This excerpt of Marrakech by George Orwell outlines what times were like in the early half of the 1900's. Funerals at the time were unimportant events that were not worth remembering

Authors Avatar

Samantha Mak

Commentary – Marrakech

“When you see how people live and still more how easily they die, it is always difficult to believe that you are walking among human beings.”

George Orwell is an author that was alive in the early 1900’s, during a time when life for some people can be quite dark and bleak. This excerpt from Marrakech portrays this very well. This excerpt tells of a funeral that, due to the poverty of the people, is simple and almost, in a way, careless. Once a person has died, they are quickly forgotten, giving the effect that a death is an event that happens often, people made numb to any emotion that would normally be attached to it. Sickness and disease is so common that people take on a non-human characteristic, making it “difficult to believe that you are walking among human beings”. Orwell uses various literary devices to create a dark and mellow atmosphere, as well as using such an event to emphasise the tone.

This excerpt is spoken from the perspective of a third person, giving a very abstract view of the way that these people live. However, this changes to a second person perspective towards the end of the text, making it seem like advice to the reader. The text is purely descriptive, without a particular character that the story centers around. However, this excerpt could also be the description of this place and its habits by someone to another person. The text is focused around a funeral, describing the ritual in which it is carried out. There is no dialogue and no personalization of the event. It seems like it is someone who is overlooking the lives of these people telling the story. Rhetorical questions such as “are they really the same flesh as yourself?” engages the reader, posing questions that make them think about the various aspects of these peoples’ lives.

Join now!

Orwell speaks of “all men and boys, no women” when describing the crowd of mourners. This shows a very patriarchal society, one in which such a grave event does not allow women to participate. The group described as a “little crowd” conveys the idea that a funeral, during that time, was not at all an event that held great importance and significance. As the early 1900’s were plagued with various incurable diseases and a lack of hygiene, it seems to be almost expected that a person did not live long. People “rise out of the earth, they sweat and ...

This is a preview of the whole essay