A consideration of Lord of the Rings: Fellowship of the Ring, and Star Wars: A New Hope.

Authors Avatar

A Consideration of Lord of the Rings: Fellowship of the Ring and Star Wars: A New Hope

A New Hope and Fellowship of the Ring can be described as epic. What do we mean by epic? An epic film would have a large cast, cover a wide area and follow an impressive story line, often with a heroic theme. There is a high level of comparison between the two films. There are many similarities and differences that can be drawn out, such as the role of the main characters or the opening sequences of the films.

Star Wars

Not only is this film a rousing adventure, but, upon its initial release, it revived science fiction as a viable movie medium, and, most importantly, began a special effects revolution that is still going on. It's impossible to estimate the full ramifications of Star Wars, but that single movie has surely influenced much about the making and marketing of motion pictures over the last two decades.

Both films are visually stunning, and are equally important to the history of cinema. Star Wars was the first of its genre and was innovative in its approach to story telling.

Fellowship of the Ring on the other hand shows how far cinema has come. It delivers realistic special effects, with a magnificent story adapted from one the centuries greatest novels. It is the first instalment of Tolkeins legendary trilogy, a film which many sceptics thought to great a task to be brought to the silver screen. in George Lucas's grand narrative of good versus evil, Star Wars.

A New Hope and Fellowship of the Ring are two types of epic. The first is science fiction, the second fantasy. Both films tell the story of good versus evil. However they are played out in many different ways. Lord of the Rings is filmed mostly in rural countryside and woodland, which makes the film seem more adventurous and more realistic. The scenery in the background is also featured more in Lord of the Rings than in Star Wars, because Tolkein (books author) described the world of middle-earth in great detail, and because the landscape is so significant in the telling of the story. Without such impressive scenery the film would have little impact on the audience. The majority of Star Wars was filmed in a studio. This makes the film seem more timeless, and has probably contributed to the fact that it is still popular today. Both films tell the story of good versus evil, and have many similar themes. However the weight of stories are considerably different. The story line of Lord of the Rings is central to the film, the story line to Star Wars is fairly minimal, and at times you get the impression that it was made solely for special effects and visual appeal. The key difference between the depth and substance of the films stories are that star wars was originally written as a pure screenplay while lord of the rings is a timeless classic novel. This is evident in certain scenes. !Such as the love interest between Luke and Leia!. Which at times feels forced and unnecessary.  You get the impression that it was only included to satisfy the film makers desire to appeal to a wider audience, and due to the commercial nature of the film this seems a likely reason. At times it feels as if the commercial aspect of the film interferes with the story telling. The film feels as though it has been tailored to fit audiences and diluted to fit the U certificate.

most of star wars was filmed in a studio, and because Tolkein (books author) went into great detail in describing the surrounding. To do the film and the book justice the director found almost identical locations to those described in the book. It is certainly more realistic than Star Wars to get the feel that it is an adventure. The scenery is also very important  

Join now!

The opening credits of both A New Hope and Fellowship of the Ring are there to set the scene, but are executed in two different ways. The introduction to Star Wars is in text, as to Lord of the Rings which is more visual. The latter is also considerably longer in length, but is equivalent to the five minutes of text seen in the opening sequence in Star Wars.  Both are equally effective but Fellowship of the Ring is much more compelling and far more memorable. Alhough there is a big difference in the duration of these opening sequences, it ...

This is a preview of the whole essay