Genetic Diversity
Captive breeding also aims to maintain genetic diversity which can be lost by random genetic drift. Genetic diversity represents a variation of DNA within cells. During asexual reproduction, off spring inherit alleles from both parents which might be slightly different. Large populations will usually have a greater diversity of alleles compared to small populations. This diversity indicates a greater potential for evolution of new combinations of genes and a greater capacity for evolutionary adaptation to different habitats. In other words, the population would be fitter. (9)
A number of factors faced by conservation breeding programs contribute to wards the reduction of genetic diversity
Founder Effect
The founder effect is another genetic problem with captive breeding.
The picture above illustrates a founder effect with the original population on the left and three founder populations on the right.
Founder effect is therefore when a new population is established but only carrying a small fraction of the original population so genetic variation is limited. (10)
Genetic Drift
When an organism is unable to reproduce and so therefore results in genetic traits being lost from a population. This is genetic drift.
Genetic drift is more likely in a smaller population as the gene pool is very limited. (20)
Inbreeding
Inbreeding is the breeding of animals which have the same recent ancestors. As a consequence inbreeding depression is an exposure of the animal to the effects of harmful recessive genes. (6)
Homozygosity (7)
In the picture above it is shown that for the given locus, some alleles will present more fitness on an individual than other alleles. Within the other class of alleles are rare harmful recessive alleles, which when appearing as a homozygous genotype in an individual.
To prevent inbreeding stud books can be used. Studbooks are used for monitoring and managing populations. They provide an accurate database for particular species that allows detailed genetic analyses. They contain all the information, for species in every zoo in the world, which includes birth, death, ancestors, gender and etc. (8)
Out breeding to prevent Homozygosity
Genetic drift, the founder effect and inbreeding all lead to increasing homozygosity as explained previously. This is a state of possessing two identical forms of a particular gene, one inherited from each parent.
Out breeding is encouraged in order to prevent homozygosity. This can be done in the aid of stud books. Obviously the best strategy would be to mate individuals form different populations. However out breeding can also sometime e a problem. This is because different isolated populations may evolve different complexes of genes that interact well within a particular population but poorly when the genes are mixed though population mating. These defects in the offspring are called out breeding depression. (11)
Summary
Overall captive breeding can be reviewed to be successful. This is proven as a number of species have been thriving in the wild after their reintroduction. An example of such species is Visayan Writhed Hornbills.
Endangered birds’ future was threatened due loss of forest habitat (12)
As a total there were only 200 of these birds left in the wild until the project to save the population was invoked. Chester zoo and Vogelpark Avifauna has funded over £180,000 between 1994 -2004. (12)
Future Developments
As more and more animals are recognised to be endangered, captive breeding programs have adapted to this in order to conserve the species at danger of extinction. As result of aiming to achieve this, new medical development have been introduced with one being Cyropreservation.
Cyropreservation equipment to conserve endangered species (15)
This is a valuable tool used to preserve sperm or tissues for future use. These samples are stored at 196 degrees. Frozen sperm or tissues may be kept or sent of to zoos which house only females of the species.
Moving embryos from one site to another will allow the transfer of genes which is very important for maintaining fitness an adaptability of the population. This means that fewer animals may be kept in captive as a result of this. (13, 14) Therefore the animals are allowed to develop in their natural environment without the threat of becoming extinct. Another ETHICAL issue that can be raised from this is that success rate of establishing a pregnancy using frozen embryos is generally lower than in a fresh cycle. Some may believe that establishing a pregnancy using frozen embryos is forcing god’s plans.
An alternative method to preserve endangered species is cloning. In its short history cloning has been successful as well as unsuccessful. The most recognised subject is a sheep called ‘Dolly’.
There are several types of cloning however, the one that the media most reports and the one that is used to preserve endangered animals is reproductive cloning. (16)
Both processes replace the nucleus (green dot in the figure) of a donated egg cell (yellow circle) with the desired nucleus (red dot) of a cell (grey circle) from the parent organism. This results in an egg containing the desired nucleus (17)
Cloning may be effective to maintain a species at danger of extinction. An unfertilised egg is removed from the mother and a culture cell from the animal to be cloned. An animal with identical information to that of the nucleus donor is produced. Due to this, gene diversity can be lost as identical genes mean that it will weaken the power and adaptations which makes the offspring subjected to great diseases. (17)
Also from cloning many ETHICAL issues can be raised. Many areas of the public have been quick to identify the ethical issues involved in reproductive cloning and to argue, almost commonly, for an international ban on such attempts. Meanwhile, scientists have proceeded with extensive research agendas in the cloning of animals. Despite this research, the public has decided against the cloning of animals as they believe it is forcing god’s plans once again. It is a controversial point that this procedure is highly unethical due to the incredibly high mortality rate of the cloned infants.
However is it proven that cloning can be successful as explained above ‘Dolly’ survived 6 years. She was the world’s first cloned mammal. (18)
‘Dolly’ Scotland’s most famous sheep (18)
In my opinion these future development are an advantage to conserve endangered animals. However both Cyropreservation and cloning both have their own individual drawbacks, yet still have been successful in proving that they succeed. Again each of the two future developments explained above have similar ETHICAL and MORAL issues which effects its further development, but cloning animals has displayed more highly unethical issues than Cyropreservation such as high mortality rate.
For this reason I believe that Cyropreservation maybe the stronger and more successful development from the two in order to save endangered species. It allows extensive amounts of genetic material to be stored over many years without having to decide on a verdict whether to use them or not there and then.
Bibliography
- North of England Zoological Society – Zoo-based research Chester Zoo
- http://science.kennesaw.edu/~tmcelro/Evolution/RND%20Genetic%20Drift%20Notes.ppt#270,24,Slide 24
- http://en.mikipedia.org/wiki/genetic_drift
Validity
Source 19 is biased as it is mainly based on the disadvantages of zoos and its aims and outcomes. However it is useful as it raises ethical issues related to the captive breeding. Born free is a pressure group and also it is a website completely against zoos and captive breeding, as it contains a lot of negative information and uses emotive images and language to portray its point of view. However I used the information found in this source along with my other sources to explore the ethical and the moral issues raised from using the future developments.
Source 5, 8 & 20 are taken from Wikipedia and contain facts which may have been added to the site by either a member of the public, a scientist. This makes it difficult to rely on the information provided completely. The website information has been edited by scientists and there are also direct links to the original sources such as scientific articles to support the literature. However I used this information after checking its validity by browsing through other websites which it was accurate as it has been discussed on two or more different sources.
Source 3, I believe is valid, as it comes from Chester Zoo containing primary information, with stats from their zoo to support this. The editor of these leaflets is the zoological society who is a very recognised group of zoologists. So therefore they are very accurate about the information being provided to the public. This makes me think that the information must be valid and correct; otherwise this information would not have been published by them.
This report is based on a visit to Chester Zoo.
The issues are role of a zoo and captive breeding at Chester Zoo. The main issue is Captive breeding.
This report is aimed at a group of A-Level students who are studying A-Level Biology and is written in a magazine style.
Words: 1983 words