• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Neutrality in psychoanalysis. Psychoanalysts draw many parallels with Batman. Psychoanalysts are also devoted to helping others and follow a set of principles when in practice. An essential part of the psychoanalytic code is neutrality.

Extracts from this document...


Running head: PSYCHOANALYSTS ARE BATMAN Neutral Psychoanalysts: I am Batman Mathew Gullotta Macquarie University Neutral Psychoanalysts: I am Batman Batman. When read, the image of a superhero with a profound power devoted to helping others comes to mind. Defined by the Complete Scoundrel sourcebook (McArtor & Schneider, 2007) as a "neutral good" character, Batman adheres to a personal code, in which he is unbiased in doing 'good', while remaining unindebted to those he helps. This personal code was devised to maintain a greater good in society by providing a set of guiding principles that aid in making moral decisions and is followed when fighting crime. Psychoanalysts draw many parallels with Batman. Psychoanalysts are also devoted to helping others and follow a set of principles when in practice. An essential part of the psychoanalytic code is neutrality. According to Meissner (1998) "neutrality has been long honored as an essential component of the [psycho]analytic situation and process" (p. 1089). The concept of neutrality has recently been the basis of highly controversial debate. Emphasis has been placed on the interactions of the analyst, in particular the use of self-disclosures. Analysts have examined the outcomes of neutrality and self-disclosure in the analytical process. These authors have purported mixed stances. Some analysts have advocated neutrality (e.g., Freud, 1912, as cited in Schatcher & K�chele, 2007; McIlwain, 2007). ...read more.


On the other hand, the analyst can participate more in the analytic process by self-disclosing. Schachter and K�chele (2007) argued that interactions, such as self-disclosure, are two-fold. Firstly, the patient participates less and important areas of the account may be obscured. Secondly, without open expression and interaction from the analyst, the patient may feel inhibited to further explore personal affects. Schachter and K�chele proposed that self-disclosure by the analyst can encourage the patient in ancillary examination. However, this prompting may be problematic. The patient may be more likely conform to, rather than challenge, the ideas of the analyst and consequently providing a false account (Shill, 2004). Analytical neutrality can overcome this fault. As a result of maximum concentration, the analyst can easily identify the areas that require attention when conducting the analysis. The analyst can probe these areas by asking carefully devised questions in order to open dialogue allowing for greater self-examination by the patient. In light of this solution, analytic neutrality is advantageous to self-disclosure techniques as neutrality can "empower [the patient], rather than encourag[e] a dependency on analyst as problem solver" (McIlwain, 2007). Likewise, the code of Batman not only maximizes his autonomy in fighting crime, it also provides a medium in which he can control and channel his attention towards doing 'good'. ...read more.


This can be juxtaposed to the subjective intrusions that occur with self-disclosing techniques. Not only do self-disclosing techniques interfere with how the patient is examined, they can also result in the denial of appropriate interventions (Shill, 2004). The inevitable expectations that psychoanalysts usually have for their patients may have a significant influence on intervention. However, the use of neutrality may be essential when devising appropriate interventions for the patient. Another criticism is that the analytical neutrality tends to disengage the patient from the analyst (Meissner, 1998). Some critics suggest that although neutrality remains equidistant from the requirements of the drives, ego, and superego, it does not preclude the existence of the intent of the therapy (Greenberg, 1986). Alternatively, proponents of neutrality assert that although neutrality may be passive in nature, there is still involvement between patient and analyst (Mills, 2007). One can suggest that as the participant-observer relationship exists, in the essence that the analyst inevitably interacts with the patient, neutrality precludes disengagement the patient. In conclusion, the patient's autonomy, guidance towards the analytic process, and the influence on interventions are aspects of the analytic process in which neutrality is advantageous to self-disclosing techniques. Through thorough evaluation it is evident that, similarly to Batman's personal code which acts as a guiding force in his assignment to fighting crime, neutrality functions to guide the analysts in the analytic process. With adherence to a code which is intended to non-pejoratively help others, one can conclude that psychoanalysts are Batman. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Social Psychology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Social Psychology essays

  1. Life coaching course essay. I present in this essay an understanding of what motivation ...

    I wanted to understand her underlying need for change be sure the change will bring long lasting fulfilment and it is right for her. I questioned her and "drilled down" to see what was beneath this need for change. I reflected her words back to her and asked questions to probe for a deeper understanding of her needs.

  2. Tony Montana, a case study of the effectiveness of Sigmund Freud(TM)s Psychoanalytic approach to ...

    The superego also acts to the standards to which the ego determines right and wrong. The super ego can fail to develop in some individuals if a child is raised poorly (Mischel & Plomin 1999). Our character in question is raised by his mother only, and is not close to

  1. Explain the importance of team building, the stages in the development of team cohesion ...

    They are highly committed but generally only have a narrow contribution to make. Being specialists in their field of work they have greater depth of knowledge on the subject then others and therefore demand a high level of concentration from team members.

  2. Multiple Sclerosis: Functional History (Department of Psychology - University of Liverpool)

    Spasticity can physically affect a person in a number of ways where the lower limbs are typically more severely affected than the upper limbs. The following effects of spasticity are presented which debilitate MS patients and limit their day to day activities (Nicolson and Anderson, 2001): * Difficulty moving limbs

  1. A Critical Appraisal of the Concept of Medicalization for Understanding Dementia.

    The medical label of dementia legitimates an individual's bizarre behaviour. Medical labels and authority also ease the stress of dementia care by increasing the sense of predictability and control for caregivers. However, a disadvantage is that once the label of dementia has been applied, even normal behaviour is interpreted in terms of disease stages.

  2. Free essay

    Investigation of the Effect of Bystander Behaviour on Helping Behaviour in a Non-Emergency Situation

    To test the diffusion theory, participants either were alone or with another person when given an opportunity to provide help in a mild or 'non-emergency' situation. To simultaneously test the normative theory, there were two conditions in which the participant was in a situation with another bystander; one in which the bystander helped (the helping-confederate condition)

  1. According to attribution theorists the laypersons judgments of others are biased

    Attribution biases support that people have a tendency to overestimate the power of personal characteristics and underestimate the power of situational issues when they make attributions, researchers called this condition as the "fundamental attribution error". Fein, Hilton and Miller in 1990 argued that people will not underestimate situational factors to

  2. Free essay

    In their attempts to transcend the individual-society dualism in understandings of the self, how ...

    Holloway and Jefferson's (2005, cited in Holloway, 2007) example of Vince's 'choice', demonstrates how unconscious conflictual desires surpass conscious awareness leaving only resolution at the forefront of people's thoughts. This happens once the unconscious defence mechanisms have resolved the contradictory feelings; in Vince's case the conflicting feelings about his job were resolved unconsciously and resurfaced as physical symptoms allowing him to stop working.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work