• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Explain Milgram's concept of the agentic state and discuss whether it is a valid explanation for obedience. What other explanations for obedience have been put forward and what evidence support these?

Extracts from this document...


´╗┐Explain Milgram's concept of the agentic state and discuss whether it is a valid explanation for obedience. What other explanations for obedience have been put forward and what evidence support these? Obedience is taught from childhood through a process of socialisation. Individuals are constantly facing authority figures and taking orders, often without even being aware they are doing so. Parents, teachers, bosses are just a few authority figures almost every individual will have come across throughout their life. Most orders given on a day-to-day basis will be harmless, but what happens when they are not? What happens when a person is asked to harm another with no seemingly legitimate reason? Milgram's famous studies focusing on obedience to authority look at just that, and his agency theory tries to form reasons as to why people obey. Milgram (1963) suggests that the mind works on two levels of consciousness and individuals will shift between the two (the agentic shift) when confronted with authority due to the process of socialisation. The autonomous state is where an individual assumes responsibility for their own actions and the consequences of their behaviour. ...read more.


Although the agency theory provides some valid concepts especially when explaining the importance of the relationship between a feeling of personal responsibility and levels of obedience displayed by subjects, it is often criticised as not providing enough of an explanation. It is viewed more of a description of the social system and how it works rather than and explanation of obedience. Social power is one alternative explanation of obedience. French and Raven (1959) identified five different types of social power; reward, coercive, referent, legitimate and expert. Figures deemed to hold authority within any society hold at least one of these forms of social power. Dependant on which form of power they hold, individuals are likely to obey for different reasons. Reward power results in positive reinforcement, Milgram's participants may have felt compelled to obey him because they were being paid to do so. Coercive power is the opposite, fear of negative reinforcement. Due to the fact the Milgram was asking for electric shocks to be administered, participants may have felt an element of fear for him. Milgram may have also been seen to hold both legitimate and expert power, as he was seen as an expert in his scientific field and would have been dressed in such a way that illustrated this reinforcing his legitimacy. ...read more.


Participants would have deemed Milgram as holding, expert, legitimate, coercive and reward power therefore making him appear a very powerful authority figure indeed. The ?learner? was also out of sight, therefore providing the argument for the social identification theory. Participants would have seen the ?learner? as the outside group, identifying with the experimenter. When social identity was broken between the two, participants were far less likely to obey orders. Although there isn't much empirical evidence for personality affecting obedience in Milgram's study. It has been found to be a deterministic feature for decision making and resisting social pressures in other studies (Blass, 1991), therefore making it impossible to rule it out as a factor affecting obedience. As Milgram's agency theory is seen more as a definition rather than an explanation of obedience it would be more plausible to use other theories such as the social identification theory to draw conclusions as to why people obey. Milgram has however provided valuable insight into understanding of obedience and much more recent research would not have been possible without his original findings. His studies into obedience to authority still remain the most recognised and talked about obedience studies world wide. Word Count: 1483. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Social Psychology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Social Psychology essays

  1. This house believes that, without exception, euthanasia

    Another problem is while this is happening, health resources are being used on people who cannot be cured and who would rather not continue living for their own reasons. Abuse of this would be disallowed by only permitting the individual who wanted to die to initiate the procedure, and by policy that thoroughly prohibited mistreatment.

  2. Explain the importance of team building, the stages in the development of team cohesion ...

    Groups are often forming and changing, and each time that happens, they can move to a different Stage. A group might be norming or performing, but a new member might force them back into storming. 'The development of a team might be recycled from any of the final stages to

  1. A Critical Appraisal of the Concept of Medicalization for Understanding Dementia.

    Furthermore, whatever the individual does out of character is a result of the disease. An alternative to the reductionist and disease orientated biomedical model is a holistic and contextual social model where ill health is caused by social factors (Gillespie & Gerhardt 1998).

  2. This essay will discuss sociological research and theories that offer the potential for advising ...

    of each other (Barry et al 1957 cited in Miell and Dallos 2002) Knowledge from the biological perspective helps us to develop an increased awareness of the possible influence of biological factors on our behaviour and relationships such as patterns of behaviour, s****l jealousy, and partner selection.

  1. Repressed memories are a figment of the imagination -critically discuss

    Briere and Conte(1993) stated that abuse characteristics more likely to produce psychological conflict such as enjoyment of the abuse, acceptance of bribes, feelings of guilt or shame were not connected with abuse-related amnesia. The results of this study were interpreted as supporting theories of post-traumatic stress disorder Feldman-Summers & Pope (1994)

  2. A summary and evaluation of Burger, J.M. 2009 Replicating Milgram: Would people still obey ...

    Volunteers were told that the experiment was looking at the effects of punishment on learning, and that they would receive $50 for participating in the experiment in contrast to the $4.50 Milgram offered. Selected individuals were informed on several times (twice in writing)

  1. Yawning through technical mediums. The object of the experiment was to see if ...

    Participants were presented with sounds of people yawning/breathing while they lay in the MRI setup. The participants pressed buttons correlated with a four point scale: ?1 = in no way felt like yawning, 2 = felt like yawning a little, 3 = strongly felt like yawning, 4 = actual/stifled yawn)? (Arnott, 2009).

  2. Causes of Aggressive behaviour. The causes of aggressive behavior can be divided into ...

    Men with high levels of testosterone are more likely to show aggressive behaviors (Berman, Gladue & Tylor, 1993). Also, there are other studies which have found that both males and females who have higher levels of testosterone are aggressive individuals (Carlson, 2004; Dabbs et al., 1987; cited in Franzoi, 2006).

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work