• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

What Limits if any should be placed on the use of the following Biotechnologies. Cloning and Embryonic Stem Cell in Research and Treatment

Extracts from this document...


´╗┐Controversies & Ethical Dilemmas In Science & Technology Department of Humanities Imperial College London What Limits if any should be placed on the use of the following Biotechnologies. Cloning and Embryonic Stem Cell in Research and Treatment In this paper I will discuss the moral issues surrounding Cloning and Stem Cell research biotechnologies and whether appropriate restrictions need to be enforced to address many of the controversial aspects regarding the conduct of research. The use of human embryonic stem cell (hESC) research is associated with many ethical controversies, as during the stem cell harvest process many embryos are destroyed. Many consider the destruction of nascent human life immoral and unethical. [1] To address this issue, the hESC policy debate in the United States focused on enforcing appropriate limits on the use of public dollar contributing to hESC research. [2] Many opponents to embryonic stem cell research believe it is morally unacceptable to fund what they perceive as being a highly controversial area of science. However, during the debate there was little disagreement on the legality of the research, and on August 9th 2001, President George W. Bush favored funding of stem cell research. [3] The guidelines set out by Bush agreed that the federal government should not fund hESC research, which required further destruction of embryos [2] (i.e. stem cell research conducted using only spare embryos from in-vitro fertilization estimated at more than 400,000 in the US alone [3]). ...read more.


[7] Rebecca Dresser, a Professor of Ethics at Washington University, addresses the issues surrounding the use of human embryos in research, and discusses whether the intention for which embryos are created for matter, and if embryos deserve ?special respect? due to their ?potentiality?. [7] Much like Blackford, Dresser concludes that at the point at which stem cells are derived, the early embryos lack many characteristics, including the ability to think, feel pleasure or more importantly pain, since their nervous system hasn?t yet formed. [7] Consequently, Dresser believes that due to the facts, many people perceive early embryos as lacking a moral status. Dresser raises an important question: ?if early embryos aren?t persons?can anything be done with them?. [7] To answer this question it is fundamental to understand the intentions for which embryos are or may be created. To highlight the significance of these views (i.e. embryos lacking moral status), which are currently being endorsed in embryo research, Dresser raises a fundamental issue concerning the creation of an embryo via cloning a living persons cell (procedure known as ?therapeutic cloning?) for biomedical research purposes. [7] Rebecca argues that deliberately ?creating human life? for research, undermines the ?special respect? embryos possess due to their potentiality and that we are treating embryos too much like objects. [7] She predicts that if the Bush administration is willing to give a lack of moral status to embryo, the implications may result in a slippery-slope. ...read more.


[11] Even though I disagree with the use of animals in cloning, I believe the opinions of the GAEIB must be considered if animal cloning continues to take place. However, many researchers today have violated the fundamental ethical conditions, which allow work on animals being viewed as acceptable. For instance, Dolly the sheep was euthanized due to a progressive lung disease and severe arthritis. [9] According to the outlines set out by the GAEIB, researchers violated the condition, which states that researchers have the ?duty to avoid animal or minimize animal suffering since unjustified or disproportionate suffering is unacceptable?. [11] Embryonic stem cell research and cloning will continue to take place, even though many ethical and moral issues surround the biotechnologies. It is therefore essential that governing bodies place appropriate limits on the use of biotechnologies, and ensure further effort is made to improve public awareness of such technologies. [11]They must realize that as science evolves, new technologies will increase the power of people over nature. [11] Therefore researchers have a responsibility and duty to ensure research work is conducted according to a strict mandate. [11] Whether we decide that the certain areas of biotechnologies are morally wrong and unacceptable depends on what moral status we assign to early embryos as discussed in the paper. Essentially, we must ensure that the agriculture and medical benefits of using the biotechnologies outweigh the ethical controversies it is associated with. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Applied Biology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Applied Biology essays

  1. Bi technology and food security: The clue for a new green revolution?

    effects on human health: for instance GM food with a higher content of digestible iron is likely to have a positive effect if consumed by iron- deficient individuals. Moreover there is a difficulty predicting the occurrence of long-term environmental effects, the precautionary approach, then, is the only solution to face this scientific uncertainty.

  2. Isolation & Characterisation of Proteins. The purpose of conducting this experiment is to ...

    Furthermore, it might also due to the electrophoresis process running too long, some of the later bands could have flow out of the gel, and this too could give different measurements within the bands formed (Darling & Brickal, 1994). Part B: Ion-Exchange Chromatography In the ion exchange chromatography part, for

  1. The Germ Theory of Disease. In the nineteenth century when the distribution of microscopes ...

    In Needham's experiment he heated broths, and transferred them into covered flasks, believing all of the microorganisms were killed by boiling, thus when they were cooled and were found to be turbid with microorganisms, he deemed it was evidence enough to prove that spontaneous generation did indeed occur.

  2. Comparing and and contrasting the endocrine system with the nervous system in their control ...

    The nervous system is defined as a brain, spinal cord and peripheral nerves (Bradley & Calvert 2011). The most important function of the endocrine system is to maintain homeostasis (Bradley & Calvert 2011). Humans belong to a group of endothermic animals that must maintain constant body temperature Native Remedies (2012)

  1. Food Science -Experiments to Determine the Properties and Uses of Enzymes in Food Preperation.

    Peroxidase also plays a very important role in degrading and synthesizing lignin in cell wall damage and repair. It provides defense against pathogens and stress, controls respiration and promotes formation of highly reactive species (Whitaker, 2003). Activity of peroxidase is also used to evaluate the effectiveness of blanching treatment (Karel, 2003).

  2. Tumour markers and their role in Cancer diagnostics

    Meanwhile future tumour markers such as tissue inhibitor of metalloproteinase-1 (TIMP-1), a marker for colorectal cancer (Holten-Anderson, 2005), and the p53 gene (Thor, 1992) are currently under research. Word count 1887 words (excluding cover page and bibliography). ________________ References Ahmed, N., Dawson, M., Smith, C., and Wood, E.

  1. Optimization of DNA Extraction from Medically and Environmentally important Fungi for Polymerase Chain Reaction

    walls, as they are often resistant to traditional DNA extraction procedures.DNA extractions from filamentous fungi possess difficulties because of its high polysaccharide contents. The use of liquid nitrogen in some extraction methods also effective against the breaking the fungal cell wall content, but in our present method the usage of such chemicals were completely eliminated.

  2. Regional anatomy - case studies of the spinal region

    In our case, patient developed Spina bifida cystica as a result of the failure of closure of one or more vertebral arches, and frequently this condition allows the herniation of meninges and/or spinal cord. The third question reviews various types of neural tube disorders and their presentation.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work