a1. – 12 + 12 =
a2. – 2 = – 2 (increase rent expense)
b1. – 3 + 3 =
b2. – 3 = – 3 (increase supplies expense)
c1. – 4 + 4 =
c2. – 4 = – 4 (increase advertising expense)
d1. – 9 + 9 =
d2. _ _ _ _ – 9 = – 9 (increase training expense)
The steps shown capture the essence of what is happening. The problem is not explicit that all of the supplies are used during the month, so some students may omit b2. Similarly, some students may argue that c2 and d2 are not clear from the problem, the advertisement and training might occur more than one month hence. The problem invites such discussion. You may wish to extend this example to reflect the more expedient procedure many accountants would use to record items which are immediately used up as expenses. For example, c and d might appear as:
c. – 4 = – 4 (increase advertising expense)
d. – 9 = – 9 (increase training expense)
2-35 (15 min.)
The cash balance on June 30 was $61,000, as shown in the balance sheet equation transactions in Exhibit 2-35. The cash balance is the only beginning or ending balance that is available from the data.
2-36 (10-15 min.)
1. The name of the statement is antiquated. It should be titled income statement (or statement of earnings, statement of operations, or operating statement).
2. The line with the date should not be for an instant of time but for an indicated span of time; a year, a quarter, or a month ending on December 31, 20X3.
3. Increases in market values of land and buildings are not usually recognized in historical cost accounting.
4. Dividends are not expenses and are not deducted before net profit is computed.
5. The appropriate deduction is the cost of goods sold, not the cost of the cars purchased.
6. The bottom line should be titled net income or net earnings.
7. Although it is not the major point of the problem, the income statement has apparently omitted some expenses; for example, neither rent nor depreciation is shown. As a minimum, one or the other would ordinarily be included.
EXHIBIT 2-35
Greenville Company
Analysis of Transaction for June
(In Thousands of Dollars)
Assets = Liabilities and Stockholders' Equity
Accounts Merchandise Accounts Paid–in Retained
Transactions Cash + Receivable + Inventory + Equipment = Payable + Capital _ Earnings
Balance,
6/1 /X4 + 15 ? ? ? = ? ? ?
a. + 80 -80 =
b. - 45 = - 45
c. + 18 = + 18
d1. + 23 + 30 = + 53 (increase sales revenue)
d2. - 24 = - 24 (increase cost of
goods sold expense)
e. – 1 = – 1 (increase depreciation
expense)
f. – 12 _ _ _ = _ _ – 12 (dividends)
Balance,
12/31/X4 + 61
2-37 (5-10 min.) Amounts are in millions.
1.
2. Dividends = $369.4 – $257.7 – $111.7 = $0
2-38 (20-30 min.) Amounts are in thousands of dollars.
The basic relations used in these problems are:
Revenues – Expenses = Net income
Assets = Liabilities + Stockholders’ equity
Beginning retained earnings + Net income – Dividends = Ending retained earnings
Beginning paid-in-capital + additional investment = Ending paid-in-capital.
1. E = 145 – 125 = 20
D = 30 + 20 = 50
C = 15 because there were no additional investments by stockholders
A = 80 – 15 – 30 = 35; or 80 – (15 + 30) = 35
B = 95 – 15 – 50 = 30; or 95 – (15 + 50) = 30
2-38 (continued)
2. K = 20 + 200 = 220
J = 60 + 20 – 5 = 75
H = 10 + 40 = 50
F = 60 + 10 + 90 = 160
G = 280 – 75 – 50 = 155
3. P = 280 – 240 = 40
Q = 120 + 40 - 130 = 30
N = 85 – 35 = 50
L = 105 + 50 + 120 = 275
M = 95 + 85 + 130 = 310
2-39 (10-15 min.)
This is straightforward. Computations are in millions of dollars:
A = 28,754 - 6,794 = 21,960
B = 9,524 + 2,218 = 11,742
C = 2,558 - 2,218 - 441 = (101)
D = 5,254+ 22,004 = 27,258
2-40 (10-15 min.)
1. Income statement or operating statement is used instead of statement of income and expenses.
2. The end of the fiscal year is typically identified.
3. The terms income or profit are used rather than surplus (and net income rather than net surplus).
-
The term loss is used instead of deficit.
- A profit-seeking organization would not receive a subsidy.
2-41 (10-15 min.)
