To what extent has New Labour abandoned traditional Labour values?

Authors Avatar

To what extent has New Labour abandoned traditional Labour values?

After decades of consistent defeat, the Labour party sought the need for change in the early 1980s. Although Labour started to change under the leadership of Neil Kinnock in 1983, it wasn’t until 1990 that Peter Mandelson, then the party's director of communications, was able to claim that "we have now effectively completed the building of the new model party". And it wasn’t until 1994 when Tony Blair was chosen to lead the Labour party that the “New Labour” project was introduced.

The introduction of New Labour was aimed at getting rid of the “party of the past” image that Labour had earned to itself and also to evolve into an electable party. For this to happen, radical policy changes needed to be made. In Blair's view, "Labour needed a quantum leap to become a serious party of government again".

There were however, significant constraints on the way to achieving drastic changes. An attempt to modernise the Party was in need to change policies which were formulated based on values which the party was actually based and founded upon. The changes that were proposed by Tony Blair and those who shared his views were in clear contrast with the Socialist ideology on which the Labour Party had originated from. The proposed changes also sought to prevent the Trade Unions- another main source of the Party’s origins- from having any further influence in the Labour Party.

Join now!

It was also a part of New Labour’s new policies to abandon the ‘tax and spend’ ideology and instead take cooler stands on public spending. They came to a conclusion that expenditure on public services was no longer an accurate measure of how well the public services were being run.

Only one year after being elected as Party leader, Tony Blair mentioned the word ‘new’ on 59 occasions- 16 of them with reference to New Labour- in the Party Conference in 1995. In contrast, he referred to socialism just once and to the working class not at all. Comparison ...

This is a preview of the whole essay

Here's what a star student thought of this essay

Quality of Writing Spelling and grammar are excellent, and the candidate's style of writing is very good. They write in a mature and controlled style, expressing their ideas in a clear and succinct way. There is a clear introduction and conclusion, but personally I do not like the final line (But the question is, if a Labour Party doesn’t stand for Labour values, how can it call itself the Labour Party? Well, it actually calls itself ‘New’ Labour) and I do not feel that it works well. While acknowledging the genesis of Blair's Third Way, referring to the Conservatives as "Tory", while very common in everyday life and the media, is not strictly correct terminology, and may be a point of contention for examiners.

Level of Analysis The level of analysis in this essay is excellent. The candidate clearly introduces areas of policy, and then describes how they have changed from Old Labour to New Labour, with a focus on how this may be a move away from traditional socialist positions. The candidate's inclusion of extra information, such as "Tony Blair mentioned the word ‘new’ on 59 occasions- 16 of them with reference to New Labour- in the Party Conference in 1995" demonstrates a good knowledge of Blair's premiership of the party and the period of transition from Old to New Labour.

Response to Question A question that begins "To what extent..." invites the candidate to debate the topic of the question, and a discussion of how far New Labour has gone from traditional Labour values could have included counter-arguments, such as the fact that Old Labour only began around 1980, and that the values of Attlee fall more under modern liberal. However, their examination of the ways in which Labour has moved to the right, and away from the dominant democratic socialist strand of Benn and Foot is detailed and considers a variety of ways in which the party changed as it moved towards New Labour, making for a very good response overall.