Was the Weimar Republic doomed from the start?

Authors Avatar

Was the Weimar Republic doomed from the start?

Lauren White – DP2 – History – Mrs. Palthe – 2nd October 2009

The Weimar Republic was declared on the 11th of November 1918, after World War One to try and get easier war terms for changing into a democracy.  It existed till 1933, when Hitler became Chancellor and began to turn Germany into a diplomatic state.  In the Republic, the SPD, Centre Party and the DDP made up the coalition government due the SPD not being able to gain a majority in elections.  Despite the best efforts of the government, the Weimar Republic did not last.  Unfortunately, the Weimar Republic was doomed from the start due to the people of Germany not being ready for democracy, opposition from Right and Left wing parties, the economic and social problems, and the upset of the German public with the Treaty of Versailles.    

One of the reasons why the Weimar Republic was doomed from the outset was the fact that the German people were not ready to be considered either Republicans or part of a democracy.  A quote from a Free Corps Commander, “…he can’t suddenly say, “Starting tomorrow I’m a Republican.””  This shows perfectly the attitude of the German people towards the administrative change that occurred.  However it was not only the public of Germany that felt this way, but civilians who were in highly-influencing positions.  Judges gave right-wing terrorists and rebels very lenient sentences or none at all.  Churches did not attempt to change anything about their teaching – and teachers spoke in favour of the empire as well as the textbooks used.  Lastly, industrialists felt that the regime was in favour of the workers, and they felt like they could lose control.  Farmers found that they were also getting little return on their produce, meaning that many were suffering from severe poverty.  By having this feeling of aversion to the government, it is hardly surprising that it was not able to become the permanent solution to Germany’s problems.  

Join now!

Another reason why the Republic was set up to fail was the harsh opposition from Right and Left wing parties.  The Left wing was made up of Communists, and the main party on this side was the KPD.  It was this party that felt the most resentment to the main party in the coalition government, the SDP.  Two prominent leaders of the KPD, Karl Liebknecht and Rosa Luxemburg, were murdered by the Freikorps men and the KPD blamed the SDP.  Therefore, once the SDP came to power the KPD tried to fight against them as much as possible.  Although they ...

This is a preview of the whole essay