This problem demonstrates how financial statements provide information for investor decisions. These ratios are compared with other companies in the industry and with the company's ratios through the years.
2-42 (10-15 min.)
1. $1,132,000,000 ÷ $1.07 = 1,057,943,925 average shares
2. $1.07 x 2.62 = $2.80; this is much larger than the $1.07 EPS.
3. (a) $2.80 ÷ $66 = 4.2% dividend yield
(b) $66 ÷ $1.07 = 61.7 P-E ratio
2-43 (20-30 min.)
1 and 2. See Exhibit 2-43 on the following page.
3. RAMANATHAN CORPORATION
Income Statement
For the Month Ended June 30, 20X2
Accrual Basis Cash Basis
Sales $115,000 Revenue (cash collected
from customers*) $ 45,000
Deduct: Cost of Expenses (cash disbursed
goods sold 60,000 for merchandise) 80,000
Net cash used by
Net income $ 55,000 operating activities $(35,000)
*The entire revenue is cash sales. If any cash had been collected from credit customers during June, it would be added here.
The accrual basis provides a better measure of the economic accomplishments and efforts of the entity. The cash basis is inferior because it fails to recognize revenue as earned (the sales on credit), and it often recognizes expenses before they really occur (for example, inventory acquired but not sold). Note that the June 28 acquisition of inventory on open account is irrelevant under both the accrual and cash basis.
EXHIBIT 2–43
RAMANATHAN CORPORATION
Analysis of Transactions for June, 20X2
(In Thousands of Dollars)
Assets Liabilities and Stockholders' Equity
Accounts Inven– Accounts Paid–in
Description of Transactions Cash _ + Receivable + tories _ = Payable _ + Capital + Retained Earnings
1. Original investment +100 = +100
2. Acquisition of inventory – 80 +80 =
3a. Sales for cash and credit + 45 +70 = +115 (increase sales revenue)
b. Cost of inventory sold –60 = – 60 (increase cost of
goods sold expense)
4. Acquisition of inventory _ _ +26 = +26 _
+ 65 +70 +46 = +26 +100 + 55
RAMANATHAN CORPORATION
Balance Sheet
June 30, 20X2
Assets _ _ Liabilities and Stockholders' Equity
Liabilities:
Cash $ 65,000 Accounts payable $ 26,000
Accounts receivable 70,000 Stockholders' equity:
Merchandise inventory 46,000 Paid–in capital $100,000
Retained earnings 55,000 155,000
Total $181,000 Total $181,000
2-44 (10 - 15 min.)
1. Criteria i and ii in the footnote relate to the earning of the revenue, and criteria iii and iv relate to its realization. With products licensed to OEMs, there is some question about when the revenue is earned. Microsoft used to regard it as earned when the OEMs shipped it to customers, but a change in licensing makes it possible to regard it as earned when Microsoft ships it to the OEMs. Those revenues that are recognized when payments are received must be ones for which it is not likely enough that the cash will actually be received to satisfy the realization criterion until the cash is in hand.
2. The licensing agreement must have been changed to make the OEMs more responsible for the items after Microsoft ships them. Microsoft has decided not to wait until the OEM delivers the items to customers to regard the revenue as earned; instead, it is deemed earned at the time Microsoft ships it. This will accelerate Microsoft’s recognition of revenues.
3. An item is not material if its omission (or change) will not likely change the decisions of users of Microsoft’s financial statements. This probably means that the amount of accelerated revenue due to the change is so small that it is insignificant compared to total revenues.
2-45 (40-50 min.)
1. See Exhibit 2-45 on the following page.
Transactions 8 to 11 illustrate the culmination of the asset acquisition-asset expiration sequence: that is, most assets are "stored" as "unexpired" or "prepaid" costs that are expected to benefit future operations (inventory, prepaid rent, prepaid insurance and equipment). As these assets are "used up" or "expire", they become expenses or "expired costs".
