• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast two models of HRM, one of which must be the Harvard model beer et al In contrast I will be using the Harvard Framework for HRM and the Burke-Litwin model.

Extracts from this document...


HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT AND ITS ENVIRONMENT COMPARE AND CONTRAST TWO MODELS OF HRM, ONE OF WHICH MUST BE THE HARVARD MODEL BEER ET AL In contrast I will be using the Harvard Framework for HRM and the Burke-Litwin model. I will begin with a brief introduction of both models followed by the contrast between the models and in conclusion will be discussing how either of the models will best prepare an organisation for change. THE HARVARD FRAMEWORK FOR HRM (BEER ET AL): Source: Google images The Harvard model takes in to account all major stakeholders within a particular environment such as HRM and establishes how these would need to be recognised and taken in to account when setting up policies and procedures. The model highlights how the different segments of the environment will effect the HRM operations. For example government legislations would have to be taken in to account and would define legally required procedures, which would become the HR policies such as the HR flow type and work systems, which would then affect issues such as competence as staff may need training and development to meet the policy needs. This would then have a long term effect on the performance, well- being and development of the individuals and the company which would in turn affect other stakeholders and situational factors. ...read more.


The Litwin model goes on to take in to account the transactional elements which are: - Management practices - Structure - System policies and procedures - Work unit climate - Motivation - Tasks and individual skills - Individual needs and values All the areas are key to the change as they will define the overall success of the change. With regards to best preparing the organisation for change the areas can be planned for and thoroughly analysed prior to the actual move. Looking in to new management practices would prepare the BBC for the new culture it wants to implement for example as mentioned in the case study the open plan work area with at "hot desk" policy would need new management protocol thus changing the management practices. The hierarchy would also be greatly changed not only due to the job cuts and redeployment but the development of current staff in the new premises would also change the current structure. In the case study it is mentioned that there has been an introduction of initiatives such as the leadership and development schemes focusing on creating better leadership and management which will empower more staff and create a different structure to what the staff have been used to prior to the move. System policies and procedures are always being adapted to suit the changes in the external environment. ...read more.


As the BBC is a public company it is imperative that it reflects the diversity of the country's nationals as they are paying their license fees just like every other individual however can see that the output is not as supportive of the communities. Culture is a key area that will retain and develop diversity as it will be the main link between the staff and their operating environment. If the culture is supportive then the BBC could easily achieve a diverse workforce however as the previous staff have been alienated to diversity at the BBC the management would need a specific strategy to curb and problems caused from other staff not accepting of change. CONCLUSION In conclusion: diversity and relocation encompass a key area of the change process. There are many different change management models that can be used, however I found the Litwin model appropriate to analyse and plan the change process. From the case study it does seem that the BBC has the change under control however in reality there would be many more problems and obstacles that the management would have to overcome. On one last not I do feel a change could be made to the Litwin model to allow for unforeseen circumstances and problems that can and may occur such as failed technology as this could be detrimental to the whole change policy. Unforeseen circumstances would allow for acknowledgement of high risk problem occurrence and can help management plan in contingency to ensure a better quality of the process. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Human Resource Management section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Human Resource Management essays

  1. Critically compare and contrast 'hard' and 'soft' models of human resource management.

    and it can be compared with McGregor's Theory Y. This is the notion that 'man will exercise self-direction and self-control in the service of objectives to which he is committed' (McGregor, 1960, p. 326 cited in Truss et al, 1997). This theory leads to the believe that if an employee is committed to the company for which he works,

  2. No one best style of leadership

    However, as discussed earlier, they later found out that perhaps he was not the best leader to be managing the innovating stage of the business. The implementor is the second type of leader, with a need for being autocratic and influencing situations.

  1. Human Resource Management: Development, Activities, Planning and Recruitment

    offer first) and is given by asking the person to place his/her hand on the guide's arm just above the elbow. The guide leads by walking a half step ahead of the person. A blind person's guide dog must also be allowed to enter the interview room.

  2. Cape Breton Wallcoverings - HRM analysis

    However design department and production department had needs that were fairly unique to the industry. Job simplification and industrial engineering Cape Breton Wall coverings exercised job simplification while designed the jobs. Because of this the jobs were divided into clearly defined and specialized tasks.

  1. International Leadership & HRM The effective leadership model

    Leader is a powerful source, which can affect employee behavior. Leaders in an organization are vital factors determine the success or failure. Cohen (2010) points out that the best leaders always know the employees who are working for them and how to motivate them to better complete their work and perform more than expected.

  2. The link between national culture and leadership style. Can one expect discrepancies between the ...

    The individualism-collectivism dimension propound that high individualism may lead to a more competitive type of leadership, whereas high collectivism may lead to a more consultative behaviour. The masculinity dimension suggests that high masculinity means-a country experiences a higher degree of gender differentiation.

  1. Is HRM a worthwhile investment for an SME ?

    the HRM practices and neglects the employee view as to the effectiveness of implementation (Kinnie et al 2005); and that it is too simplistic and unlikely to be implementable in reality (Purcell 1999). The alternative to best practice in the world of strategic HRM is the ?fit? approach, again the name gives a reasonable suggestion as to the methodology.

  2. Discuss the main factors and issues that the Sparkle corporation took into consideration when ...

    As each factory differentiated their HRM approaches, a more effective cross-company learning was structured, aiming to make best practice management in one factory be easily transferrable to others. Sparkle has run a policy of massively reducing the staff of head office in the acquired companies to eliminate national loyalty.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work