Examine the settings which the writers have chosen for their stories in 'the signal man',' the man with the twisted lip' and 'the red room', consider the effects that each writer has created and how they contribute to the atmosphere

Authors Avatar

Examine the settings which the writers have chosen for their stories in ’the signal man‘, ‘the man with the twisted lip‘ and ’the red room‘, consider the effects that each writer has created and how they contribute to the atmosphere

This report is examining the different settings and atmospheric effects used by writers in three different stories. The stories are called, “The Red Room”, “The Man with the Twisted Lip” and “The Signal Man”. The stories are different but they all have a mysterious theme to them and they all try to keep the reader gripped and engrossed in the story until the final ending

 ‘The man with the twisted lip’ is a murder mystery detective story. The reader is kept in suspense because they want to find out who committed the murder or even if there was a murder. The reader is engrossed in the story because they can pick up the clues with the detective and therefore try themselves to form theories or ideas to solve the mystery. This creates suspense because the reader wants to find out what actually happened, who committed the murder and why. The ending of the story is a solution and tells the reader exactly what happened and why.

In ‘The red room’ suspense is created for the reader because they don’t know what is in the room. What the characters say about the room and their fear for it, entices the reader’s desire for the answer to what is in the room. In the ending the reader is told what is in the room and why. This is a solution to the mystery and gives closure for the reader’s speculation.

‘The signalman’ creates suspense because the main character does not know what is happening to him and neither does the reader. This creates suspense because the reader wants to find out what is happening - is there really a ghost? Or is the signalman going crazy from his extensive time alone in this discomforting setting? The ending is not a solution. The reader is left to decide for him or herself what they think happened.

The stories all have different contexts. “The Signal Man” has an historical context as it is set in and around a signal box at the time when railways where seen as very new, modern and, to some, frightening. The author made this choice because the railways were seen by some at the time to be unnatural or scary, also as the railways were a new invention it was unexpected to have a mysterious, scary story centring on them, this shocks the reader.  Dickens chose a setting that many people had experienced, a dark, damp tunnel and the surrounding areas. Therefore he didn’t invent a setting he used a common place and portrayed it as a dark, hell-like place where normality and reality had little influence or importance.

The man with the twisted lip has social context. One reason for this is that at the time of writing the notorious Jack the Ripper was at large in the East end of London. Knowing that the police never managed to catch such a dangerous killer, the public were scared. And Conan Doyle uses this fear that people had to capture their inquisitive nature, they know that Jack the Ripper was not caught to the want to read about criminals who are.  When they read books about Sherlock Holmes it made them feel safe to read about a detective who always solved the mystery. Also the story reflects many social aspects of the time such as the scene in the opium den, this also has social context today. The author uses real settings in London. The street names and areas are real as is of course the iconic River Thames, which is described as polluted, and symbolises a nasty dangerous city to be in.

Join now!

The Red Room has a gothic, fictitious and literary context. The setting is one common in many gothic stories and this is why the author invented this setting - so he could incorporate all the aspects of Gothic stories, for example, Loraine Castle, grotesque characters, haunted rooms, ghosts, witches, superstition, previous deaths and curses. Also gothic stories are written in a way supposed to terrify the reader and always involves the supernatural.

In ‘The Signalman’ the setting is centred mostly around the tunnel. This is where most of the suspense and frightening imagery comes from. We can see ...

This is a preview of the whole essay