• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To what extent do Thelma and Louise and Shirley Valentine tell stories from a women's point of view about women's real life problems.'

Extracts from this document...


Women in Film: 'To what extent do Thelma and Louise and Shirley Valentine tell stories from a women's point of view about women's real life problems.' Throughout the history of film actresses have always received the worst roles in which to portray women. Women are often featured as lovers or prostitutes, backstage roles that support the power and domination of men. Hollywood has always been dominated and 'run' by the influence of male actors and directors. Statistics have shown that 71% of male actors are given major roles compared to women who receive only 29% of centre stage roles. Thelma and Louise and Shirley are two films, which change that. They portray woman in a positive role, showing them in a positive light against male oppression. Although Shirley Valentine is a British film and Thelma and Louise is American, both films still show women facing the prejudice of society in the 20th century. In this way women viewers can relate to the films believing them to show the difficulties women face in life, the loss of women's individuality due to the domination of their husbands and their experiences of sexism and prejudice in modern day society. There are many similarities as well as differences in both films and the storylines are varied, yet both films still feature woman who overcome the typical stereotype that they are nothing but sexual objects for men to abuse. ...read more.


However, Shirley was always put down by her teachers who regarded her as less able than her friend Marjorie who they always praised. Some women may understand the neglect in Shirley's childhood, why she let go of her dreams and how she turned into the person she now is. This true-life experience makes women relive their past and understand how they have become the people they are today. When her friend Jane wins tickets to Greece Shirley sets off on a road of self-discovery, which will help to fulfil her dreams. Thelma and Louise is more of an action film and we understand each character by their actions, words and the way they interact. In both films we see abusive husbands. Thelma's husband Darryl is a dominating character who uses Thelma as a maid and may be being unfaithful; there is a suggestion that he may be having an affair. Many women can see themselves in Thelma's position, dominated by their husbands and treated unfairly. At first Thelma is seen as a typical southern housewife completely naive and inexperienced. While this may be a stereotypical character that may not appeal to a modern audience of women who consider themselves independent, it sets the scene for Thelma's progress in character and the change in her personality. At the beginning of the film we see Thelma trying to fit in and be comfortable in modern society yet the actions she makes are based on stupidity and she frequently gets herself and Louise into a lot of trouble by her inexperienced actions. ...read more.


He then robs her. This can be compared to Shirley Valentine who falls for a man named Costas who charms her with his politeness and his eagerness to keep her happy but who later uses her. This shows men from a women's perspective. They show the way that men use women for their own uses, winning them over with charm until they finally hurt them. In some ways men in both films men are presented very negatively. Yet it can be true to say that this aspect of men from a women's viewpoint is something many women can relate to. In both films the women find themselves. They are freed from the oppression of men and find the strong willed personalities that they were losing. Therefore I believe both films are successful in presenting stories from a women's viewpoint on the real life problems women face. Both films are realistic and can be compared to the lives of many women in the same situations. These films allow women to relate to the characters and experience emotions on issues that they have faced throughout history such as rape and sexism. They allow women to feel a sense of hope and to make them understand that they are individuals who must fulfil their dreams. Shirley Valentine and Thelma and Louise allow women to overcome stereotypical images of 'housewives' and 'sex objects' and present women as strong with their own individual characters. In this way both films are successful in showing the problems and issues women face and overcome from a female perspective. Sonam Raja 10:16 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Shirley Valentine section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Shirley Valentine essays

  1. Shirley Valentine

    In the play, Shirley achieves her personal ambition to 'drink a glass of wine in the country where the grape is grown' It furthermore deals with domestic issues mainly, and is set in a working class environment and 'Shirley Valentine' certainly reflects this.

  2. Shirley Valentine. How does Russell invite the audience to sympathise with Shirley?

    "I give word of honour, I don't try make fuck with you" this is Costas promising Shirley that he won't try anything with her. Shirley is reassured and goes on the boat with Costas and she puts her trust in him instantly after she met him.

  1. How does the dramatic technique used in the play help the audience to understand ...

    Shirley feels that if she goes back to Liverpool '...who would care... they wouldn't really miss me...' implies that Shirley really doesn't want to go back, as she likes the idea of living in Greece. She feels life for her in Liverpool is a waste as no one cares about her.

  2. shirley valentine

    Historically Liverpool was a poorer part of Britain and was very industrial and bleak, compared to southern cities most of the north was very similar to Liverpool - industrial, poor, more lower class people, meaning people who lived in these areas, like Shirley, would have struggled and didn't have the

  1. Shirley Valentine

    A good aspect about Shirley which is not disguised by her original personality (Shirley Bradshaw) is during her life in Liverpool is her use of verbal humour which keeps the viewers interested, this is a good use of comedy. Willy Russell uses flashbacks/ expositions to show the audience a glimpse of Shirley's past life.

  2. shirley valentine

    The first flashback is all about Shirley going to look after her neighbour Gillian's dog whose name is Claymore. Gillian and her husband are going to Brussels. Shirley has to feed Claymore for the evening, but there's a problem, Claymore eats muesli as Gillian thinks he is a vegetarian but he doesn't seem to like it.

  1. Shirley Valentine-how does Russel encourage the audience to feel sympathy for Shirley?

    Mans most important invention was the wheel'. The headmistress bursts out with rage; pointing a shacking finger at her saying 'Somebody must have told you!' This shows that no one really believed in Shirley, as they thought that she came from a lower class, therefore, she will not know anything.

  2. How do the dramatic techniques used in the play help the audience to understand ...

    This relates to socio-historical context of working class women. Russell's use of voice overs helps us to understand how she sees certain situations. As Shirley quotes 'the only thing I hated was myself' shows the play how Shirley sees different situations.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work