What are the main differences between Republicans / Nationalists and Unionists / Loyalists?

Authors Avatar
What are the main differences between Republicans/Nationalists and Unionists/Loyalists?

For many years there has been serious conflict and bloodshed in Ireland. The cause of over 3000 deaths is just one question: Should the North stay part of the United Kingdom, or should it become part of the Republic? This has caused a divide in people's opinions about the future of Ireland. One side, who wish Northern Ireland to stay part of Britain, are called unionists. Those who disagree, who want a united independent Ireland, are called Nationalists.

Unionists generally want Northern Ireland to remain under British control. They do not want to unite with the Republic for two main reasons relating to finance and religion. Many people believe that in order to retain good trade links with the United Kingdom and Europe, they must keep a harmonious relationship with them, and remain part of it. More significantly, most Unionists are members of the Protestant community. Within Northern Ireland they are the majority, however within the whole of Ireland they would be a minority, facing scrutiny and discrimination from the Catholic community. They believe that events would imitate those of over 300 years ago when British settlers were persecuted in Ireland, and so they too waged war upon the Catholics. Therefore, they wish Britain to remain in control in order to protect them from persecution.

These points are relevant to nearly all Unionists; however, there are differences within that group. For example, more hard-line Unionists are known as Loyalists. These include paramilitary groups such as the Ulster Defence Association and Ulster Volunteer Force. These loyalists use violence and weapons to achieve their aims, whereas the Ulster Unionist Party (led by David Trimble) and the Democratic Unionists Party (led by Ian Paisley) use democratic means.

The Nationalists disagree with the Unionists. They feel that Northern Ireland should be free from British control and join with the South to form one united Ireland. Many nationalists are from the Catholic community, which has very strict beliefs about religion and politics. They believe that the British are to blame for many of Ireland's past problems. Nationalists feel that they can govern Ireland far more effectively themselves and put an end to the hostility and conflict.

However, yet again there are differences in opinion within this group. More hard-line Nationalists are called Republicans. The two main democratic parties are the SDLP, who are strictly non-violent, and Sinn Fein who, in the past, have been linked with violence, and terrorist organisations such as the IRA. However, in recent years they have been very involved in the peace process and have not resorted to violent methods. The IRA is one of several Republican paramilitary groups, which use violence to put across their message. The IRA is also split into groups due to disagreements in methods of achieving their targets. The Real IRA and the Continuity IRA continue to use violence and terrorism, whereas the IRA have currently signed a ceasefire and are negotiating using peaceful methods. This is mainly due to the severe control of and penalties for terrorism currently being enforced, following September 11th.

Question 2: How has the Easter Rising Shaped The Views of Today's Loyalist/Unionist/Protestants and Republican/Nationalist/Catholics?

It is necessary to understand how past events can influence the future in order to understand the current problems and divisions in Northern Ireland. Conflict in Ireland can be traced back to the 16th and 17th centuries. However, many historians would agree that the real roots of the present conflict are found in the period 1880-1922. One major event, which has greatly influenced the opinions of both Nationalists and Unionists, is the Easter Rising of 1916.

Since the British government passed an Act of Union in 1800, the Irish people have disputed over who should govern Ireland. In the 1860s a group of Nationalists began to seek 'Home Rule' for Ireland. They wanted their own Parliament to deal with issues inside Ireland, but agreed to stay part of the British Empire and allow the British to deal with things such as foreign affairs. This movement grew in popularity during the 1880s and it began to seem as though Home Rule would be achieved for Ireland. Conversely, many Protestants believed that Home Rule would damage the economy of Ulster considerably. Their main concern however, was that Catholics would dominate the parliament. "Home Rule equals Rome Rule" summarized their thoughts concisely. These people formed the Unionists, and their own political party, the Ulster Unionist Party. By 1912, Home Rule looked inevitable. In response, some unionists formed the paramilitary group, the Ulster Volunteer Force, in order to resist the introduction of Home Rule. Consequently, in 19013 the Nationalists formed their own rival army, the Irish Volunteers. However, in August 1914, just as the British government feared an Irish Civil War, The Great War broke out. This brought a temporary end to the crisis, as thousands of Irish men, both Catholic and Protestant, joined the British army. This took people's minds off the Home Rule situation for a while, until a small group of Republicans felt that their situation was being ignored. In the spring of 1916, leaders of the Irish Republican Brotherhood (another Nationalist private army), saw the war as the perfect opportunity to stage an armed uprising. They planned to seize control of Dublin on Easter Monday, when the British would be weaker from fighting the Germans, when they would have a strong advantage.

The exact aims of the Easter Rising however are quite unclear. Some people believe that its leader, Patrick Pearse, saw the rising as a 'blood sacrifice'. This meant that even if the rebellion was unsuccessful, the deaths of nationalists at the hands of the British would hopefully increase support for the Nationalist cause in Ireland. He was very accurate in this opinion. Unfortunately for the rebels, the suffered a major set back shortly before the rising was to take place: the British Navy captured a German ship, carrying much needed ammunition for the Irish rebels. Despite this, the rebels went ahead. On 24th April 1916, whilst many British soldiers were fighting in the trenches, 2000 rebels stormed the General Post Office Building in Dublin and made it their headquarters. Patrick Pearse read out a proclamation declaring that Ireland was an independent Republic, and the Irish tricolour was raised. Unfortunately for them, British soldiers quickly defeated the 2000 rebels. They used heavy artillery and a gunboat stationed on the River Liffey to overcome the Nationalists. In total 418 were killed and £2.5 million worth of damage was caused to buildings in the area. The whole of Ireland was in shock.
Join now!


The damage caused by the Easter Rising was irreparable in many people's eyes. Generally, Irish civilians were shocked and disgusted by what they had witnessed on 28th April 1916. The cost of life and money scarred the lives of many people, both Catholic and Protestant, and so as the rebels were marched away, they were verbally abused and tormented by many passers by. A sense of betrayal was felt by all the families of men who had joined the British army, when they were united against the Germans. The Nationalists had stabbed their own men in the back. ...

This is a preview of the whole essay