Make an analysis of the two stories and compare and contrast how the supernatural is presented in Charles Dickens' 'The Signalman' and 'The Red Room' by H G Wells.

Authors Avatar

Amna Abdelrahim

May 2005

Make an analysis of the two stories and compare and contrast how the supernatural is presented in Charles Dickens’ ‘The Signalman’ and ‘The Red Room’ by H G Wells.              

H.G. Wells wrote ‘The Red Room’ in the nineteenth century; the title is a particularly well-chosen one because the colour red signifies blood, danger, hell, and above all ‘fear', the title also shows the setting of the story. ‘The Red Room’ contains all the features of a Gothic novel, it is set in an old, derelict house, it involves moving through dark passages, and contains a ghost and a haunted room. The signalman written by Charles Dickens, is also set in the nineteenth century, and is set outside around a railway track it has a daylight feel, but is very eerie the whole way through.

The Red Room is told in first person, which makes it very personal and makes the reader feel a direct connection. It is about a young man who volunteers to go and stay overnight in the in famous ‘Red Room’, in Lorraine Castle which is known for being jinxed and there are many stories or legends about death that are brought up during the story, 'and eight-                                                                                     and -twenty years you have lived and never seen the likes of this house'. The night chosen is a particularly bad night to go and stay there because it is the anniversary of the death of a duke who had tried to stay in the room previously. This gives the reader the impression that the man going to stay in the room is doomed, 'the great red room of Lorraine Castle, in which the young duke had died.’ The stories are brought up and again have an effect on both the reader and the young man in the story. For the reader it reinforces the feeling that the man is doomed and for the young man himself, it shatters his nerves and makes him aware of all the possible dangers that could seal his fate if he entered the room.

The main character of the story is not introduced to us in any detailed way, all we know is that he is 28 years old and is at the castle to try and prove his manhood and overcome the enemy which is within him, fear, by staying overnight in a ‘haunted room’. We do not know how he came to be at the house or whom he is trying to prove himself to. He is, at no point in the story given a name but within the first few lines of dialogue we understand that he is a very confident and boastful man: ‘It will take a very tangible ghost to frighten me.’ However brave he says he is, he carries a gun with him, this shows that he is prepared for a possible emergency and it reinforces that he doesn’t believe in ghosts. By the end of the story the man has much changed and the confident boastful man that we knew at the beginning has gone, again, this tells us that he had really experienced authentic fear.

The story begins in the ‘old people’s room’ (housekeeper’s room) and the main plot is brought up straightaway, which immediately engages the interest of the reader. This room, like much of the castle, is very dark and dreary, not very welcoming and everything in it is very old. It is typical of a 19th century room; it has a mirror at one end of the room and a fire near to the table. The setting of each room is described extremely acutely so as to make the reader think that they are actually there. The old people that inhabit the house were left in charge by ‘her ladyship’. They are all elderly and are in some way disabled, one of them has a withered arm, one of them has a whooping cough and the woman is just old and decrepit. The narrator describes them in great detail, ''The old woman sat staring hard into the fire, her pale eyes wide open'', he feels them to be a key element in his story. Everything that the old people wear and are surrounded by was designed and made by someone now dead, this reinforces the image of them being ghosts. They are all afraid of what the young man is about to do and do not take any responsibility for his actions. The old people repeat phrases like ‘it is of your own choosing’ and ‘this night of all nights’. Again, they do not want any responsibility for anything that might happen to the young man. When the narrator leaves the room they all huddle together and none of them look him in the eye. This could be because they know that he is doomed and do not want him to think that they are responsible for him; also it stops them having to say goodbye to him. Lastly it could be a sign to him that he is on his own. Whenever any one of the three old people speaks, they leave sentences unfinished and open to interpretation. Everything about the old people is depressing, dismal, drab and dreary. The young man finds the old people who look after the castle, frightening and depressing. We know this because he refers to them as ‘grotesque custodians’. He also says that he 'will relieve you from the task of entertaining' him, meaning that he feels himself a burden. Once he has left the room he describes his feelings when he was 'in the company of the old people. He calls them odd and the surroundings that they were ‘ghostly’. He then banishes all thoughts of ghosts from his mind so as not to distract him from the long walk through the ‘chilly, echoing passage.’

Join now!

This ‘chilly, echoing passage’ is a common factor in a ghost story for it is dark, damp, cold and dusty. It is dimly lit, any sound can be heard and any movement made casts greatly magnified, ‘monstrous’ shadows onto the surrounding walls. When walking through the passage you would probably not be able to see to the other end, which means that anything could be lurking there. The passage has a great effect on both the reader and probably, the young man. It creates fear and suspense and is a tension builder; this passage is the start of the ...

This is a preview of the whole essay