Pre-1914 Prose: The Red Room Compared by H.G Wells compared to The Signalman by Charles Dickens

Authors Avatar

Pre-1914 Short Stories

In class we have been studying several short stories from the Victorian era. At this time, stories about the supernatural were very popular, otherwise known as gothic fiction. They are often set in dark, gloomy settings and contain mysterious and sometimes chilling characters. The atmosphere is usually tense, dark and frightening.

The two stories I will be writing about are ‘The Red Room’ by H.G.Wells and ‘The Signalman’ by Charles Dickens. ‘The Red Room’ is a story set in a haunted castle of which a young man has inherited. He comes to the castle to prove to the three old people who live there that ghosts do not exist, but he is given a fright when he reaches his room. Afterwards he concludes that it may not have been ghosts that haunt the room, but the person’s fear. ‘The Signalman’ is about a man visiting a signalman who works on the railway only to learn that he has had several encounters with a ghosts or spirits who all seem to be warning him of something. Whenever he sees this thing, an accident occurs on the line. In the end, the signalman himself is killed in an accident after going to investigate what he sees. Both these stories use similar techniques to keep the readers interested, for example, chilling descriptions and mysterious events. Both use tension and suspense to illustrate the narrators’ fear by building things up slowly and giving away clues before the climax.

The Red Room begins by capturing the reader’s attention by starting with the narrator saying ‘I can assure you that it will take a very tangible ghost to frighten me.’ This gives us almost confirmation that there will be some kind of ghost later in the story. ‘The Signalman’ also begins with speech, but it is the mysterious behaviour of the Signalman who looks the wrong way when called to which gets the attention. The Red Room sets the atmosphere with description of the strange old people who are hosting him, for example it says ‘ his lower lip, half averted , hung pale and pink from his decaying yellow teeth’. They warn him of something terrible that will happen to him if he stays in the red room. ‘It is your own choosing’ and ‘This night of all nights’ are repeated by them, causing the narrator and the reader to become nervous. However in The Signalman the atmosphere is created with the setting, which is described as ‘dismal’ and ‘gloomy’. It says ‘there was a barbarous, depressing and forbidding air’ which creates a premonition for what is to come. There is also the use of the strange character of the signalman to set the tone, it says ‘there was something in the man that daunted me’.

Join now!

As The Red Room develops, so does the tension. He leaves the old people and makes his way to the red room alone. The journey builds up the suspense of what is going to happen; it says ‘the echoes ran up and down the spiral staircase, and a shadow came sweeping up after me’ and ‘I stood ridged for half a minute perhaps.’ The old people’s warnings have stumped out his arrogance and he is left nervous and fearful of what may happen to him. It gives more clues when we discover what had happened to the narrator’s predecessor who ...

This is a preview of the whole essay