• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How victims of globalisation have been presented in poems, novels and films.

Extracts from this document...


In the late 20th century some people could be regarded or see themselves as victims of globalisation. Critically evaluate the way composers have represented these people to show how globalisation has created ways of thinking that have affected them. Globalisation has seen the erosion of traditional boundaries, in order for technology to expand the communication of universal truths, collapsing time and distance, and homogenise global and local constructions of reality into a single cultural identity. This "culture of cultures," however, maintains values which perpetuate negative impacts upon the local, victimising one's cultural environment and identity on various levels as can be seen in Seamus Heaney's poems - "Digging" and "Requiem for the Croppies," and Annie Proulx's novel- "The Shipping News." These texts along with others including Yasumara Morimara's visual "The Slaughter Cabinet II," the film "Snow Falling on Cedar," and the Television series - "Star Trek: Voyager;" use various techniques and paradigms to illustrate how retreating becomes a way of challenging the status quo, through preserving the local. These texts illustrate the way globalisation has created different ways of thinking, which have often emphasised the way one struggles to exclude the global, or balance both cultural forces. These different ways of thinking have often come to existence, as a result of individuals who become aware of the disintegration of the qualities which make their local traditional and enlightening. ...read more.


Scientifically, there are those who argue that the victimisation of the local is inevitable, as culture is a social invention, changing since the beginning of history. The "Requiem for the Croppies" however, utilizes past tense to create a nihilistic atmosphere illustrating the way a retreat can be made through counterattacking all consuming global forces such as colonialism - ""Terraced thousands died, shaking scythes at cannons." The image of the priest and the tramp together, transcends class and religious barriers, and illustrates the way the local upholds their land to any cost. The phrase "Shaking scythes at cannons" is symbolic of the inadequacies suffered by the local, however, it allows the local to inherit heroic qualities. The first person plural of "we" and "our," further personalises the local's struggle. The imagery of the barley and the notion of time, invokes the audience's sense of justice, attentively highlighting the local's defiance through counterattacking -"and in august...the barley grew up out of our grave." Like Heaney's poems, the positive qualities of the local, brings about a struggle for those who are confronted with the pressure of global networks to standardise. chapter 25 of "The Shipping News," in particular, sees Proulx's characterisation of Tert Card and Billy Petty, illustrate her debates on the ways individuals are economically victimised - "We're all going to be rich... ...read more.


The contrast of flashbacks however illustrates the extent to which global attitudes affect the local. The parade scene, for instance, is similar to the Christmas Pageant, and contrasts to the flashbacks of World War II, where Japanese fellow citizens are placed into concentration camps. The discontinuation of the music, the spatial distance between the boat exporting the Japanese people and the island creates a dramatic visual impact, convincing us that, at times, the chance the local spirit retreat, after the erosion of communal values, is relatively less. Retreating from the global constitutes an exclusion of global ways and a preservation of contrasting traditional values in order to avoid a victimisation the global perpetuates. As the texts show through creating symbolic relationships with global and local concepts, globalisation has created a vast tapestry of ideals and values. The representations of one's retreat, suggest that the global is all consuming, and negatively impacts upon local culture, as consumerism, materialism and hedonism erode traditions and identity. Retreating is thus more preferable, however, may not always be possible due to the degree cultures have become standardised. Some of the composers, however, illustrate that the global can provide benefits to accommodate the inadequacies of the local. And in turn, most of the texts point to the ideal that there is a need to integrate global and local aspects - a glocalised culture, in order to substantially support one's identity in the 20th century. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate World Literature section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate World Literature essays

  1. Two poems that have captured the essence of emotional survival are Katrina by Bruce ...

    that he has done all he can do and he is still helpless, that by writing this poem nothing has changed. Dawe also uses many metaphors to show the preciousness of the child's life. The most obvious of these is "against the black velvet threatening your life shines like a jewel".

  2. Free essay

    It has been said that literature consists of victors and victims. Discuss how the ...

    This would then mean that the indirect murderer would have been Angela Vicario. This would then ultimately mean that the Vicario brothers were a victim that were also caught up in a big lie and had to pay the consequences for actions that they thought were necessary and correct but had a falsified reason.

  1. WIT Essay_Zorba the Greek_Personification of Dyonisian and Epicurean Values in Zorba

    The other significant aspect of Epicureanism is the indifference toward death; according to Epicureanism there is no after life. Freidrich Nietzsche believed humanity should work to enhance the life of the individual and focus on the realities of the present world.

  2. During the entire novel of The Sorrow of War Kien is on a quest ...

    These 'terrible things' come to a head when the men discover that their sweethearts have been shot. Again, Ninh's motives are unclear. While it is evident that the nature of the affair meets his disapproval, demonstrated by its violent end, we are again left wondering whether it is the specifics

  1. I will be examining two poems, The History Teacher by Billy Collins and The ...

    My interpretation is because the word "chilly" has an alliteration link with the word "million" in the same line. The word "sweaters" has also been specifically chosen because the term "sweater" is a term used to cover various types of garments like jumper, pullover and sweatshirt.

  2. Commentary on Twice Shy by Seamus Heaney

    Heaney limits the poem to just the two protagonists. This is a deliberate decision on the poet's part: by isolating characterization, Heaney conveys the feeling that for either character, there is but one destination: each other. It is an idyllic and arguably somewhat clich� concept of love; that certain pairs of people are fated for each other.

  1. An exploration of the ways in which injustice in both novels is revealed. ...

    Their breakfast 'skilly' includes 'little fish' whose flesh had 'disintegrated', 'cabbage' and sometimes it consists only of 'carrot', which is followed by 'magara porridge', which was "tasteless when hot, and left you no sense of having filled your belly"(p. 18).

  2. Stereotyping in Literature - 4 modern American novels concerned with ethnic identity.

    Norms within a group are usually seen as internal rules that the group members tend to follow so that the group itself will be more efficient. These norms set up leadership roles, ways of approaching each other and outsiders,

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work