The Weimar Republic was weak form the start, its collapse was always likely. How far do you agree with this judgement on the period 1919 - 33?

Authors Avatar

        MARIA-PAULINA SOCARRAS-GARZON        12 URS

‘THE WEIMAR REPUBLIC WAS WEAK FROM THE START; ITS COLLAPSE WAS ALWAYS LIKELY.’ HOW FAR DO YOU AGREE WITH THIS JUDGEMENT ON THE PERIOD 1919-33?

The Weimar Republic was created in 1919 with the abdication of Wilhelm II. The new government was the body that signed the Treaty of Versailles, and to many, that was a betrayal. The consequences of Versailles were severe to Germany, and many were looking for someone to blame, the government was the ideal scape goat. Communists and the right saw an opportunity to create a state that they wanted, and were prepared to challenge the new republic. Many richer Germans had lived well under the Kaiser, and distrusted the new government. Considering all of these points, it would seem that the collapse of the republic was inevitable, but was that the case?

From the start, the new Weimar government faced opposition from both left and right. The Left wing Spartacist group, lead by Luxemburg and Liebknecht, admired the new Russian Communist political system, and with the fall of the Kaiser, saw an opportunity to attempt to place Germany into a similar system. In January 1919 they revolted, and tried to take control of Berlin, with the support of the USDP they proclaimed a new revolutionary government. However, Ebert had already won the support of the military, and the troops suppressed the revolt. This pact was significant, the government had associated itself with the right, and perhaps this early incident is one of the factors which would convince the government to appoint Hitler Chancellor in 1933. The Right were next to revolt. In 1920 the Kapp Putsch revolt occurred. The rebels surrendered on March 17 as unions declared a general strike. The government had another close escape. The early major activities of Hitler included his 'Beer Hall Putsch' where he tried to seize control of The Bavarian government. His revolt was like the others, crushed, but clear opposition to the republic had been established.

Join now!

The political instability was exacerbated by the financial implications of the Treaty of Versailles. By 1921, the level of reparations had been fixed to the equivalent of £6600 million. It was clearly evident that the weakened Germany would not be able to pay. By January 1923, the French were angered at Germany's poor payment record, and occupied the Ruhr region. The citizens of the Ruhr began to hate the French who were exploiting them, and so again needed someone to blame. They decided to blame the people who had agreed to pay reparations, the government. By November 1923, a situation ...

This is a preview of the whole essay