2. ORTIZ COMPANY
Income Statement
For the Month Ended July 31, 20X2
Sales $200,000
Deduct expenses:
Cost of goods sold $160,000
Rent 5,000
Depreciation 2,000
Insurance 1,000
Total expenses 168,000
Net income $ 32,000
EXHIBIT 2–45
ORTIZ COMPANY
Analysis of Transactions for July, 20X2
(In Thousands of Dollars)
Assets = Liabilities and Stockholder's Equity
Accounts Mer– Pre- Prepaid
Trans– Receiv- chandise Paid Insur- Equip- Note Accounts Paid–in
action Cash + able + Inventory +Rent + ance + ment = Payable + Payable + Capital + Retained earnings _
1. +250 = +250
2. – 60 +60 =
3. – 40 +100 = +60
4. – 24 +24 =
5. – 35 +35 =
6. +190 = +190
7. +30 +170 = +200 (increase sales revenue)
8. –160 = –160 (increase cost of goods)
9. – 5 = – 5 (increase rent expense)
10. – 2 = – 2 (increase depreciation expense)
11. – 1 = – 1 (increase insurance expense)
12. +35 – 35 =
13. –80 _ _ _ _ _ = _ – 80 _ _
Balances
7/31/X2 +76 +135 +65 +55 +23 +98 = +60 +110 +250 +32
2-45 (continued)
3. ORTIZ COMPANY
Balance Sheet
July 31, 20X2
Liabilities and
Assets Stockholders' Equity
Liabilities:
Cash $ 76,000 Note payable $ 60,000
Accounts receivable 135,000 Accounts payable 110,000
Merchandise inventory 65,000 Total liabilities 170,000
Prepaid rent 55,000 Stockholders' equity:
Prepaid insurance 23,000 Paid-in capital 250,000
Equipment 98,000 Retained earnings 32,000
Total stockholders’
Total $452,000 equity 282,000
Total $452,000
2-46 (35-40 min.)
1. See Exhibit 2-46 on the following page.
2. DICHEV COMPANY
Balance Sheet
April 30, 20X2
Liabilities and
Assets Stockholders' Equity
Liabilities:
Cash $ 57,000 Note payable $ 24,000
Accounts receivable 47,000 Accounts payable 5,000
Merchandise inventory 43,000 Total liabilities 29,000
Prepaid rent 4,000 Stockholders' equity:
Equipment and fixtures 35,000 Paid-in capital $150,000
Retained earnings 7,000
Total stk. equity $157,000
Total $186,000 Total $186,000
EXHIBIT 2–46
1. DICHEV COMPANY
Analysis of Transactions for April 20X2
(In Thousands of Dollars)
Assets = Liabilities + Stockholders' Equity
Accounts Mer- Pre- Equip- Note Accounts Paid-
Receiv- chandise paid ment & Pay– Pay- in Retained
Description Cash + able _ + Inventory + Rent _ + Fixtures = able + able + Capital + Earnings
1. Incorporation +150 = +150
2. Purchased
merchandise –45 +45 =
3. Purchased
merchandise +35 = +35
4a. Sales +25 +65 = + 90 (sales revenue)
b. Cost of inventory –37 = – 37 (cost of goods sold
sold expense)
5. Collections +18 –18 =
6. Disbursements to
trade creditors –30 = –30
7. Purchased equipt. –12 +36 = +24
8. Prepaid rent – 6 +6 =
9. Rent expense – 9* = – 9* (rent expense)
10. Wages, etc. –34 = –34 (wages expense)
11. Depreciation – 1 = – 1 (deprec. expense)
12. Rent expense _ _ _ –2 _ = _ _ _ – 2 (rent expense)
Balances,
April 30 20X2 +57 +47 +43 +4 +35 = +24 + 5 +150 + 7
* 10% x $90,000 = $9,000.
2-46 (continued)
DICHEV COMPANY
Income Statement
For the Month Ended April 30, 20X2
Sales (revenue) $90,000
Deduct expenses:
Cost of goods sold $37,000
Wages, salaries and commissions 34,000
Rent ($2,000 + $9,000) 11,000
Depreciation 1,000
Total expenses 83,000
Net Income $ 7,000
3. Most businesses tend to have net losses during their infant months, so Dichev’s ability to show a net income for April is impressive. Indeed, the rate of return on beginning investment is $7,000 ÷ $150,000 = 4.67% per month, or 56% per year. Dichev also has high stockholders’ equity compared to its liabilities, quite high cash balance, and flexibility because most assets are either in cash or will be turned into cash relatively quickly. Many other points can be raised, including the problem of maintaining an "optimum" cash balance so that creditors can be paid neither too quickly nor too slowly. See the next solution also.
2-47 (5-10 min.)
