• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10

'The Five Year Plans brought glory to Stalin and misery to his people' - How valid is this judgement?

Extracts from this document...


GCSE History Coursework Task 2: 'The Five Year Plans brought glory to Stalin and misery to his people.' How valid is this judgement? 1. 'Brought glory to Stalin . . .' - is this the only, or the most important reason why Stalin embarked on his industrialisation programme? 10 marks Unmistakably, it is true that one of the most important reason why Stalin introduced the Five Year Plans was to earn the glory he always wanted to earn from the Russian public and supporters of Communism across the globe. It is alluring to derive that his introduction of the Five Year Plans was for his objective of portraying his own pose as an undisputed Soviet Union leader as well as increasing his power. This is evident as the initiation of the industrialisation programme led to the "disposal" of his political opponents - the Right leaders Tomsky, Bukharin and Rykov who were still interested in not getting rid of the NEP which was holding back industrialisation for the Soviet Union. Besides, the fact that Stalin disagreed with Trotsky on the idea of modernisation and suddenly changed his mind to industrialise the economy within five years when he came into power after getting rid of Trotsky and the Left Party reveals Stalin as a conniving and shrewd trailblazer concerned principally in his own supremacy. However, apart from his motive of his glorification, there are other distinct reasons why Stalin started his industrialisation. Firstly, one of main goals which Communism in this case the Soviet Union aimed to achieve was rapid industrialisation of Russia so that her industrialised economy can tally and be compared with that of the European countries. Under Lenin's NEP, the Russian economy improved but the speed of industrialisation was not anywhere near the acceptable level which the Communists wanted in order to modernise the economy which would result in successful socialism. We know this is true as by 1926, the industry did reach the pre-war levels in many parts of the country ...read more.


Nevertheless, in this new programme, the concentration was not just on the heavy industries of coal, oil and iron but also to boost the mineral industry, communication and transport. We know this is true as the lead, tin and zinc industries intensified whereas many new canals and railways being built, the Moscow underground railway being the most magnificent centrepiece project. This further helped in reducing unemployment in Russia to such extent that foreign observers such as Dr Hewlett Johnson, Dean of Canterbury Cathedral began to believe that Russia has become a land "where none are employed" as there is such enthusiasm in the Soviet workers. Furthermore, by the late 1930s many Soviet workers had improved their conditions by acquiring well paid skilled jobs and earning bonuses for meeting targets. Under this second industrialisation programme Russia thrived to such a high degree that in 1940, there were more doctors per head of population in USSR than in capitalist countries like Britain. Moreover, the edification system improved immensely as schooling became free and compulsory for all types of people as Stalin started huge investments in the teaching methods based in colleges and in the workplace. Moreover, by the process of collectivisation, Stalin got enough grain to feed the hungry Soviet workers in the cities before the famine stuck. It was the result for this that the grain production excelled from 36 in 1921 to 95 in 1940. Stalin's goal of improving the agricultural Russia also meant that the machine tool industry also excelled as well as the huge improvement in modern chemical industry. This allowed the use of modern machinery such as tractors on the now collectivised farms which intensified the farm produces benefiting the Russian economy as these food bonuses were exported abroad for profit. Besides, people who were keen to work extra in the factories and in the various hydroelectric power plants did do well as they received better housing and salary and were not exposed to poverty and crowdedness to a very large extent. ...read more.


I believe what Stalin achieved for Russia during World Wide depression of the 1930s was absolutely spectacular - forceful heavy industries, new and contemporary machine tool industries, modern chemical industries, improved communication and transport as well as free education and medical system. 3. 'Brought misery to his people . . .' - in what ways did the Soviet people suffer? Is there any way in which life improved? 20 marks 4. What verdict would you give on the Five Year Plans? 10 marks MARKSCHEME Question 1 * INTRODUCTION - Is it true that the only and the most important reason why Stalin introduced the Five Year Plans was that he wanted to achieve glory. HOWEVER not the only way * The question is basically asking apart from the fact that it would glorify Stalin, what other reasons are there that got Stalin to start on his industrialisation programme known as the Five Year Plans. * CONCLUSION Don't you think there are several reasons that are important instead of just one reason being the most important one? Give your verdict - in your personal opinion which reason do you think is the main one and the most important one why Stalin introduced the Five Year Plans ? * Tip - include statistics and dates as well as Stalin's quotes in speeches (background knowledge) Question 2 INTRODUCTION - * The question is basically asking you apart from glorifying Stalin, what were the other achievements of the Five Year Plans? Tip - include statistics Nevertheless * Don't you think that there are other achievements of the Five Year Plan which are important rather than just the idea of Stalin's glorification? CONCLUSION - * Don't you think all the other achievements of the Five Year Plans play a significant role in describing the Five Year Plans as a successful scheme of improving USSR's economy? * Did it not infuse the element of prosperity and competitiveness in the Russian society * In your personal opinion which achievement do you think is the most important? Akshat Krishna 11TS ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Russia, USSR 1905-1941 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Russia, USSR 1905-1941 essays

  1. 'The Five Year Plans brought glory to Stalin and misery to his people.' How ...

    This proved to be true in 1927 when a series of events were seen as evidence of an impending attack on the Soviet Union. In different parts of the world there was many attacks. In 1927 there was a raid by the British government on the Soviet trade mission in

  2. Stalin and the Five Year Plans

    He needed to industrialise to complete his cry for 'Socialism in One Country'. Also, as the wall street crash had led to the rise of the anti communist Hitler in Germany, Stalin very much needed to prepare Russia for what was to come.

  1. Russia 1905-1917 exam questions with mark schemes.

    The food shortages were too much. As the Russian army were needed for troops, most of the farmers including workers and peasants were gone for battle. Because of this there weren't enough people to grow food which led to food shortages.

  2. five year plans in russia

    Propaganda was used. Brochures, pamphlets and posters were distributed all over to boost the people's confidence. A man was said to be working at a rate of 500% more productive than the average worker. Of course, most of these figures were exaggerated and the people were killed by jealous workers.

  1. How did Stalin control Russia from 1924-1953?

    This would never have happened before the industrialisation, and if the army had been defeated by Germany, Stalin would have failed, and all Russia's hard work would have been for nothing. This would not have helped Stalin at all, but as the army were successful, the Russians saw him as

  2. How did Stalin transform the economy of the USSR in the 1930s?

    other parts of the world should appreciate what it had to offer the working people of the USSR. Was the NEP working at the end of the 1920s? * The 1926 Party Congress had charged the leadership with 'the transformation of our country from an agrarian into an industrial one, capable by its own efforts of producing the necessary means'.

  1. Stalin Man or Monster

    Q7 It is complicated to come to a final conclusion of whether Stalin was a man or a monster. Stalin is the man responsible for the industrialization of Russia, however he is also responsible for the death of millions of Russians.

  2. Stalins Five Year Plans were a great success 1928-1941. Do you agree? Explain you ...

    In addition to the inflation of the production figures, we must also consider the human cost that had to be paid for the remarkable achievements to be accomplished. In order to produce the perfect image in which the industry of the USSR was benefitting from the Five Year Plans, the

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work