Dostoevsky and Maslow

Authors Avatar

Sarah Medley

Psychology 101/ Feres

Short Paper #1

27 September 2010

Dostoevsky and Maslow:

Needs in Life, How They Are Prioritized, and the Exceptions

        Dostoevsky has written, "Without a clear perception of his reasons for living, man will never consent to live, and will rather destroy himself than tarry on earth, though he be surrounded with bread.” (The Grand Inquisitor) With indirect opposition, Maslow’s idea on these needs is stated in his quote, “A person lacking food, love, and self-esteem, would most likely hunger for food more strongly than anything else.” A number of instances stand as evidence to both Maslow and Dostoevsky’s statements.  

        First let us look at the claim Fyodor Dostoevsky has made. The Bible also has three references for a very similar idea. Scripture has expressed, in Deuteronomy 8:3, Matthew 4:4, and Luke 4:4, that 'Man does not live on bread alone, but on every word that comes from the mouth of God.' (The Bible) All individuals have accepted the Bible as truth would feel this way and therefore approach life’s needs as Dostoevsky. The act of fasting is also an example of how Fyodor’s statement might come into play during an individual’s life. Another group of individuals who might be observed to follow the Dostoevsky idea would be those who are suffering from serious mental disorders. A loss of regular and proper diet is a symptom of severe cases of depression, anxiety, and stress. (MayoClinic) They become so focused on their struggle to overcome these feelings, of being lost, or alone, or unorganized, and unsafe, that the priority of food becomes pushed aside. But in Maslow’s Pyramid the feelings of safety and organization, love and belonging, are all placed higher, or less important, than the need to satisfy hunger. (Myers) Order of prioritization is the foundation of contradiction between the two statements.

Join now!

        Abraham Maslow’s idea seems to be more realistic to a majority of the remaining population. How is it reasonable to think a person would have the capability to even find their identity or “the purpose in life” without the energy supplied by fulfilling basic needs, like eating? This was a common reaction I heard from peers and adults after telling of Dostoevsky’s statement. Gandhi said, "Even God cannot talk to a starving man except in terms of bread." (Aldrich) Some needs take priority over others. (Myers) Our brain causes us to have feelings of motivation for needs; the most concrete ...

This is a preview of the whole essay