• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Critically evaluate the extent to which academic research enables practitioners to meet todays HRD challenges

Extracts from this document...


Criticall evaluate the extent to which academic research enables practitioners to meet todays HRD challenges ________________ ?HRD practice does not come close to what we know from sound theory? (Swanson, R.A. 2001) This paper will evaluate the extent to which academic research into Human Resource Development (HRD) practices enables practitioners to meet the challenges they are presented with in today?s fast-changing workplace. By considering the issue from various adverse perspectives, using a range of academic evidence, it will give a rounded critical evaluation of the topic. It will also critique the potential benefits and limitations of using academic research to the practical development of HRD policies and strategies intended to meet corporate objectives at organisational, group and individual levels. The theoretical HRD research upon which practical applications are based will be considered in terms of both findings and methodology. An evaluation will also be given of the current debate in relation to the concept of the ?theory-practice gap? and developing on this a discussion of the nature of academic research. To what extent does academic research enable, if it is meant to at all, the work of HRD practitioners? But also if the position is taken that academic research is not there to enable the work of HRD practitioners what is its purpose? Following on from this, the paper will deal with specific HRD challenges in the current workplace and how theory is, or is not, useful in considering these issues. Firstly, as necessary groundwork the issue raised by the lack of clarity in respect to a usable definition of HRD needs to be addressed. It is widely recognised that HRD is a discipline with a background in other fields such as sociology, psychology, education, organisational behaviour and other social sciences. ...read more.


?Just as our colleagues in the world of practice are faced with building credibility with senior line management, HRD scholars working within an academic setting are confronted with building credibility with deans and senior academic officers? (2005, p.112). And the ability to build this credibility lies on different foundations. HRD scholars build their credibility not on the practicality of the research they produce but on the rigor with which it is conducted and the respect and usage it gains from others in the academic community. With the possibility that a piece of academic HRD research may gain significant acclaim for its scholar, while at the same time having no impact on the world of the practitioner a strong one, what is the incentive to produce work designed to enable practitioners to meet real organisational problems? It is in creating this world that Bennis and O?Toole (2005), cited in Markides (2011) can argue that business schools have lost their way in the past 30 years by focusing too much on doing ?scientific? research that has no real practical value. According to Swanson (1997) theory, research, development and practice should go together to form a cycle that allows ideas to be gradually refined as they evolve from concepts into practices and from practices into concepts. This cycle allows for the different elements of the process of constructing HRD thought to be seen as completely interrelated. The union of the research and practitioner spaces also creates an impression of equilibrium between the two and suggests the need for all to inform each other so that the HRD profession as a whole can be enhanced. What are then some of the specific challenges facing today?s HRD practitioner and to what extent can research be seen to be enabling them to be met. ...read more.


This can lead to academic research into HRD becoming something of an exercise in ?preaching to the choir?. The result being that HRD does not gain the understanding or impact that it perhaps deserves. McGoldrick, citing Jacobs (2000), does not see this as an issue and indeed states, ?the emergence of HRD-related journals has presented an opportunity to define the field on basis of theory and practice. Yorks, citing Torraco, pointed to the belief that despite the acknowledgement of the issue of the research ? practice link being one of the most significant challenges for HRD ?the gap between research and practice has been widening, not closing?and successfully bridging this gap goes to the heart of our Academy?s commitment to improving practice through sound theory and research? (2005, p.111). While accepting that there is a need to ?bridge? the gap between research and practice it should also be acknowledged that they are two different things and it is for the benefit of the HRD profession that they remain so. As Yorks states, ?the tension between the worlds of theory and practice can work to the advantage of both.? (2005, p.112). HRD is a relatively young discipline and there are significant challenges to its future. Failing to acknowledge these challenges will run the risk of marginalising HRD within organisations and seeing the advancements made since the days of the ?training department? being lost. Unless HRD practitioners with the assistance of academic researchers can provide a professional service that is more focused on delivering business outcomes in a measurable and time critical way and supported by a stronger theoretical basis HRD risks being side-lined within the organisation. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Human Resource Management section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Human Resource Management essays

  1. Reflexivity. Critically evaluating my learning logs I will determine why students and professionals need ...

    I have never been confronted to trade unions and I do not know exactly how it works in practice. I took this as an opportunity to think how having a trade union in my organisation would change the way we manage conflicts.

  2. Human Resource Management: Development, Activities, Planning and Recruitment

    awarding body approves funding for a named individual to work on a particular piece of research and the grant is dependent on that individual's contribution. 6. When employing temporary or casual staff on a short-term basis the principles of good practice outlined in this policy should be followed.

  1. Training & Development - The challenges associated with introducing e-learning within organisations

    But according to Sloan, virtually all public higher education institutions, as well as a vast majority of private, for-profit institutions, now offer online classes. By contrast, only about half of private, nonprofits schools offer them. The Sloan report, based on a poll of academic leaders, says that students generally appear

  2. HRM best practise case study. Research into HRM at a branch of Barclays ...

    and suddenly employees decides to leave then it is a major loss to the organization plus "Layoffs put important strategic assets on the street for the competition to employ" (Pfeffer 1998 p66). Sometimes even temporary workers and used to protect the overall workforce (Marchingston & Wilkinson, 2002).

  1. Part A of this report will examine my learning styles, preferences, highlight any areas ...

    based on the four stages and developed the Learning Style Questionnaire (LSQ) to measure them (Honey and Mumford, 1986). The LSQ results are calculated by splitting the questions into the four learning styles and the highest score is determined to be your preferred learning style.

  2. What can organisational learning, and the search for the learning organisation, offer to companies ...

    suggested it was a process of thought attempted to improve the actions of an organisation by developing knowledge and understanding. The authors, however, do acknowledge the problem of distinguishing learning from change which can occur spontaneously and not as a result of design.

  1. On-the-Job Training - Practice and limitations in the hospitality field

    That means the level of knowledge will be the same between trainees and trainers. It will be good news for the trainees undoubtedly. However, trainers may not be happy at this moment. The reason is that, the trainees are having the same level of knowledge with the trainers.

  2. International management. This essay aims to discuss challenges, which international teams have to ...

    The theory has the objective of improving efficiency and productivity. The aforementioned definitions show that it is not easy to find one common definition of the term management. It depends on the context and situation in which it is used.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work