Cash Inflows:
Cash sales $ 25,000
Cash collected from credit customers 18,000
Cash disbursements*: 43,000
Disbursements for merchandise $(75,000)**
Disbursements for rent, wages,
and sales commissions (49,000)***
Total cash disbursements 124,000
Net cash outflow for operations $(81,000)
*Some students will also include the $12,000 cash paid to purchase equipment as a cash outflow. This is consistent with a strict cash-basis of accounting.
*$45,000 + $30,000
*** $6,000 + $9,000 + $34,000
The accrual basis provides a more accurate measure of economic performance. If the two revenue recognition criteria are met (earning and realization), the $90,000 measure of revenue on the accrual basis is preferred to the $43,000 measure of cash receipts for measuring economic performance, and the $83,000 measure of costs is preferred to the $124,000 measure of cash disbursements. The $7,000 net income is a more accurate measure of total accomplishments for April than is the $81,000 net cash used for operating activities.
2-48 (20-35 min.)
This alternative to 2-50 does not include dividends, but 2-50 does.
1. See Exhibit 2-48 on the following page.
2. H. J. HEINZ COMPANY
Statement of Earnings
For the Month Ended May 31, 2003
(In Millions)
Sales $11
Deduct expenses:
Cost of goods sold $3
Selling and administrative expenses 1
Rent and insurance 1
Depreciation 1 6
Net earnings $ 5
H. J. HEINZ COMPANY
Balance Sheet
May 31, 2003
(In Millions)
Liabilities and
Assets Stockholders' Equity
Cash $ 795 Liabilities:
Accounts receivable 1,168 Accounts payable $ 942
Inventories 1,156 Other liabilities 7,088 8,030
Other assets 4,158 Stockholders' equity 1,204
Property, plant and equip. 1,957 Total $9,234
Total $9,234
EXHIBIT 2–48
H. J. HEINZ COMPANY
Analysis of Transactions for May
(In Millions of Dollars)
2-49 (5-10 min.) Amounts are in millions.
Cash Inflows:
Cash sales $ 3
Collections from credit customers 5
8
Cash disbursements:
Payments on account payable $ (2)
Disbursements to prepay rent and insurance (12)
Disbursements for selling and
administrative expenses (1)
Total cash disbursements (15)
Net cash outflow $ ( 7)
The accrual basis provides a more accurate measure of economic performance. If the two revenue recognition criteria are met (earning and realization), the $11 million measure of revenue on the accrual basis is preferred to the $8 million measure of cash receipts for measuring economic performance, and the $6 million measure of costs is preferred to the $15 million measure of cash disbursements. The $5 million net income is a more accurate measure of total accomplishments for May than is the $7 million net cash outflow.
2-50 (25-40 min.)
1. See Exhibit 2-50 on the following page.
2. WM. WRIGLEY JR. COMPANY
Statement of Earnings
For the Month of January, 2003
(In Millions)
Sales $75
Deduct expenses:
Cost of goods sold $45
Selling expenses 29
Depreciation 3
Total expenses 77
Net Loss $ (2)
EXHIBIT 2–50
WM. WRIGLEY JR. COMPANY
Analysis of Transactions for January
(In Millions of Dollars)
Assets = Liabilities and Stockholders' Equity
Property, Divi- Other
Receiv- Inven- Plant, & Other Accts. dends Liabi-
Description Cash + ables + tories + Equip. _ + Assets = Pay. + Pay. + lities + Owners’ Equity
Balance, January 1 +279 +313 +321 + 836 + 359 = +98 +46 +441 +1,523
1a. Sales + 35 + 40 = + 75 (sales revenue)
1b. Cost of inventory – 45 – 45 (cost of goods
sold = sold expense)
2. Collections + 42 – 42 =
3. Depreciation – 3 = – 3 (depreciation
expense)
4. Selling and
administrative (sell &
expense – 24 = – 24 adm. exp.)
5. Selling and
administrative (sell &
expense -5 = – 5 adm. exp.)
6. Reduce liability – 46 _ _ _ _ = _ –46
Balances,
January 31 +286 +311 +276 +833 +354 = +98 + 0 +441 +1,521
2,060 2,060
2-50 (continued)
WM. WRIGLEY JR. COMPANY
Balance Sheet
January 31, 2003
(In Millions)
Liabilities and
Assets Stockholders' Equity
Cash $ 286 Accounts payable $ 98
Receivables 311 Dividends payable 0
Inventories 276 Other liabilities 441
Stockholders’ equity 1,521
Property, plant
and equipment 833
Other assets 354
Total $2,060 Total $2,060
2-51 (35-45 min.)
