• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Examine how Willy Russell presents the nature/nurture debate in Blood Brothers.

Extracts from this document...


Natalie Baker Examine how Willy Russell presents the nature/nurture debate in Blood Brothers. Where you live determines your future. This was very true during the time in which Willy Russell's Blood Brothers was set. It was all about the amount of money you had, what job you had and who your relatives were. It was all about how you spoke, the clothes that you wore and the school that you went too. It was all about class, but did any of this determine the kind of person you were. Are you born an intelligent, nicer individual just because you are born into upper class, or are you born a thief just because you are born into middle class? It was the nature vs. nurture debate, which Willy Russell used to ask the question, does class determine your future? In Mickey and Eddies case it did, although they started off as two very similar boys who enjoyed playing games and running about, it was inevitable for the two boys to lead two very different adult hoods. For Mickey, he thought that he would never be anything more than a factory worker and that because of where he came from, meant that he couldn't possibly do any better. It's the same for Eddie, except he knew that he could be whatever he wanted to be because of the money he had and the school that he went to. Willy Russell based a lot of his story around the effects that Margaret Thatcher caused. She made the gap between middle class and upper class people wider than ever, making where you lived and how much money you earned more important than the person you were. ...read more.


Mickey wants to be jus like Eddie and have nice clothes and to use 'big words', 'I wish I could be like, ear clean clothes, talk properly like, do sums and history like, my friend' but Eddie wants to be like Mickey and be scruffy and use cool slang words. 'I wish I could be like, kick a ball and climb a tree like, run around with dirt knees like my friend.' To them, everyone is equal, they don't see that there should boundaries to who you can be with and what you can do. Even though Eddie was taken away from his birth mother, later in life when they are re united, without Eddie's knowledge, they begin to bond almost straight away. There is always a closeness that lingers between them. 'MRS.J: What y'lookin at? EDWARD: I thought you didn't like me. I thought you weren't very nice. But I think you're smashing.' It doesn't mean to say that adoptive parents love them any less, or can be any less close to the child, as Eddie shows much compassion for his mother, and it is obvious that he loves her very much, genetics aren't that important when it comes to a parent-child relationship. The actors had to make sure that the audience saw two different sides to Mickey and Eddie. The side that showed them as lads, both equally innocent and energetic, and the side that showed them as adults, after Mickey had been in prison, and Eddie when he came home from university. ...read more.


He comes down on the nurture side hard and does seem to side very much with the middle class side of life, making out that the upper class citizens were all the 'badies' in the play, not to many of the critics liking at the time. If you have enough money, you don't need to worry about bills for simple things like food, or paying the milkman, but when you need every penny you can get, like Mrs.Johnstone, you haven't got the financial comfort that you need with eight children, which is why she is so superstitious. She uses luck to get through life, and blame all of her problems on. Mrs.Lyons takes advantage of this and is how she persuades her to give away her baby, and then again to keep her away from Edward. It comes down to the money issue, and how much you can afford to lose, in Mrs.Johnstone's case, she is bought off and can't realistically afford to say no to the offer from Mrs.Lyons's to stay away. Though it may be a sad reality, during that time, even peoples standards for their own lives were based on where they lived. Their own hopes and aspirations, curved to where they thought the boundary for their success lay. It was as if they could only do as well as others saw fit for them. Nowadays, everyone decides his or her own future. No matter what their background is, with the right amount of determination, goals can be reached, it doesn't matter anymore about how much many you have or what area you can afford to live in. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Blood Brothers section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Blood Brothers essays

  1. How does Willy Russell demonstrate class difference in Blood Brothers?

    Mickey spends time in jail, and becomes more depressed and addicted to anti-depressant pills. Edward, meanwhile, becomes a councillor and helps Linda to fix up Mickey with a job, and they have an affair. Mrs Lyons' jealousy and hatred forces her to tell Mickey.

  2. Who is to blame for the tragic deaths of the twins in Willy Russell's ...

    was jealous; "Why didn't you give me away!...I could have been him", resulting in Mickey thinking that he could have had Edwards life!

  1. Compare how Willy Russell portrays the two mothers in Blood Brothers. Account for the ...

    Lyons has opened the knife drawer and has a lethal looking kitchen knife in her hand." He then says, "Mrs. Lyons lunges again but Mrs. Johnstone manages to get hold of her wrist, rendering the knife hand helplessly". This quote proves that Mrs.

  2. Blood Brothers interview with Willy Russell

    play can be when letting the reader take a side with a character, in this case, Mrs Johnston or Mrs Lyons. Allowing the audience to choose a side is one of the narrator's clear intentions, since in the opening song he says, 'and judge for ourselves this terrible sin', noticeably

  1. Blood Brothers- How does Russell display to his audience the ways that class affects ...

    Mickey knows the reality of not having enough money, but Eddie does not realise because he has never been in that situation. Eddie offers Mickey money but Mickey feels too ashamed to take it from him so goes without because he wants to support his family on his own "Look, look money lots of it, have some."

  2. What techniques and devices does Willy Russell use in 'Blood Brothers'? How effective are ...

    Some characters exist only to allow the plot to continue e.g Sammy and Mr Lyons. Sammy and Mr Lyons are 1dimensional characters. Sammy's purpose is to destroy Mickey's life, whereas Mr Lyons function is as the traditional Englishman of the time.

  1. My Mother Said I Never Should - response.

    This helped me explore my role because it showed exactly what type of character I was trying to play, which also included the use of stereotyping because in order to prove that I was playing a certain type of role, for example, if I was trying to represent an old

  2. Blood brothers - Willy Russell writes entertaining drama and champions the socially disadvantaged

    Johnstone herself. Milk is something we take for granted now, and to say she doesn't have enough money to even pay off milk deliveries shows how bad things are. The social divide is obviously there and signs can be even heard in the dialogue too, in the same scene as noted above when Mrs.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work