friend. Before I go any further I sadly have to note the fact that Osborne was hit in the hand by a grenade which sadly resulted in his death. I have to realize the fact that this is all a new experience and soon incidents, like Osborne's death, will soon be a part of my everyday life. Despite this I think it has been hard on some of the more experienced officers also. Many soldiers talk of the raid as a standard procedure with an inevitable but "normal" outcome. However I saw it differently. Because I am still so unaware it seems that I am the only one to notice the fact that during the raid, many of our men were lost. Even when I was talking to the men earlier they did not seem able to acknowledge the fact that their fellow soldiers were no longer with them. They had seemed expressionless; using only simple vocabulary that had made them seem so withdrawn and far away. It was obvious that they were dreadfully upset but did not appear to want to show it for fear of spilling their sadness on the others around them. The strength in these soldiers is astonishing; it is hard to believe that I will ever have the ability to just carry on like they do. I do not know if I could ever be able to shield how
How does the poem "Immigrants at…" enlighten your understanding of how physical journeys shape our lives?
How does the poem "Immigrants at..." enlighten your understanding of how physical journeys shape our lives? Physical journeys shape our lives in everything we do and think. These journeys often lead to inner journeys as well, which can lead to self-actualisation. These experiences can alter a person's perspective by providing them with new information and ideas. So, a physical journey basically allows a person to experience new things, while at the same time becoming enlightened toward certain situations, issues or toward certain people. "Immigrants at Central Station, 1951" is a poem that clearly reflects these concepts. This poem shows that the persona is directly involved in a physical journey (through the use of personal pronouns such as, 'our' in "sank into our thoughts) as he/she is amongst several other migrants, who are waiting for a train at Central Station to an unknown destination after a stasis in their journey. Throughout the poem, the poet chooses to use several language features to communicate the persona's thoughts and feelings towards the journey. In particular, Skzynecki chooses to rely upon the landscape to convey how the journey occurs, rather than focus the poem on the persona and the other migrants. Time is also strongly emphasised in this poem. Every single detail given seems to relate to time and the progression of the journey eg. the repetition
Is Mandragora all about journey and discovery? Discuss this in relation to Adam and the Reader
English Essay Is Mandragora all about journey and discovery? Discuss this in relation to Adam and the Reader Introduction. At the start of Mandragora Adam is very shy and during the book he develops into a self confident and mature person. Adams life changes when he finds five mandrake dolls in a cave known to exist by local legend. What he doesn't know about them is that they are cursed; they end up causing all sorts of disasters, which are somehow linked with the disasters that happened on the Dunarling an 18th century barque. Journey and Discovery could mean Adam's personal journey or the journey of his relationship with either his father or Catriona. Adam's Physical and Mental Maturity This is a key aspect of the book. Adam matures both physically and mentally throughout Mandragora and we see him grow from being afraid to talk to others to saving the town from the curses of the Mandrake dolls. This shows us that the Adam we met at the start of the book wouldn't be ready to do this. Therefore it is obvious that he has changed and matured since he discovered the mandrake dolls. His maturity has earned him respect from his father which is something Adam has wanted throughout Mandragora. Towards the end this is shown when Adam's father helps him up after his fight with Hamish Lechie. Adam's Relationships. The relationship with Catriona is the main relationship of the