1. VITALY CORPORATION
Income Statement
For the Year Ended December 31, 20X2
Sales $281,000
Deduct expenses:
Cost of good sold $157,000
Salaries 86,000
Rent 18,000a
Advertising 9,300
Utilities 5,000
Depreciation 5,000
Insurance 1,000b
Office supplies 1,200 282,500
Net Loss $ (1,500)
a $19,500 – $1,500 = $18,000; $1,500 is prepaid rent.
b $ 1,800 – $ 800 = $ 1,000; $800 is unexpired insurance.
2. VITALY CORPORATION
Statement of Retained earnings
For the Year Ended December 31, 20X2
Retained earnings, January 1, 20X2 $18,000
Net loss for 20X2 (1,500)
Remainder $16,500
Cash dividends declared 4,000
Retained earnings, December 31, 20X2 $12,500
2-51 (continued)
3. VITALY CORPORATION
Balance Sheet
December 31, 20X2
Liabilities and
Assets Stockholders' Equity
Cash $14,800 Liabilities:
Accounts receivable 27,400 Accounts payable $ 14,000
Notes receivable 2,500 Notes payable 7,000
Merchandise inventory 61,000 Dividends payable 4,000e
Total liabilities $ 25,000
Prepaid rent 1,500 Stockholders' equity:
Office supplies inventory 800d Paid-in capital $100,000
Unexpired insurance 800 Retained earnings 12,500
Trucks 28,700c Total stockholders' equity $112,500
Total $137,500 Total $137,500
c $33,700 – $5,000 = $28,700
d $2,000 – $1,200 = $800
e $4,000 dividend declared
Note that the $4,200 net income reported by the office manager is incorrect. There is a net loss of $1,500, as shown above. Reconciliation: $4,200 + $1,500 = $5,700 difference, accounted for by changed expense items as follows: $1,000 (b) – $1,500 (a) + $5,000 (c) + $1,200 (d) = $5,700.
2-52 (50-75 min.)
1. See Exhibit 2-52 on the following page.
2. FUNCO SUPPLIES COMPANY
Balance Sheet
December 31, 20X8
Liabilities and
Assets Stockholders' Equity
Cash $ 436,000 Liabilities:
Accounts receivable 650,000 Accounts payable $ 900,000
Merchandise inventory 610,000 Stockholders' equity:
Prepaid rent 56,000 Paid-in capital 300,000
Equipment 80,000 Retained earnings 632,000
Total stockholders' equity 932,000
Total $1,832,000 Total $1,832,000
EXHIBIT 2–52
FUNCO SUPPLIES COMPANY
Analysis of Transaction for 20X8
(In Thousands of Dollars)
Assets = Liabilities and Stockholders' Equity
Accounts Merchandise Prepaid Accounts Paid–in Retained
Transactions Cash + Receivable + Inventory + Rent _ + Equipment = Payable + Capital _ Earnings
Balance,
12/31/X7 + 340 + 400 + 860 +40 +100 = + 800 +300 + 640
a. +1,000 = +1,000
b. + 200 +1,500 = +1,700 (increase sales revenue)
c. –1,250 = –1,250 (increase cost of
goods sold expense)
d1. –40 = – 40 (increase rent expense)
d2. – 84 +84 =
d3.* –28 = – 28 (increase rent expense)
e. –20 = – 20 (increase depreciation
expense)
f. +1,250 –1,250 =
g. – 200 = – 200 (increase wages
expense)
h. – 70 = – 70 (increase misc.
expense)
i. – 900 = – 900
j. – 100 _ _ _ = _ _ – 100 (dividends)**
Balance,
12/31/X8 + 436 + 650 +610 +56 +80 = + 900 +300 + 632
1,832 1,832
* All rent effects for the entire year are shown in three steps as part of the analysis of Transaction d. There are alternative ways of handling this transaction, but the ultimate effects on the accounts would be identical. For instance, Transaction d3 might be shown as a final separate entry after Transaction i or j. The new lease is at a rate of $84 ÷ 12 = $7 per month and four months elapse in 20X8.
** Note that the amount of cash dividends is usually tied to the amount of net income, but not necessarily. The amount and timing of dividends is a separate decision by the board of directors.
