• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Discuss the claim that [in the History of Chemistry] some knowledge are discovered and others are invented.

Extracts from this document...


Discuss the claim that [in the History of Chemistry] some knowledge are discovered and others are invented. Write an essay between 600-800 words applying deductive reasoning, inductive reason and language, to info on the invention and discovery of gallium, germanium and scandium Firstly, in order to best understand the question, it is essential to define a few of the key terms mentioned above, namely deductive reasoning, inductive reasoning and language, as a way of knowing. Deductive reasoning can be defined as a form of reasoning that moves from the general to the particular; a type of reasoning which progresses logically in order to arrive at a conclusion. Hence a deductive argument would be deemed valid when the conclusion is a logical consequence of its premises, making its conclusion a necessary truth. Inductive reasoning, however, is quite the opposite, and is instead a type of reasoning which moves from the particular to the general. The premises of an inductive argument would hence carry a high level of support for the conclusion, though this does not necessitate the conclusion to be ensured true. The third and last way of knowing, language implies a form of human thought that is conveyed through the usage of a series of symbols. ...read more.


The concept of induction is a tool of extreme importance in the area of science, which goals include the finding of regularities and patterns among observed findings, before making a hypothesis and experimenting to test the hypothesis. An apropos example of the application of this concept would be that of Mendeleev's invention of the periodic table in 1869; it was based on recurring trends that were observed by him. His arrangement of the elements in terms of their weight, from lightest to heaviest, saw him organizing them into a table. It was only when Mendeleev organized the table into horizontal rows did he observe a pattern between the elements. However, this pattern was only present when he left certain blanks in the table. This is a prime example of inductive reasoning, as his predictions of the elements were based on the hypothesis that was supported by the premises, though there was no solid proof to suggest that the conclusion was necessitated to be true. In his assumption that the blanks were left there, he noticed that elements with similar chemical properties appeared at regular intervals in the form of vertical columns on the table, leading him to suggest that the blank spaces were held by elements that were chemically similar to elements in the same column. ...read more.


Gallium, derived from the latin word Gallia meaning "Gaul", quintessentially meaning modern day Frances, was discovered by French scientist Lecoq de Boisbaudran in 1875. Though it was predicted by Mendeleev in 1869 as eka-aluminium, Boisbaudran named it Gallium after his homeland of France, thus showing how through language, the background of the discoverers of the elements could be conveyed. Similarly, the elements of Scandium and Germanium were discovered by a Scandinavian and German scientist respectively, leading to their names. Thus, in conclusion, one can see how inductive, deductive reasoning, as well as language as a ways of knowing can be seen to be rather accurate, though in reality, they are also hindered by limitations with regards to their employment, which make it inadequate to thoroughly prove something scientifically. While deduction is based on a logical progression based on true premises, it does not allow for observation or experimentation to test the validity. Likewise, though induction is driven by observation of trends, it does not use the logical progression which is featured in the deductive reasoning to make its proof. Hence, the development of scientific method would necessitate the synthesis and usage of BOTH logical approached to make for an all encompassing conclusion. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate Theory of Knowledge section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate Theory of Knowledge essays

  1. TOK History Essay

    English spoken today and hence it was a huge shame for them because they could not interpret their own language. In addition, the interpretation of Beowulf was done differently when composed in the Anglic dialect and when translated to Standard English, showing that history can be interpreted differently based on the language that was used then.

  2. Discuss the claim that some areas of knowledge are discovered and others are invented

    Where does this knowledge come from, if the shapes do not and cannot exist? We have two possibilities open to us. The first option is that perfect shapes do exist, in some transcendent non-physical form. This belief is based on that posited by Plato, the ancient Greek philosopher.

  1. Discuss the claim that some Areas of Knowledge are discovered and others are invented.

    I believe that fractals are best explained as self-similarity or a pattern that is reoccurring within itself. We learned that Fractal Geometry is present in all forms of nature such as plants, weather and trees. Even in the nature of human biology for instance the shape of lungs, kidneys and blood vessels.

  2. TOK: What are the effects of biased language and unsound reasoning on history?

    According to David Hume, our ideas through which our reason transacts are just copies of our impressions. These impressions give rise to our feelings or passions regarding a particular thing. These impressions are then articulated through language, and language is used to communicate thoughts.

  1. Discuss the claim that some areas of knowledge are discovered and others are invented.

    The reason for that is that sometimes we are influenced by the physical world without us realizing, and at times it is just a coincidence. Let us take Pythagorean theorem as an example, it states that the shorter two sides of a triangle squared are he same length as the longer side squared.

  2. Hebraism and Hellenism by Matthew Arnold. Applying Arnold's analysis to modern day America.

    If we didn?t play well then we would run. If you don?t follow Gods word then you will be punished. For as often as Hebraism is shown in the Bible, Hellenism is shown in Greek literature. The Greeks believed more in thinking. Some of the greatest thinkers in the world were Greek such as Socrates or Plato.

  1. Theory of Knowledge: There is no distinction between true or false. Discuss

    theory: ?there is no absolute distinction between true or false.? but also in science which is logical. There are examples of a classical belief like ?Spontaneous Generation? which has been tested with the adoption of scientific method. The classical beliefs are quickly crumbled in this generation.

  2. History is always on the move, slowly eroding todays orthodoxy and making space for ...

    In 1898 Thompson imagined an atom to be like 'Plum Pudding'. Rutherford (1911) presented the 'Planetary' model, which shows electrons in finite orbits. In the present model, we imagine the electrons in orbitals having precise energies and diffuse spacial properties, often referred to as electron clouds.3 The model of displaying atoms keeps changing and so does chemistry.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work