Mini comentrries

Authors Avatar

Sarut (Time) Chayanupatkul

December 3, 2007

Seamus Heaney Poetry Commentaries

Storm on the Island

        In the poem “Storm on The Island”, Heaney focuses on the ideas of isolation and living so close to nature. The poem mainly depicts on the destructive powers of nature, for example, the wind is so strong that the spray hits “the very windows” of people's houses. The poem challenges the idea that island life is idyllic - the sea is not “company” but like a cat, seemingly tame, yet apt to turn “savage” and spit. At first living on the island may have advantages like “no stacks/Or stocks that can be lost”, but disadvantages soon appear like the absence of trees (cannot hear the sound of the wind approaching the “leaves and branches” and no “natural shelter”. The poem also uses a lot of military metaphors: the wind (like a fighter-bomber) “dives and strafes” while space is a “salvo” and air bombards.

Perch

        In the poem “Perch”, Heaney shows how the perch lives up to its name - keeping its place while the river and everything else moves past or around it. Heaney uses the metaphor of “holding the pass” to show how the perch remain unmoved. The readers see the fish from the human perspective, looking down into the clear river, but also from the perch’s perspective - “under the water-roof”. Heaney also uses a lot of sound effects such as monosyllabic words and for groups of words with the same vowel: “grunts...slubs...runty”.

Join now!

Death of a Naturalist

        In the poem “Death of a Naturalist”, Heaney explains a change in his attitude to the natural world with two parts separating before and after. The title is ironic because literally a naturalist means someone with great knowledge in nature, but Heaney suggests that the naturalist in this poem is someone who take direct observation from the nature. The poem starts off with an innocent and curious perspective as seen in the diction of childish language, “mommy”, “daddy”, but towards the ending Heaney presented a clear, striking contrast in the tone and mood of the poem. ...

This is a preview of the whole essay