2-52 (continued)
FUNCO SUPPLIES COMPANY
Income Statement
For the Year Ended December 31, 20X8
Sales $1,700,000
Deduct expenses:
Cost of goods sold $1,250,000
Rent 68,000*
Depreciation 20,000
Wages 200,000
Miscellaneous 70,000
Total expenses 1,608,000
Net income $ 92,000
*$40,000 for first 8 months plus $28,000 for next 4 months = $68,000. Note that the beginning balance of prepaid rent of $40,000 related to the first 8 months of the year, and therefore, implies a monthly rate of $5,000 and annual rent of $60,000. The payment in 20X8 of $84,000 represents an increase in the rental.
FUNCO SUPPLIES COMPANY
Statement of Retained earnings
For the Year Ended December 31, 20X8
Retained earnings, December 31, 20X7 $640,000
Net income for the year 20X8 92,000
Total $732,000
Cash dividends declared 100,000
Retained earnings, December 31, 20X8 $632,000
2-52 (continued)
FUNCO SUPPLIES COMPANY
Statement of Income and Retained earnings
For the Year Ended December 31, 20X8
Sales $1,700,000
Deduct expenses:
Cost of goods sold $1,250,000
Rent 68,000*
Depreciation 20,000
Wages 200,000
Miscellaneous 70,000
Total expenses 1,608,000
Net income $ 92,000
Retained earnings, Dec. 31, 20X7 640,000
Total $ 732,000
Cash dividends declared 100,000
Retained earnings, Dec. 31, 20X8 $ 632,000
3. Only the balance sheet would be affected. Cash would be $100,000 higher and a $100,000 liability -- Dividends Payable -- would be created. Both accounts would be decreased by $100,000 when the dividend disbursement is made on January 31.
We usually point out that a stockholder is simultaneously a creditor and an owner the minute the board of directors declares a dividend. Of course, the entity is never liable for a dividend until such a declaration occurs.
2-53 (10-15 min.)
This is straightforward. All computations are in millions of dollars:
A = 4,051 – (339 + 975) = 2,737
B = 5,975 – 5,885 = 90
C = 975 + 90 – 51 = 1,014
D = 4,096 –1,014 – 358 = 2,724
2-54 (15-25 min.)
Assets = Liab. + SE
Entity _ Cash _ Receivables* Trucks Payables*
1. Fidelity –120,000 + 120,000 =
Walker +120,000 = +120,000
2. Fidelity + 10,000 – 10,000 =
Walker – 10,000 = – 10,000
3. Time + 90 = + 90
Paperman – 90 + 90 =
4. Postal Serv. (millions) – 10 +10 =
GSA (millions) + 10 –10 =
5. US Treas. +100,000 = +100,000
Lockheed –100,000 +100,000 =
6. Safeway + 11 = +11
Simon – 11 + 11 =
7. Sears +100 – 100 =
Debreu –100 = –100
8. American Express +1,000 = +1,000
Sharpe –1,000 +1,000** =
9. Bank +600 = +600
Kennedy –600 =
+600***
10. United +400 = +400
Peecher –400 +400 =
2-54 (continued)
* We are using catch-all titles called "Receivables" and "Payables" here. Obviously, each entity might use highly specific descriptions of the type of receivable or payables. For example, Safeway's use of "cash deposits" implies amounts payable. Similarly, United's collection of cash for tickets in advance and Time's collection of a subscription collected in advance are basically payables that must be extinguished either by cash refunds or by supplying the flight services and magazines.
** Sharpe may prefer to show the travelers checks as a separate asset. Many people would think of travelers checks as cash or a "cash equivalent."
*** Kennedy (and nearly everyone) would ordinarily label a cash deposit in a bank as Cash or Cash in Bank. Strictly speaking, Cash in Bank is really a form of receivable from a bank; however, it is almost never labeled as such.
2-55 (20-25 min.)
The following statements follow the format used by McDonald's. Obviously, various alternative formats are possible:
1. (a) McDONALD'S CORPORATION
Consolidated Statement of Income
For the Year Ended December 31, 2002
(In Millions of Dollars)
Revenues $15,406
Deduct expenses:
Food and paper expense 3,917
Payroll and employee benefits 3,078
Selling, general, and administrative expenses 1,713
Occupancy and other operating expenses 3,745
Franchise expenses 840
Interest and other non-operating expenses 549
Total expenses 13,842
Income before provision for income taxes* 1,564
Provision for income taxes* 670
Net income $ 894
* This is the nomenclature used by McDonald's.
2-55 (continued)
(b) McDONALD'S CORPORATION
Statement of Retained Earnings
For the Year Ended December 31, 2002
(In Millions of Dollars)
Retained earnings, December 31, 2001 $18,608
Net income for the year 894
Cash dividends (298)
Retained earnings, December 31, 2002 $19,204
2. The cash dividend is small compared to the amounts for net income and retained earnings. It is 33% of the net income. This conservative dividend policy may reflect management's intention to finance growth mainly from internal sources.
2-56 (15-25 min.)
The following approximates Dell’s statements. Student may use other acceptable formats.
1. DELL
Statement of Income
For the Year Ended February 1, 2003
(In Millions)
Total revenues $35,404
Costs and expenses:
Cost of revenues * 29,055
Other expenses 3,322
Income before income taxes 3,027
Provision for income taxes 905
Net earnings $ 2,122
*Also called cost of goods sold
2. DELL
Statement of Retained Earnings
For the Year Ended February 1, 2003
(In Millions)
Retained earnings, February 1, 2002 $ 1,364
Net earnings 2,122
Dividends declared 0
Retained earnings, February 1, 2003 $3,486
2-57 (10 min.)
Because Balkan Airlines is committed to selling its assets and using the proceeds to pay off creditors, the appropriate valuation of its assets is the market price Balkan expects to receive for them. Because they will no longer continue to be used in the way anticipated when they were purchased, the original purchase price less accumulated depreciation is no longer relevant.
An operating airline would continue to use the book value, original cost less accumulated depreciation, for its assets. In contrast, an airline in liquidation should use the current market value for its assets.
2-58 (20-35 min.)
The solutions are underlined in the following table:
Computations follow:
1. FedEx:
Price = $2.79 x 22.9 = $63.89 per share
Dividends = $2.79 x .07 = $.20 per share
Dividend yield: = $.40 ÷ $63.89 = 0.3%
2-58 (continued)
2. UPS:
Earnings = $54.50 ÷ 25.6 = $2.13 per share
Dividend = $54.50 x .014 = $.76 per share
Dividend payout = $.76 ÷ $2.13 = 36%
3. Deutche Post:
Dividends = .26 x €1.42 = € 0.37 per share
P-E = €15.00 ÷ €1.42 = 10.6
Dividend yield = €0.37 ÷ €15.00 = 2.5%
Highest dividend yield is Deutche Post.
Highest dividend payout is UPS.
Lowest P-E is Deutche Post.
2. This information is not sufficient to answer these questions. How rapidly are prices and earnings growing? Value investors who look for “under-priced” stocks might be attracted to Deutche Post’s low P-E. Others might like the low dividend payout for FedEx in the belief that it means FedEx is reinvesting all of its earnings profitably. The case for UPS would rest on its high P-E as a proxy for perceived growth.
2-59
The solutions are underlined:
Computations follow:
1. Shell:
P-E = €41.95 ÷ € 2.87 = 14.6
Dividend yield = € 1.72 ÷ €41.95 = 4.1%
Dividend Payout = € 1.72 ÷ € 2.87 = 60%
2. ExxonMobil:
Earnings = $39.30 ÷ 17.6 = $2.23
Dividends = $39.30 x .023 = $0.90
Dividend payout: = $0.90 ÷ $2.23= 40%
3. ChevronTexaco:
Price = 28.9 x $3.10 = $89.59
Dividend = .85 x $3.10 = $2.64
Dividend yield = $2.64 ÷ $89.59 = 2.9%
Highest dividend yield is Shell.
Highest dividend payout is ChevronTexaco.
Lowest P-E is Shell.
2-59 (continued)
This information is not sufficient to answer questions about investments. How rapidly are prices and earnings growing? Value investors who look for “under-priced” stocks might be attracted to Shell’s low P-E. Others might like the low dividend payout for ExxonMobil in the belief that it means ExxonMobil is reinvesting more of its earnings profitably. The case for ChevronTexaco would rest on its high P-E as a proxy for perceived growth.
2-60 (10 min.)
The revenue recognition practices of KSR were much too aggressive. Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) require the risks and benefits of ownership to pass to the buyer and the collection of cash to be reasonably certain before revenue is recorded. Often these conditions are satisfied at the time of shipment of the product. However, for KSR this was not the case. When a sale is contingent on the winning of a grant, or depends on the future delivery of upgrades, revenue should not be recorded. Similarly, if the sale depends on the actions of a third party who has no obligation to the purchaser, there is too much uncertainty to record the revenue.
KSR had very good reason to believe that the shipment of computers was not sufficient for the recognition of revenues. By aggressively recording the revenue, KSR violated ethical standards that require adherence to GAAP and full and accurate disclosures of financial information. The drop of the stock price of KSR after complete disclosure was made provided evidence that the original information was misleading to investors.
KSR may also have violated the law. A series of shareholder suits were filed in late 1993 alleging that KSR executives either knew or should have known that the company’s revenue recognition policies were inappropriate. In November of 1993 the company’s auditor withdrew its report on KSR’s 1992 financial statements.
Beyond the problems of revenue recognition, there were charges of insider trading by top executives. President and CEO Henry Burkhardt III confirmed Wall Street analysts’ forecast of high earnings and two weeks later sold $1 million of his KSR stock. In November of 1993 Mr. Burkhardt and other responsible executives were fired.
2-61 (60 min. or more)
This exercise has three main purposes:
1. Learn how to find financial information about companies.
2. Compute ratios.
3. Determine reasons for ratios to vary across companies.
We believe the third purpose is especially important. Finding information and computing ratios is mechanical, but finding reasons for variations in ratios across companies requires much thought and reasoning. Doing this in teams is extremely helpful; ideas can build on one another, and students can see how other students think through the issue. It also allows students with more experience and knowledge of business practices to share this knowledge with those with less experience.
If time permits, we suggest discussing the second requirement in class. Groups will find it informative to learn the conclusions reached by other groups.
2-62 (15-30 min.)
Each solution will be unique and will change each year. The purpose of this problem is to focus on the income statement, and statement of retained earnings.
2–63 (10-15 min.) (in thousands except per share amounts)
1. Net revenues = $4,075,522; net earnings = $268,346.
2. Increase in retained earnings = $1,069,683 - $801,337 = $268,346.
This is the same as the net earnings. Thus, Starbucks must not have paid any dividends in fiscal 2003. This is also evident fro examination of the Statements of Shareholders’ Equity.
3. Earnings per share = $268,346 ÷ 390,753 = $0.69 per share
This amount is shown at the bottom of Starbucks’ income statement. Also shown is diluted earnings per share, which is beyond the scope of our discussion at this point.
Price-Earnings ratio = $29 ÷ $0.69 = 42
4. The Starbucks P-E ratio is nearly triple the average P-E in the market. Thus, investors must think that Starbucks’ income will grow quite quickly in the future.
2-64 (30-40 min.)
NOTE TO INSTRUCTOR. This solution is based on the web site as it was in late 2004. Be sure to examine the current web site before assigning this problem, as the information there may have changed.
1. Outback recognizes revenues from normal sales when it performs the services. For franchises, it recognizes revenues when it has performed all its material obligations under terms of the franchise contract.
2. Outback recognizes a liability for unearned revenues when it sells gift certificates. It is a liability on the balance sheet because it is an obligation to provide future services for which it will receive no more cash.
3. Outback recognizes revenues from restaurant sales, the largest source of revenues, and lumps together all other sales. In the Management’s Discussion and Analysis, revenue is segregated by: (1) Domestic Outback Steakhouses, (2) International Outback Steakhouses, (3) Carrabbas Italian Grills, and (4) other restaurants, which include Fleming Prime Steakhouse, Roys, Lee Roy Selmans, Bonefish Grills, and Cheeseburger in Paradise.
4. Outback’s cost of sales equals food and beverage costs. Labor and other restaurant operating costs are listed separately.
5. Like all large companies, Outback uses the accrual method. This is perhaps most clear from the use of the terms “accrued expenses” and “unearned income” among the liabilities on the balance sheet. It is also evident from the use of “revenues” rather than cash receipts and “expenses” rather than cash outlays.
6. Outback is clearly a profit-seeking organization. This is evident from the income statement, where it shows not only net income but also earnings per common share. On the balance sheet, it is evident from the stockholders’ equity section. It is also clear from the presence of income tax expenses.